moran for hartigan

[Bren]

we dont want him

for moran i was thinking

Brown+Moran+4th Rounder to brissy
Breenan + Selwood to Roos

they won't want that many talls

 

[jezza]

You'd use pick one in the PSD on Moran?

Way to shoot low there.

You're obviously unfamiliar with the standard of player available in the pre-season draft.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2006_AFL_draft
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_AFL_Draft
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004_AFL_Draft

 

[Bren]

You're obviously unfamiliar with the standard of player available in the pre-season draft.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2006_AFL_draft
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_AFL_Draft
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004_AFL_Draft

Max 1 decent player per year.

 

[Patty#32]

WE, i have no doubt about this have the least run out of back line by a long way, even less than Melbourne and Richmonds run!

 

[AGC]

WE, i have no doubt about this have the least run out of back line by a long way, even less than Melbourne and Richmonds run!

Don't you hate that stupid Jesse Smith and Jesse Sinclair. Duds of the highest order. And that Firrito guy. They're all crap.

 

[shinboner magic]

Why would we be interested in a injury plagued player when we just got rid of one and still have 2 0r 3 still on our list.

Another thing is we dont have to many tall players either so giving one away for nothing would be a great joke.

dean its time to stay away from trade week forever

 

[fraser25]

Hartigans a dud, watching him in the VFL and he is nothing special. Couldn't even crack a game for Richmond.

Neither could Rodan. However due to this fact I doubt you would even have to trade anyone for him, just pick him up in either drafts if you want him.

I quite like him, he's not perfect but there are plenty of imperfect players going around these days getting alot of it, ie. Stanton, Swallow just to give examples.

 

[RoyalBlue]

So his value as a speculative pick goes from 70 to 35.

You better be pretty good Goldy.

 

[rooboy_88]

Don't you hate that stupid Jesse Smith and Jesse Sinclair. Duds of the highest order. And that Firrito guy. They're all crap.

Forgot Pratty to that list of crappy players

 

[Roosurgence]

Again, it's not a good trade for you because he is out of contract and having pick 1 in the PSD gives us leverage to get him for less than market value. I can not stress this enough.

So you are hpoing Judd will fall through to your second pick in the PSD

 

[jezza]

So you are hpoing Judd will fall through to your second pick in the PSD

Judd won't go through to the PSD, anyone thinking he will is living in a fantasy land. The only reason we are trying to push it as a possibility is so that WCE get a high price in a trade for Judd and in return we get Mitch Morton on the cheap.

 

[The Teflon Dean]

in the works reported on sen moran for hartigan

I'm not against trading Moran, but I think we could do better than Hartigan for him.

 

[Moti]

Greg Miller says that this deal will not happen.

 

[year of the roo]

Greg Miller says that this deal will not happen.

Good to see Greg still working for us even though we're not paying him anymore.

 

[Bozz.Clunker.H]

Greg Miller says that this deal will not happen.

when?

 

[AGC]

Should have done the deal. We could have got a pick 5 higher spots in the draft, and a good player for NB with a heap of endurance. Plus, we would be giving Moran to Richmond who are not going to have success anytime soon, whilst Adelaide are at least a 1/2 decent team.

 

[year of the roo]

Should have done the deal. We could have got a pick 5 higher spots in the draft, and a good player for NB with a heap of endurance. Plus, we would be giving Moran to Richmond who are not going to have success anytime soon, whilst Adelaide are at least a 1/2 decent team.

Fair point. I can't believe this deal actually looks decent with hindsight. We are terrible traders, terrible.