Changes Vs Melbourne

[RichosGuns]

OUT: Cartlege, Riewoldt

IN: Pattison, Rance

Simple, Cartlege isn't as good as Pattison around the ground while Reiwoldt has done SFA for the last month. Play Schultz up foward or on th wing and give Alex a taste. He gives excellent rebound from defence and has size and hance wouldn't be beaten in one-on-one contests against players like mark johnson (cough thurstfield cough)

 

[Bojangles17]

OUT : Riewoldt, needs a break
IN : Gourdis, left field I know, but showed something today in the Front half

 

[_RT_]

If the finals are gone I'm tipping 2 changes Tivendale and Hyde in for farewell games.

If finals are still a chance then I tipping, Edwards & Riewoldt out Polo & Rance in.

 

[emperor]

Edwards out?? I thought he was pretty good today.

 

[polakthetiger]

R22...No Change.

Maybe Rance for Jack (he is right to play finals for the Burgers right?)...then Rance gets a taste. Play Schulz forward and feed him all day and try to get a bag for trade value.

 

[Tigerland]

If McMahon isn't dropped in favour of Polo after a game like that then the selection panel are taking the piss.

Everything he did turned to crap. He was undisciplined. His skills are laughable.

Why he was left on the ground for so long amazed me.

Poor Coaching.

 

[_RT_]

Edwards out?? I thought he was pretty good today.

Just seemed like for every good thing he did he did something to undo it. 2 that reall stood out were the missed opportunity from the square & the flick back over his head to a Freo player in the last got caught a couple of times trying to take the play on. Sometimes things you do in the last quarter are the things that the coach remembers come selection.

 

[getthefooty]

If the finals are gone I'm tipping 2 changes Tivendale and Hyde in for farewell games.

If finals are still a chance then I tipping, Edwards & Riewoldt out Polo & Rance in.

Surely Hyde doesn't need a farewell game? Players that are going to get delisted usually don't get a farewell game do they?

 

[emperor]

Just seemed like for every good thing he did he did something to undo it. 2 that reall stood out were the missed opportunity from the square & the flick back over his head to a Freo player in the last got caught a couple of times trying to take the play on. Sometimes things you do in the last quarter are the things that the coach remembers come selection.

Funny thing is RT I only remember the good start to the match he had I'd forgotten about the brain fades he had. I still don't think he should be dropped though.

BTW have you got you're TW hat on or your Realistic Tiger hat on....is that what you think could happen or what your selection policy would be?

 

[Crumden]

Reiwoldts defensive work in the forward line was very good today. Often breaks packs to allow other forwards a chance and applies a lot of pressure to keep the ball in. Some of you need to pay a lot more attention to some of the things he does when he doesn't have the ball.

 

[bushranger58]

Totally agree with McMahon being dropped in favour of Polo. It did seemed like when he made a right decision he then made a bigger blunder making all the work he did before look worthless.

 

[_RT_]

Funny thing is RT I only remember the good start to the match he had I'd forgotten about the brain fades he had. I still don't think he should be dropped though.

BTW have you got you're TW hat on or your Realistic Tiger hat on....is that what you think could happen or what your selection policy would be?

Just think thats what could happen, with the way the selection panel have done things this year who knows what could happen next week. Did hear Wallace after the match though say if we're a chance the they'll try and get Brown up, if we're done then Brown wont play. Makes me think Brown is gone for the year.

 

[TIGER03]

OUT : McMahon - say no more after today
Morton - very selfish, needs to become more team oriented.
Edwards - has a dip but wastes too many opportunities.
Cartledge - not up to it
IN : Collins meyer polo pattison. all deserve to be playing senior football, and would add much needed run.

 

[krustyman]

Out: Riewoldt, Edwards. Connors

 

[Up em tiger boyz]

If browny is fit id say hed come back in

 

[polakthetiger]

Reiwoldts defensive work in the forward line was very good today. Often breaks packs to allow other forwards a chance and applies a lot of pressure to keep the ball in. Some of you need to pay a lot more attention to some of the things he does when he doesn't have the ball.

Interesting...I wasn't at the game but, I was thinking the exact opposite...It seemed to me some of his second efforts and attack on the ball were ordinary. But since he is just a kid, not having a go, just thought he could have gone a bit harder on a few occasions I saw. Just seemed a bit lost today IMO.

 

[Bojangles17]

Interesting...I wasn't at the game but, I was thinking the exact opposite...It seemed to me some of his second efforts and attack on the ball were ordinary. But since he is just a kid, not having a go, just thought he could have gone a bit harder on a few occasions I saw. Just seemed a bit lost today IMO.

its a pity that Hughes has only just come back and doesnt seem to be setting the world on fire as Id love to give im another go, JR is struggling

 

[db26]

guys relax there wont be many changes at all if any i know we didnt play well today but the main thing is we got the points today.Why play rance for nothing wrong with our backline keep him there for 2009 and bulk him up.Yes riewolt has struggled of late but at the moment theres not many options up forward at coburg since hughes has gone down.I though patto gone for the year

 

[TimeFor11]

No way should we drop McMahon it is crazy talk he had by far his worst game for the club no doubt but doesnt change his weeks prior to it. He can be up and down but is in our best 22.

JR chased well today but when he got it wasnt great so I wouldnt mind seeing Rance in.

 

[boodsyboy]

Krustyman are you on Drugs NO WAY drop Conners

 

[Dez!]

Just chuck in all of your out of form players, we can play them straight into form.

Need some assurance? Just watch our game against Port, played Peter Burgoyne into some ripper form.

 

[sante]

No change unless Brown is ready and in that case, Connors will go out.

Patto for Cartledge would be good too.

 

[krustyman]

doubt cartledge would be dropped. graham should be consider before patto, he is a far better ruck, and deserves a game more than patto.

 

[RichosGuns]

doubt cartledge would be dropped. graham should be consider before patto, he is a far better ruck, and deserves a game more than patto.

clearly you didnt see the coburg game today in which they both played. needless to say, patto>angus

 

[PHX]

Out:
McMahon (OMIT)
Cartlege (OMIT)

Edwards (Back to Coburg, only because he needs one more game to qualify for VFL finals I believe)

In:
Meyer (For McMahon)
Pattison (For Cartlege)
Polo (For Edwards)