Game Day Collingwood v Carlton, MCG Friday 28 July, 7.50pm

[Sweeetleftfoot]

I hope we aren't expecting a win tonight against the scum, I mean, they have beaten 4 of the worst sides in the comp and a Port that came with guns but no ammo, we should be afraid

 

[3rdMan]

I think it's the wrong way to look at it. Anyone who's going to come on and consistently have a big impact in a quarter and a half should be in the starting 22. The tactical sub comes on to play a role, allowing us to change the balance or dynamic and give some extra rotation. It'll be the last runner picked. It'll be a runner, because Maynard and WHE can play a tall role, but the talls can't play the small roles.

May be right. Given the number of times we've had to make a charge in the last, I wouldn't be surprised for a Hill, or other attacking impact player, to be sub though. Someone who can have an impact playing a full game but too often either doesn't or for too few moments. As a sub he has the advantage of coming on when the oppo is tired and when we need to make a run - assuming not through injury - all year this has been the most attacking part of our game, injecting a pacy, attacking player at that time could be useful.

 

[sr36]

May be right. Given the number of times we've had to make a charge in the last, I wouldn't be surprised for a Hill, or other attacking impact player, to be sub though. Someone who can have an impact playing a full game but too often either doesn't or for too few moments. As a sub he has the advantage of coming on when the oppo is tired and when we need to make a run - assuming not through injury - all year this has been the most attacking part of our game, injecting a pacy, attacking player at that time could be useful.

Agree. My point though is that you're still picking what you consider to be the best starting 22, but then when it comes down to the 23rd you may think one person is more suited than another for a reason like that. Eg - I think WHE is a lock for the 23, because if he doesn't make the 22, he's a better sub than others due to his running, flexibility and the range of roles he can play. But you're not going to play him as sub if you think he improves the first 22 - he'll be in the first 22.

Ultimately, I think it'll be Markov as our sub in finals - if we're all fit - as the defence will probably already have Noble, Maynard, IQ and probably Crisp (in Daicos role) plus the 3 talls. And thus he's surplus to the best 22.

 

[No SPIN]

They've beaten Hawthorn, Freo, West Coast and a Port Adelaide side that rested like 8 players.

The hype at the moment for them is laughable.

And it will be those facts commentators will use to down play our victory if we smash them.

 

[No SPIN]

Who's that a dig at Hill supporters or Ginnivans?
I'd have both in my 22 when in form.

Who’s place is Ginnivan taking?

 

[riddick78]

I'm not that confident about this game. I hope it's just nerves. I hope we aren't too beaten up and tired after last weeks game.

What's with us and illnesses?!?!?! would of been great to have Hill in, would of been great to have him running around the fwd50, i hope Beau snags a couple in his place.

Great to have WHE back in, great sub, can play pretty much anywhere.

 

[Jen2310]

We can't just expect a win, we need to go and take it.

 

[stormskye]

it’s game day! And the only question I want to know is how much Dave tipped the blues by!

 

[Lifelong Pie]

We can't just expect a win, we need to go and take it.

We as supporters can, as long as the players don't

 

[daicos jaicos]

Feel confident for tonight. Woulld.love a 10 goal smashing. Snuff them out. In Sydney tonight so cant make the game. Have 2 tickets for anyone who would like to use them. Let me know . Will check in through the day to see if anyone interested. Free to a good Collingwood home

Interested if still available! Can't seem to be able to send a PM, is there any way for you to contact me?

 

[Jen2310]

We as supporters can, as long as the players don't

haha yes, exactly.

 

[Kirby]

I expect an early challenge from the Blues then a fizzle out from them, then a comprehensive win to the Pies.

I reckon the MCG will have lots of empty seats halfway through the last quarter as the Blues supporters waddle off back to their cave of delirium.

 

[Jen2310]

I expect an early challenge from the Blues then a fizzle out from them, then a comprehensive win to the Pies.

I reckon the MCG will have lots of empty seats halfway through the last quarter as the Blues supporters waddle off back to their cave of delirium.

The blues will throw everything at us early, 100% then they'll fall because they wont be able to keep up.

 

[JuniorB]

I think Carlton make finals anyway but wouldn’t mind making them squirm for the remainder of the season. But also I really don’t care about tonight we got bigger issues to worry about than a meaningless round 18 or whatever we’re up to game

We still have to ensure we finish top 2.
Most likely we will, but the best way to make sure is to keep winning.

 

[Copeland]

Feel confident for tonight. Woulld.love a 10 goal smashing. Snuff them out. In Sydney tonight so cant make the game. Have 2 tickets for anyone who would like to use them. Let me know . Will check in through the day to see if anyone interested. Free to a good Collingwood home

Oh really, are they still available?

 

[Kirby]

Dou you want to know what my prediction is for Carlton tonight??

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

And it will be those facts commentators will use to down play our victory if we smash them.

No no, it will be the injuries

 

[Mick F]

Interested if still available! Can't seem to be able to send a PM, is there any way for you to contact me?

Long term supporter and BF contributor

 

[hellfire]

No no, it will be the injuries

Yes, their "entire midfield" is apparently missing. In fact, only 5 of their top 6 'centre bounce attendances' players will line up tonight.... crippling.

 

[MightyRoar]

Anyone still wanting a ticket to tonight’s game PM

 

[Big Bryza]

so why wasn’t he recalled?

I’m suggesting it’s team balance, it’s not a best 22 but a best 23, Markov’s elevation to the starting 22 still means we’d be down a runner from the side we fielded last week, if we’re in a situation like last week we we’re lacking run WHE can provide it.

Not being a smart arse, but can you think of another reason beside team balance that has ginni overlooked?

I think we'll be looking to exploit Carlton on the outside, hence the Markov inclusion.

The Blues strength is around stoppages. We put enough heat on and we can see a repeat performance from Moore, who can dish it off to Crisp, IQ, Noble, Markov etc and we will run the Blues off their feet. Let alone the Daicos boys, Sidey and JDG through the middle. Carlton have had it all one way for the past 5 weeks. Let's see how good they are against a proper footy side.

We also gain far more with WHE's versatility as the sub compared to Ginny. He's an everywhere man and has had big moments late in games.

Just like last week with Port, Carlton are bringing back 'managed' players to throw the kitchen sink at us.

We have an unbelievable ability to absorb the oppositions best and get them on the rebound, time and time again.

 

[Big Bryza]

No! That concedes a win to the tagger through reduced opportunities for Nick.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Imagine the scenes though if we push Nick forward and he kicks 6.

 

[Big Bryza]

I think Carlton make finals anyway but wouldn’t mind making them squirm for the remainder of the season. But also I really don’t care about tonight we got bigger issues to worry about than a meaningless round 18 or whatever we’re up to game

They need to beat one of us or the Dees. Otherwise they'll play an unofficial Wildcard game in the final round v GWS.

 

[TradeDraft]

I tipped Pies by 15pts this week

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

I tipped Pies by 15pts this week

Can't you go back and change it. Please.