Unofficial Preview Changes V Sydney (Cloke, JDG in & White, Schazza, Maynard emergencies, see team in OP)

[Pie in the Sky]

Then why was he Subbed and Reported to have a Injury

What? I agree he was probably playing sore, just saying there's no denying he struggled for whatever reason.

 

[TradeDraft]

What? I agree he was probably playing sore, just saying there's no denying he struggled for whatever reason.

Well I have found the last few weeks. The Midfield outside of Swan and Pendles have been down. Espcially at Ruck Contests

 

[Wooljay]

Well I have found the last few weeks. The Midfield outside of Swan and Pendles have been down. Espcially at Ruck Contests

Our centre clearance work and stoppages have been putrid for a while.

Crispy has been solid, but need more out of Adams and Greenwood imo.

 

[orion21]

hearing goldsack will play as well as cloke. who goes out? Source....some lady from Collingwood on the phone trying to sell me a raffle ticket LOL

 

[wello]

Can't see the point of bringing back the Sack or the Seed. Both now have finite ceilings on their ability to contribute to the team's fortunes. I would rather leave players like Marsh, Scharenburg, Maynard and even (gulp) Sinclair in the team than play either of these guys.

Couldn't agree with you more, but that's the way I reckon Bucks will go...

 

[Somebody]

White on the plane.

Doesn't mean he's in the 22 of course;

was Witts onboard too?

 

[Old Spice]

This would have to be one of the toughest team sheets to guess about this year. That's a good thing. #depth

 

[didaksrightfoot]

Id bring in both Cloke and White... Moore to come out for this game, not sure who else comes out. (if Adams is out, id replace him with JDG)

A tall FWD line of Cloke-Reid-White... With White backing up Grundy in the ruck...and having both Cloke and White doing a lot of roaming up the wings, with Reid staying home at FF. (basically what we did with Gault in the lineup early - just a big improvement with Reid)

 

[CFC2010]

hearing goldsack will play as well as cloke. who goes out? Source....some lady from Collingwood on the phone trying to sell me a raffle ticket LOL

Goldsack must have photos of Bucks if that is true!

 

[Mavs13]

hearing goldsack will play as well as cloke. who goes out? Source....some lady from Collingwood on the phone trying to sell me a raffle ticket LOL

Did you buy the tickets?
YES - must be true
NO - giving you a lie

 

[lenny20]

Why all the "out: Moore" calls? I wouldn't be surprised to see us structure up with Cloke, Reid, Moore and White all playing. Yes, they're all tall KPF types, but they're all pretty damn mobile, too, so I can't see it encumbering our forward line too much. Especially with Moore and White - there aren't many more agile big men in the game than those two.

HF: White - Cloke - Fasolo
F: Elliott - Reid - Moore

That's a little bit exciting, for mine.

 

[The Magnificent Seven]

I'm going to go out on a limb and say

IN: Cloke, De Goey
OUT: Adams, Maynard

Why not Moore ye ask? Because he's going to be able to rotate through backline if need be (even with Reid) and give us some aerial assistance if the Swans start bombing them in. Even if Buddy isn't up and about there is still enough tall timber to cause us headaches and I don't know that Frost/Brown can hold the fort by themselves

 

[MagpieJoel]

Prob too tall for the MCG let alone the SCG.

 

[iGNITER]

HF: White - Cloke - Fasolo
F: Elliott - Reid - Moore

That's a little bit exciting, for mine.

I would love to see that.

 

[BC__]

Why all the "Moore: out" calls? I wouldn't be surprised to see us structure up with Cloke, Reid, Moore and White all playing. Yes, they're all tall KPF types, but they're all pretty damn mobile, too, so I can't see it encumbering our forward line too much. Especially with Moore and White - there aren't many more agile big men in the game than those two.

HF: White - Cloke - Fasolo
F: Elliott - Reid - Moore

That's a little bit exciting, for mine.

 

[jmac70]

Out Moore, Frost,
In- White Karnezis.

Patty K deserves to come in, cops a hell of a raw deal on here i reckon, can't do much more at VFL level really.
White, purely as it's against Sydney, if that's not enough to motivate him to a great game then nothing is.

Moore could stay in, not fussed either way but Frost has been going backwards and quickly as the year has worn on, confidence looks shagged and seems to be in two minds about positioning far too often, defensively he has cost us massively lately.
I like the kid but he needs a spell.

I liked PK's game too but not sure he will come in. If Adams misses I think they will go for JDG or Kennedy.

 

[LukeH10]

White in the side
"Drop him" "delist him"
White out of the side
"We need him" "play him Bucks"

I must admit I'd bring him back in this week also but I didn't necessarily want him dropped in the first place.

 

[Ketchup]

White in the side
"Drop him" "delist him"
White out of the side
"We need him" "play him Bucks"

I must admit I'd bring him back in this week also but I didn't necessarily want him dropped in the first place.

Most people don't look at the structure but instead look at player deficiencies. In other words, they need to see the result of someone out of the side to realise it is the wrong decision, in which case it generally turns to the coach is a fool and not "I was wrong"

 

[didaksrightfoot]

Why all the "out: Moore" calls? I wouldn't be surprised to see us structure up with Cloke, Reid, Moore and White all playing. Yes, they're all tall KPF types, but they're all pretty damn mobile, too, so I can't see it encumbering our forward line too much. Especially with Moore and White - there aren't many more agile big men in the game than those two.

HF: White - Cloke - Fasolo
F: Elliott - Reid - Moore

That's a little bit exciting, for mine.

Yeah i cant see that working out well at all.
White and Moore may be mobile for "bigs" but they are still bigs, and wont be able to manage the mobility of guys like Elliot, Fas and Blair.

I would be happy with either White or Moore, but right now rate White the better player - by a fair distance. Moore clearly has a lot of potential and will get better, but other than a good quarter against the Dogs he hasnt shown to be a consistent AFL contributor right now. (which is not an indictment - given its season 1 for a KPP... And that he has been doing a lot of things right so that he can still play a role out there). I would play our absolute best side available against Sydney - which IMO includes White, (if we win, we are still a reasonable chance for the 8) but then if we lose then happy to turn the focus to 2016

 

[NT.Thunder]

I'll just back whatever Scodog10 brings to the table in T-Minus 100 minutes

 

[orion21]

Did you buy the tickets?
YES - must be true
NO - giving you a lie[/QUOTE


LOL yes I did so hope

 

[mattys123]

I'll just back whatever Scodog10 brings to the table in T-Minus 100 minutes

100 minutes? What's the use of having an inside source if it's only 20 minutes early.

 

[NT.Thunder]

100 minutes? What's the use of having an inside source if it's only 20 minutes early.

Agreed - but maybe we'll upgrade on Scodog10 this trade period but atm, he's all we got!

But we do love him - but not in that sort of way - not that's there's anything wrong with that........

 

[mattys123]

It's ok people, relax, Jono Marsh spotted at training.

 

[Apex36]

hearing goldsack will play as well as cloke. who goes out? Source....some lady from Collingwood on the phone trying to sell me a raffle ticket LOL

Hope she's wrong. Goldsack was shithouse in the VFL last week.