If Silvagni had done a brilliant job you still wouldn’t be languishing at the bottom of the ladder.
Silvagni took over a bottom of the ladder list almost devoid of young talent; he hit the draft hard and now 3 years down the track, about half the team are btw 18-21yo. Reckon your method for assessing a list manager needs calibration of you think this strategy was designed to payoff in 2018. Let’s be real, whether SOS has done a brilliant job or not won’t be known for at least a couple of years.