Judd trade may fall over.

[Dodgy Barry]

we are not in trouble as Judd DOES NOT WANT TO GO TO RICHMOND......Connors is also working hard behind the scenes to remind all players involved of this......Richmond can throw the kitchen sink at WCE,, but if Judd doesn't agree then he goes into the PSD and WCE get ZIP.....so basically it is 3 & JK, vs ZIP.... Judd will have been consulted and would accept the 3 & JK offer (he will not want to cripple the club he is moving to), so with judd and connor's blessing as to the adequacy of the trade, he will refuse to sign any trade with richmond and WCE get nothing...so again, i repeat, 3 & JK versus nothing and Nisbett being forced to stand down as WC CEO for gross incompetence.

Veale deal gives us 2 & 18 v 3 & a hack.

And Judd DOES NOT NEED TO SIGN WITH RICHMOND... they get him in the PSD.

Comprenhende?

I would ask Nisbett to stand down if he accepted your rubbish offer.

Make no mistake, 95% of WCE supporters would rather stick the knife into Judd's back, rather than allow him to stick the knife into ours, as he has thus far.

 

[Big Delut]

Our list is a train wreck?? This coming from a guy who supports a team that has won how many games in the last 3 years???

Our record versus yours in the last 3 seasons speaks for itself.

I didn't see many teams paying your list much respect this year... or last year... or the year before...

Ignoring all injuries (and therefore this year's ladder washup), any position-by-position comparison between Richmond and Carlton's team lists conducted by an impartial 3rd party (say, a Brisbane supporter), would come out in favour of the Tiges.

I have no problems with you spouting your opinion parrot, (although you do tend to say the same thing in every second post of any judd thread I come across), but when you start talking crap with nothing to back it up, then it's just plain irritating.

My 2 cents, I don't care who gets Judd. You don't have a midfield where he can really flourish, and neither do we. Take him away from Braun, Cousins, Kerr, etc, and you're looking at a different player. Still good, but not worth what would have to be given up to West Coast.

They'll be the real winners out of all of this, mark my words.

You've beaten us 3-2. Hardly noteworthy.

 

[Snout]

You've beaten us 3-2. Hardly noteworthy.

I actually meant total season win:loss ratio over the last 3 years.

Although it's nice that our train wreck of a list has managed to beat yours one on one 3 out of 5 times recently as well

 

[Big Delut]

I actually meant total season win:loss ratio over the last 3 years.

Although it's nice that our train wreck of a list has managed to beat yours one on one 3 out of 5 times recently as well

Considering many of your ridiculous fans say we have been tanking the last 3 years it doesn't mean much. The bottom line is Richmond have made 3 finals series since 1980. We have won 4 premierships since 1980.