List Mgmt. Contracts, trades, draft - 2022 superstar edition

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Link to contract status of all players -

 
Culley's improvement gives me strong Clayton Oliver vibes (in as much as any player can be compared to another - and also comparing in-season improvement and opportunity to off-season improvement creating opportunity).

From what I understand he was playing 2021 out of position as a not-that-fast mid/small forward. 11-12 possessions and a goal a game. OK, but not draftable.

Worked on his speed and pace-off-the-mark over the offseason, and through better conditioning forced his way into his preferred position in the midfield (Olivers opportunity was due to players being at the carnival).

Not saying he will be that good, but that improvement trajectory just has to set off alarm bells with recruiters and hopefully ours are at least listening.
That is what I think of Jai Culley, he's a late bloomer and everything I've seen of him is he's on a linear growth trajectory.
He came late onto the scene for Dandenong Stingrays too, was plucked from club footy late to play for them.
So was never going to get midfield time last year, over mids that had been there a long time.
Covid then hit and he had to wait until this season. I'd have no quarms taking him pick 1 in MSD and he turned out to be a dud. I just think the upside could be massive.
 
Last edited:
How long did we carry Shuey before he sorted out his hammies?

When do 18 or 19 year olds start peaking and break into the best 22?

More than 12 months from being drafted.

The only acceptable reason to delist O'Neil was his attitude. Maybehe needed a kick up the backside to get serious?
Shuey was a high draft pick though. Compared to a rookie pick (I know he was AA x2 U18, but still every other club passed multiple times).

Gov might be a better comparison, as he showed a bit but lacked professionalism.

I just think we would have inevitably have cut O'Neill so doing it earlier has probably benefited both parties.

On SM-G986B using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

Log in to remove this ad.

That is what I think of Jai Culley, he's a late bloomer and everything I've seen of him is he's on a linear growth trajectory.
He came late onto the scene for Dandenong Stingrays too, was plucked from club footy late to play gof them.
So was never going to get midfield time last year, over mids that had been there a long time.
Covid then hit and he had to wait until this season. I'd have no quarms taking him pick 1 in MSD and he turned out to be a dud. I just think the upside could be massive.
I completely agree
 
What are the odds Culley gets OP just before the draft, everyone avoids him so we get him with our last pick, everyone here gets excited, other clubs are like WTF West Coast, his OP is so bad his cajones fell off, why didn't you do your homework, pie man is like om nom nom on a Jester's, and our medical staff led by Harold Shipman ensures he never plays football again.

Said cajones somehow end up in the tennis ball bucket, and Kennedy is forced to retire after getting hit in the eye.

$1.01 surely
 
Yeah we are all about "synergy" whatever that is.
if someone could invent a Synergy Maker I reckon they might earn a bit of cash. I don't know what synergy is or what a synergy maker looks like but I'd image some sort of contraption where you put good shit into it and gooder shit comes out the other end.

I'm pretty sure it doesn't look like this though:

1653475451152.png
 
What are the odds Culley gets OP just before the draft, everyone avoids him so we get him with our last pick, everyone here gets excited, other clubs are like WTF West Coast, his OP is so bad his cajones fell off, why didn't you do your homework, pie man is like om nom nom on a Jester's, and our medical staff led by Harold Shipman ensures he never plays football again.

Said cajones somehow end up in the tennis ball bucket, and Kennedy is forced to retire after getting hit in the eye.

$1.01 surely

I want some of what you’re having.
 
Any chance we can trade into the top 10 of the MSD?

You can only trade picks in the upcoming draft for a MSD pick.

Its a new concept and it will be interesting to see what clubs who wont use a pick be willing to trade for it. Lions may accept a 4th rounder for the points. Giants have a top 10 pick in the MSD.

And we need to open another spot. And have pick 37 no 4th.

We wont be trading 37. Unless we were confident players would also be traded out to regain picks. Too many variables.

If we are that keen open another spot and see who is left.
 
Last edited:

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Don’t know him from a bar of soap but Culley surely suits our required age profile (18 to 22yo) better than Florenca.

Take Florenca with our second pick by all means. But an overlooked 19 year old Vic kid who missed exposure to recruiters due to Covid seems the far more preferable option as several posters have noted.
 
Don’t know him from a bar of soap but Culley surely suits our required age profile (18 to 22yo) better than Florenca.

Take Florenca with our second pick by all means. But an overlooked 19 year old Vic kid who missed exposure to recruiters due to Covid seems the far more preferable option as several posters have noted.
Agree re Florenca (take him with our 2nd).

Culley wasn't good enough last year, not due to Covid as much as being mid-team on talent, so being played out of position as a forward.

Worked on his main weaknesses over summer to get midfield time, and has shown how much better he can play I his preferred position (not sure if we have heard that sort of thing before at West Coast...)



On SM-G986B using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Culley is exactly the type of pick you make in the MSD. Rate of development, skills and can kick a bomb. Still young, might cost a first rounder in this draft.

Is there a risk that he's only beating up on teenagers as opposed to Carmichael who's playing SANFL

Sent from my SM-G998B using Tapatalk
 
Ahh the mid season draft saviour.

No matter who we take, it’ll be wrong to someone on here. 😅

Culley? - White guy with dreadlocks? Red Flag.

Florenca? - BOOOOOORING! We’ve already seen that one! Too vanilla! (but for god’s SAKE! Don’t let Freo take him instead).

Not to mention the melts if we don’t lose by enough to the Dogs and ‘miss out’ on not being dead last to get the coveted pick….
 
Ahh the mid season draft saviour.

No matter who we take, it’ll be wrong to someone on here. 😅

Culley? - White guy with dreadlocks? Red Flag.

Florenca? - BOOOOOORING! We’ve already seen that one! Too vanilla! (but for god’s SAKE! Don’t let Freo take him instead).

Not to mention the melts if we don’t lose by enough to the Dogs and ‘miss out’ on not being dead last to get the coveted pick….
Pretty sure no one on here will be upset if we take Culley then Florenca.
I haven't really seen anyone on here suggest taking anyone else except maybe Carmichael.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top