Traded Mitch McGovern [traded to Carlton in a three-way trade involving Sydney and McAdam]

[Thetrader15]

i agree many are saying 24 and 25 are fair value for him

Particularly those who support carlton

 

[Kramer1]

Having said that I'm critical of SOS for not trading a player with personal issues that he wanted to go home for when the crows had put a reasonable trade on the table and so were Gibbs and his manager.

Going over very well trodden ground here...but SOS was very willing to trade Bryce for fair value. One year later Adelaide agreed that price was fair and the deal was done. Not sure how this is doing the wrong thing by Bryce.

 

[When I Crow Up]

Going over very well trodden ground here...but SOS was very willing to trade Bryce for fair value. One year later Adelaide agreed that price was fair and the deal was done. Not sure how this is doing the wrong thing by Bryce.

Gibbs and his manager disagreed with your view. Gibbs' manager Nigel Carmody, of TLA the player management company owned by Kelly, admitted his client was disappointed not to be traded but understood as a contracted player the trade had to be agreed.

"Yeah he is [disappointed with Carlton]," Carmody said. "He was really honest with them and we also think that the deal that Adelaide put forward was more than fair and reasonable, particularly in comparison with some of the other deals that have been done during the trade period looked like.

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl...aide-trade-falls-through-20161020-gs6v0p.html

One year later crows lost the grand final and felt Gibbs was the missing piece so paid overs to get the deal done. Gibbs had personal reasons for wanting the trade and SOS didn't respect those reasons. But like I said, both teams handled the deal poorly, but SOS forced crows to pay way overs for Gibbs so shouldn't expect any favours for McGovern.

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Particularly those who support carlton

You’ll find many neutrals who think an early second is around the mark for Mitch.

Two seconds should be more than enough to do the deal, it’ll allow you to get into the top 5, but I think this has become more about getting one back over SOS than anything else.

Would honestly rather keep 12 should Sydney trade with us and come back for Gov next year. Cam McCarthy 2.0

 

[TGFC]

my personal view is he gets lots of players to the club that are quite average which overall doesn't improve the quality of the team. Losing a bloke like a that stage of his career isn't ideal at all. there is plenty more examples of him just bringing in average players who couldn't get a game at other clubs and that is not getting carlton out of this low period of the football club.

You can only play 18 on the field

 

[marty36]

You’ll find many neutrals who think an early second is around the mark for Mitch.

Two seconds should be more than enough to do the deal, it’ll allow you to get into the top 5, but I think this has become more about getting one back over SOS than anything else.

Would honestly rather keep 12 should Sydney trade with us and come back for Gov next year. Cam McCarthy 2.0

Who cares about nuetrals, not really worried what richmonds director of footy thinks, the only one that counts is the AFC and their director of footy has said no to pick 24 and 25

 

[jezzajay]

Neutrals generally have an unbiased view of things, hence why people appreciate their view.
The AFC and director of footy aren't the only ones who have a say in where McGovern's trade lies....the team/person trading him in has a say also.

 

[dickie_douglas]

Just one trade that comes to mind... of many more including trades he made for GWS.
Could say the same for a lot of list managers, as there is only one #1 team....which is currently the eagles and you could pick out bad trades they've done in recent years also.

No other list manager trades as many spuds onto one list though, continues to search for second rate players who are not in a 22 that are going deep into finals. Yes eagles won the flag but there was 11-12 teams that were in realistic contention and anyone of which probably could have won if a few things went their way. Carlton do not seem to be going in contention with SOS incharge making many horrible decisions.

 

[Jbudds]

I really don't understand the swaying of arguments here.

Isn't it this simple. The Crows need to be put in a position that they consider better than retaining McGoven?

He's a 23 year old gun that's a walk up start in the team. The club will not be put in a position that means it goes backwards. Even a break even position is worth considerable value for a contracted required player.

 

[marty36]

Neutrals generally have an unbiased view of things, hence why people appreciate their view.
The AFC and director of footy aren't the only ones who have a say in where McGovern's trade lies....the team/person trading him in has a say also.

as we know the only one that really counts when a players is contracted as the great man SOS says himself

 

[jezzajay]

No other list manager trades as many spuds onto one list though, continues to search for second rate players who are not in a 22 that are going deep into finals. Yes eagles won the flag but there was 11-12 teams that were in realistic contention and anyone of which probably could have won if a few things went their way. Carlton do not seem to be going in contention with SOS incharge making many horrible decisions.

He has seen through 3 trade/draft periods...said from the get go he would turn the list over (which he has done in an unprecedented manner) and it wouldn't be until the 4th period (which we're entering) that the real business of trading for better and older players will commence.
Hitting the draft has been his mantra since he came back to us. He has seen this through, plus he has been honest in regards to this from the outset.
Much like the crows and a few other teams we had a horrid year in 2018 with injuries with our bottom of the ladder not being a fair assessment of where our list truly lies.
Anyone with a grain of understanding of where our list is at knows what SOS is doing and has the patience to see it through.
Head to this thread and you will understand what I'm talking about...https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/track-the-66-game-rebuild.1129290/

 

[jezzajay]

as we know the only one that really counts when a players is contracted as the great man SOS says himself

View attachment 567847

Yeah, for a player that doesn't want to play for the club they are at again...different story
This has been done to death but Gibbs and McGovern are different in that regard.
Well aware that McGovern has two more years like Gibbs...but he doesn't want to play for Adelaide again...where as Gibbs publicly stated he was fine to play on at Carlton.
And like so many others have said before on here (yawn)... if a trade cant come to fruition, so be it...we move on.

 

[Jeremias]

Mitch McGovern [requested a trade to Carlton]

Let's get back on track thanks.

If you want to discuss Carlton's recent draft history, start another thread. It has nothing to do with the McGovern trade.

 

[When I Crow Up]

Mitch McGovern [requested a trade to Carlton]

Let's get back on track thanks.

If you want to discuss Carlton's recent draft history, start another thread. It has nothing to do with the McGovern trade.

Sorry there was context earlier in the thread RE their draft history and that bringing in McGovern is a step in the right direction of them becoming a bit more of a destination club and that their list management could be willing to pay more for him knowing that it may then lead to other recuitments but that got a bit lost in things.

 

[marty36]

Yeah, for a player that doesn't want to play for the club they are at again...different story
This has been done to death but Gibbs and McGovern are different in that regard.
Well aware that McGovern has two more years like Gibbs...but he doesn't want to play for Adelaide again...where as Gibbs publicly stated he was fine to play on at Carlton.
And like so many others have said before on here (yawn)... if a trade cant come to fruition, so be it...we move on.

Of course Gibbs wanted to play for the club that's why he requested a trade

 

[Adelaide97]

Plus Reid has never indicated he's interested in McAdam, that's the media being the media. I don't know how many times I need to link this guys stats to show that he will not help the crows. Avg 8 disposals a game, 2 goals, 2 tackles... he's the occasional highlight reel, not the forward 50 pressure crows want. Add to this that Stengle has just told Richmond he wants to be traded to the crows which will get done so we don't need another small forward as he fits the mold we want plus is a much better all round player than McAdam, there's no way Crows take this guy.

AND just to make things even better, the following has just been announced - "Adelaide and Port Adelaide have been given access to an increased pool of top up players for their state league sides following the Commission’s review of their licence conditions and list regulations.

The commission approved the changes in a bid to ensure the SANFL and its clubs continue to provide the best talent pathway opportunities to young South Australians, ensuring as many players as possible reach the AFL, according to SANFL football operations manager Tom Hurley.

The Crows and Power can now contract 10 players who will receive an upfront payment of up to $4000 and they are able to obtain players over 19 years of age not on the 40-player lists at the eight state league clubs. Previously, those players had to be under 25."

So in a nutshell, both Crows and Port will now have access to develop more young talent.

Reid did show interest in McAdam on trade radio this morning, he also said that the crows have been watching him for the last 18 months.

 

[jezzajay]

Of course Gibbs wanted to play for the club that's why he requested a trade

Ummm...yeah...

 

[davis_756]

as we know the only one that really counts when a players is contracted as the great man SOS says himself

View attachment 567847

25 + McAdam is overs, so we indeed will be paying overs just not the triple value some of you crows fans expect.

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Of course Gibbs wanted to play for the club that's why he requested a trade

Gibbs wanted to play for Carlton but needed to live in South Australia.

Clearly the circumstances are different with McGovern. McGovern has issues with Adelaide.

 

[arsene wenger1]

Yeah, for a player that doesn't want to play for the club they are at again...different story
This has been done to death but Gibbs and McGovern are different in that regard.
Well aware that McGovern has two more years like Gibbs...but he doesn't want to play for Adelaide again...where as Gibbs publicly stated he was fine to play on at Carlton.
And like so many others have said before on here (yawn)... if a trade cant come to fruition, so be it...we move on.

yea hates the club so much he went to the bnf and if currently still training at the club. He’s requested a trade yes but ain’t holding this club to ransom.

 

[arsene wenger1]

25 + McAdam is overs, so we indeed will be paying overs just not the triple value some of you crows fans expect.

Serious question....how many times you seen McAdam play?

 

[arsene wenger1]

Of course Gibbs wanted to play for the club that's why he requested a trade

Twice

 

[davis_756]

Serious question....how many times you seen McAdam play?

Never, 25 is fair value for a player of Mcgoverns current output and anything on top of that is overs. It won't actually be McAdam, it will be the state league pick which you will use on whoever you rate.

 

[arsene wenger1]

Never, 25 is fair value for a player of Mcgoverns current output and anything on top of that is overs. It won't actually be McAdam, it will be the state league pick which you will use on whoever you rate.

Yea we pick up the state league players in the rookie draft, no need to use a gun like McGovern for that. Obviously you’ve probably only seen MM a handful of time cause pick 25 is so unders you either don’t know anything about him or your clearly trolling.

Imagine Carlton getting him for pick 25, they’d be laughing all the way to the bank. If that happens then maybe you can start giving SOS the credit he currently doesn’t deserve but seems to get

 

[marty36]

Gibbs wanted to play for Carlton but needed to live in South Australia.

Clearly the circumstances are different with McGovern. McGovern has issues with Adelaide.

Of course he did hahahaha

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app