-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Preview R1: Changes for 2025
- Thread starter jamesclean
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I noticed him up forward late. Didn't do much though. GWS will be fine without him. What will he add to the Crows? Not sure.
Kane McGoodwin
Make me an Admin!
- May 21, 2001
- 86,023
- 91,387
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Adelaide Crows
im ok getting him too as long as we dont use too much cap on him and piss off our better players paid less
B: Hamill Butts Worrell
HB: Laird Murray Michalanney
C: Hinge Crouch Dowling
HF: Neale-Bullen Thilthorpe Keays
F: Rachele Fogarty Rankine
R: "Someone else" Dawson Soligo
I: Walker Curtin Nankervis Pick 4 Mid
Sub: Pedlar
HB: Laird Murray Michalanney
C: Hinge Crouch Dowling
HF: Neale-Bullen Thilthorpe Keays
F: Rachele Fogarty Rankine
R: "Someone else" Dawson Soligo
I: Walker Curtin Nankervis Pick 4 Mid
Sub: Pedlar
MsTopG
Norm Smith Medallist
- Mar 21, 2023
- 5,572
- 5,305
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Out: Nicks, Roo, Ogilvie, Reid, Silvers, Kelly, Olsen and the board, Assistants. Laird, Smith, Crouch, Murphy.
In: Buckley
Michalanney Keane Worrell
Nankervis/Bond Murray Hinge
Dowling Dawson Curtin
Rachele Thilthorpe Neale-Bullen
Keays Fogarty Pedlar
ROB?/Better ruck Soligo Rankine
Walker pick 4 Berry Edwards
In: Buckley
Michalanney Keane Worrell
Nankervis/Bond Murray Hinge
Dowling Dawson Curtin
Rachele Thilthorpe Neale-Bullen
Keays Fogarty Pedlar
ROB?/Better ruck Soligo Rankine
Walker pick 4 Berry Edwards
Last edited:
Assuming we finish the trade period with Cumming and ANB as our only significant ins (along with pick 4), this is how I would line up:
Michalanney Keane Worrell
Cumming Murray Hinge
Sholl Crouch Dawson
Rankine Walker Thilthorpe
ANB Fogarty Rachele
ROB Soligo Taylor
Nankervis Keays Curtin Berry
SUB: Dowling
*Dawson plays wing, half back and midfield. Is used in midfield in spurts. We will be a much better team once we don't need him in the midfield and can utilise his outside strengths.
*Nankervis is part of wing and back line rotations.
*Keays small forward rotations
*Curtin helps rotate the tall forwards. Would also use on wing if needed.
*Berry part of midfield rotation. Main aim is to avoid having Crouch and Berry in midfield together, particularly in centre bounces.
*Rankine utilised in midfield in spurts. Rachele also used in spurts.
*Pick 4 hopefully coming into the side quickly. Maybe for Berry.
Laird and Smith in SANFL. As is Murphy. Finally. Hopefully. Of course I fully expect that all 3 will play round 1, most likely in place of Taylor, Nankervis and Berry.
Michalanney Keane Worrell
Cumming Murray Hinge
Sholl Crouch Dawson
Rankine Walker Thilthorpe
ANB Fogarty Rachele
ROB Soligo Taylor
Nankervis Keays Curtin Berry
SUB: Dowling
*Dawson plays wing, half back and midfield. Is used in midfield in spurts. We will be a much better team once we don't need him in the midfield and can utilise his outside strengths.
*Nankervis is part of wing and back line rotations.
*Keays small forward rotations
*Curtin helps rotate the tall forwards. Would also use on wing if needed.
*Berry part of midfield rotation. Main aim is to avoid having Crouch and Berry in midfield together, particularly in centre bounces.
*Rankine utilised in midfield in spurts. Rachele also used in spurts.
*Pick 4 hopefully coming into the side quickly. Maybe for Berry.
Laird and Smith in SANFL. As is Murphy. Finally. Hopefully. Of course I fully expect that all 3 will play round 1, most likely in place of Taylor, Nankervis and Berry.
Kane McGoodwin
Make me an Admin!
- May 21, 2001
- 86,023
- 91,387
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Adelaide Crows
Early days...
B: Laird, Murray, Keane
HB: Michaelanny, Worrell, Hinge
C: Sholl, Soligo, Cumming
HF: Rachele, Fogarty, ANB
F: Walker, Thilthorpe, Keays
R: O’Brien, Dawson, Rankine
I: Nankervis, Crouch, Curtin, Pedlar
Sub: Taylor
E: Butts, Jones, Berry
But we should be looking to manage around 30ish players through the season.
Tex to play around 2/3rds of games... so we can mix up Curtin's role.
Edwards, Ryan & pick #4 debut & hopefully play plenty of games.
More of Bond & Dowling.
Hopefully Milera can get an injury free run.
B: Laird, Murray, Keane
HB: Michaelanny, Worrell, Hinge
C: Sholl, Soligo, Cumming
HF: Rachele, Fogarty, ANB
F: Walker, Thilthorpe, Keays
R: O’Brien, Dawson, Rankine
I: Nankervis, Crouch, Curtin, Pedlar
Sub: Taylor
E: Butts, Jones, Berry
But we should be looking to manage around 30ish players through the season.
Tex to play around 2/3rds of games... so we can mix up Curtin's role.
Edwards, Ryan & pick #4 debut & hopefully play plenty of games.
More of Bond & Dowling.
Hopefully Milera can get an injury free run.
- Oct 6, 2012
- 13,740
- 27,821
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
On paper a side like that should be contending for finals. Geez our coaches are hopeless.
Well now that Cumming’s confirmed
B: Michalanney, Murray, Worrell
HB: Hinge, Keane, Cumming
C: Sholl, Dawson, Nankervis
HF: Rachele, Fogarty, ANB
F: Keays, Thilthorpe, Walker
R: ROB, Soligo, Rankine
I/C: Crouch, Laird, Dowling, Curtin
Sub: Taylor
Need Laird to have a Smith 2024 arc (hopefully quicker) and get overtaken by our younger talent. Otherwise, I like how the team stacks up
Pedlar/Milera/Berry/Bond/pick 4 should all be varying levels of chances, too
Hopefully the Peatling rumours are true, he’d add even more to the side
B: Michalanney, Murray, Worrell
HB: Hinge, Keane, Cumming
C: Sholl, Dawson, Nankervis
HF: Rachele, Fogarty, ANB
F: Keays, Thilthorpe, Walker
R: ROB, Soligo, Rankine
I/C: Crouch, Laird, Dowling, Curtin
Sub: Taylor
Need Laird to have a Smith 2024 arc (hopefully quicker) and get overtaken by our younger talent. Otherwise, I like how the team stacks up
Pedlar/Milera/Berry/Bond/pick 4 should all be varying levels of chances, too
Hopefully the Peatling rumours are true, he’d add even more to the side
- Jul 22, 2012
- 4,399
- 10,340
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Philadelphia 76ers
I didn’t pick Smith in my 2024 Round 1 team because the writing was well and truly on the wall for him based on his last 2 months of 2023, and this time I’m not going near Laird in the 2025 Round 1 team for the same reason.
B: Hinge - Keane - Worrell
HB: Cumming - Murray - Michalanney
C: Nankervis - Soligo - Dawson
HF: Rachele - Walker - Neal-Bullen
F: Keays - Fogarty - Thilthorpe
R: O’Brien - Crouch - Rankine
Int: Curtin - Taylor - Sholl - Pick 4
Sub: Dowling
Emg (from): Edwards - Pedlar - Butts - Cook - Milera - Berry - Ryan - Bond - 2nd draftee
Depth only: Strachan - Laird - Smith - Schoenberg - Jones - Murphy - Borlase - T Murray - Burgess (assuming Burgess actually has a contract) - Gallagher
No longer at the club: Himmelberg - Hamill - Gollant - McHenry - Parnell
Notes:
1) Butts vs Keane is a fascinating battle. We can’t play all 4 of Butts, Keane, Worrell and Murray in the same side IMO. I actually don’t love Butts being the one to miss out, but the recovery from another surgery just puts him a bit behind the 8 ball initially for Round 1.
2) Walker plays in Round 1, assuming the game is in Adelaide or Melbourne and he’s 100% fit. I’m basically not putting him on a flight to any other city for the entire season, unless it’s a final and he’s still a viable selection by then.
3) all of the emergencies I have listed have enough upside to be considered seriously for Round 1 if they have a ripping preseason, so there’s a few spots up for grabs, most notably those occupied by Dowling, Taylor, Keane, Curtin and Sholl.
4) Nankervis moves to a wing, and Cumming goes to half back. This is a more natural fit for both of these players IMO. Cumming was shunted away from a HBF at GWS due to them having arguably the best attacking HBF in the league in Whitfield back there (plus Lachie Ash). Nank to me looks a more natural wingman than defensive half player.
5) I’ve got Dawson on the other wing. Realistically the guy can play anywhere. I don’t want to name him in defense because we have a ton of medium sized defenders. I don’t want to name him on ball because let’s face it, Rankine has to start there, Soligo is another dynamic option in there, and Crouch’s uncanny ability to gather and handball complements those two nicely. Why not try Dawson alternating between a wing, half forward and stoppages?
For me, there’s just something about Taylor that screams “class”, and Curtin is a freakish prospect so we should just prioritise getting games into those two above all of the other “fringe” options - I can’t budge on either of them.
I could, however, easily be talked out of picking any of Dowling (who really cares too much who the sub is - Berry isn’t bad in that role if we’re getting specific), Keane (Butts might outplay him in preseason and grab the spot) or Sholl (vanilla pace, no kicking penetration, no tackling ability but improved sharply in 2024 and deserves to be well and truly in the frame based on that) though. I’m absolutely drafting a mid at pick 4 and putting them straight in the Round 1 team and that’s another non-negotiable. If we draft someone at pick 4 who isn’t ready to play in Round 1, then it was the wrong choice. Our midfield is our main weakness as a team. It’s a strong midfielder draft in the top 10. Not a difficult equation.
A fully fit and in-form Milera and/or Pedlar would make for a selection headache or two. Much like Butts though, coming off surgery, I’m sending them to the SANFL for at least the first fortnight.
Edwards, Cook and Ryan have a lot of tricks that could help the team if utilised correctly.
I still really want to see Cook given a 5-6 week block of games playing 75ish% wing at AFL level (he’s maybe played 2 games with a percentage approaching that there ever). If he fails in that role, he is relegated to depth only, but don’t relegate him based on what happened when we played him out of position.
We simply must debut Edwards at some stage in 2025 and alternate him between half forward and midfield stoppages. Let’s see what he can do. Continuing to play guys like Laird, Murphy, Smith and Jones ahead of Edwards would be blatant stupidity.
Ryan is a genuinely exciting prospect who exceeded expectations at SANFL level in his first year, but his chances of debuting in Round 1 just took a hit with the Cumming acquisition.
Injuries will play a huge part in all of this - there’s virtually no way all players listed in anyone’s 23 will actually be available for Round 1 - it’s unavoidable.
B: Hinge - Keane - Worrell
HB: Cumming - Murray - Michalanney
C: Nankervis - Soligo - Dawson
HF: Rachele - Walker - Neal-Bullen
F: Keays - Fogarty - Thilthorpe
R: O’Brien - Crouch - Rankine
Int: Curtin - Taylor - Sholl - Pick 4
Sub: Dowling
Emg (from): Edwards - Pedlar - Butts - Cook - Milera - Berry - Ryan - Bond - 2nd draftee
Depth only: Strachan - Laird - Smith - Schoenberg - Jones - Murphy - Borlase - T Murray - Burgess (assuming Burgess actually has a contract) - Gallagher
No longer at the club: Himmelberg - Hamill - Gollant - McHenry - Parnell
Notes:
1) Butts vs Keane is a fascinating battle. We can’t play all 4 of Butts, Keane, Worrell and Murray in the same side IMO. I actually don’t love Butts being the one to miss out, but the recovery from another surgery just puts him a bit behind the 8 ball initially for Round 1.
2) Walker plays in Round 1, assuming the game is in Adelaide or Melbourne and he’s 100% fit. I’m basically not putting him on a flight to any other city for the entire season, unless it’s a final and he’s still a viable selection by then.
3) all of the emergencies I have listed have enough upside to be considered seriously for Round 1 if they have a ripping preseason, so there’s a few spots up for grabs, most notably those occupied by Dowling, Taylor, Keane, Curtin and Sholl.
4) Nankervis moves to a wing, and Cumming goes to half back. This is a more natural fit for both of these players IMO. Cumming was shunted away from a HBF at GWS due to them having arguably the best attacking HBF in the league in Whitfield back there (plus Lachie Ash). Nank to me looks a more natural wingman than defensive half player.
5) I’ve got Dawson on the other wing. Realistically the guy can play anywhere. I don’t want to name him in defense because we have a ton of medium sized defenders. I don’t want to name him on ball because let’s face it, Rankine has to start there, Soligo is another dynamic option in there, and Crouch’s uncanny ability to gather and handball complements those two nicely. Why not try Dawson alternating between a wing, half forward and stoppages?
For me, there’s just something about Taylor that screams “class”, and Curtin is a freakish prospect so we should just prioritise getting games into those two above all of the other “fringe” options - I can’t budge on either of them.
I could, however, easily be talked out of picking any of Dowling (who really cares too much who the sub is - Berry isn’t bad in that role if we’re getting specific), Keane (Butts might outplay him in preseason and grab the spot) or Sholl (vanilla pace, no kicking penetration, no tackling ability but improved sharply in 2024 and deserves to be well and truly in the frame based on that) though. I’m absolutely drafting a mid at pick 4 and putting them straight in the Round 1 team and that’s another non-negotiable. If we draft someone at pick 4 who isn’t ready to play in Round 1, then it was the wrong choice. Our midfield is our main weakness as a team. It’s a strong midfielder draft in the top 10. Not a difficult equation.
A fully fit and in-form Milera and/or Pedlar would make for a selection headache or two. Much like Butts though, coming off surgery, I’m sending them to the SANFL for at least the first fortnight.
Edwards, Cook and Ryan have a lot of tricks that could help the team if utilised correctly.
I still really want to see Cook given a 5-6 week block of games playing 75ish% wing at AFL level (he’s maybe played 2 games with a percentage approaching that there ever). If he fails in that role, he is relegated to depth only, but don’t relegate him based on what happened when we played him out of position.
We simply must debut Edwards at some stage in 2025 and alternate him between half forward and midfield stoppages. Let’s see what he can do. Continuing to play guys like Laird, Murphy, Smith and Jones ahead of Edwards would be blatant stupidity.
Ryan is a genuinely exciting prospect who exceeded expectations at SANFL level in his first year, but his chances of debuting in Round 1 just took a hit with the Cumming acquisition.
Injuries will play a huge part in all of this - there’s virtually no way all players listed in anyone’s 23 will actually be available for Round 1 - it’s unavoidable.
Chances Are
Senior List
- Dec 14, 2023
- 181
- 228
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
I have the following 3 wishes for 2025.
1. ROO out.
2. Nix sacked.
3. Board to be changed, both in personel and the members to have the ability to pick the entire board.
Too early for rd.1 teams.
1. ROO out.
2. Nix sacked.
3. Board to be changed, both in personel and the members to have the ability to pick the entire board.
Too early for rd.1 teams.
- Oct 2, 2022
- 6,417
- 8,828
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Here's where I figured they could start round one, though you could slide the positional magnets around.
FF: Darcy Fogarty - Riley Thilthorpe - Alex Neal Bullen
HF: Josh Rachele - Taylor Walker - Dan Curtin
C : Isaac Cumming - Jordan Dawson - Jake Soligo
1st R: Riley O'Brien - Matthew Crouch -
Izak Rankine
HB: Josh Worrell - Mark Keane - Mitch Hinge
FB: Max Michalanney - Nick Murray - Rory Laird
RES:
Pick 4, Ben Keays, Luke Nankervis, Chayce Jones, Zac Taylor
EMERGENCIES & DEPTH
Lachie Sholl
Luke Pedlar
Hugh Bond
Jordon Butts
Wayne Milera
Charlie Edwards
Brayden Cook
Oscar Ryan
Billy Dowling
Harry Schoenberg
James Borlase
FF: Darcy Fogarty - Riley Thilthorpe - Alex Neal Bullen
HF: Josh Rachele - Taylor Walker - Dan Curtin
C : Isaac Cumming - Jordan Dawson - Jake Soligo
1st R: Riley O'Brien - Matthew Crouch -
Izak Rankine
HB: Josh Worrell - Mark Keane - Mitch Hinge
FB: Max Michalanney - Nick Murray - Rory Laird
RES:
Pick 4, Ben Keays, Luke Nankervis, Chayce Jones, Zac Taylor
EMERGENCIES & DEPTH
Lachie Sholl
Luke Pedlar
Hugh Bond
Jordon Butts
Wayne Milera
Charlie Edwards
Brayden Cook
Oscar Ryan
Billy Dowling
Harry Schoenberg
James Borlase
Scorpus
Moderator
- Apr 16, 2014
- 61,723
- 165,054
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Moderator
- #66
B Worrell - Murray - Michalanney
HB Hinge - Keane - Cumming
R O'Brien - Dawson - Rankine
C Nankervis - Soligo - Sholl
HF Rachele - Fogarty - Neal-Bullen
F Walker - Thilthorpe - Keays
I Curtin - Pick 4 - Taylor - Pedlar
S Dowling
E Crouch - Laird - Milera - Welsh
HB Hinge - Keane - Cumming
R O'Brien - Dawson - Rankine
C Nankervis - Soligo - Sholl
HF Rachele - Fogarty - Neal-Bullen
F Walker - Thilthorpe - Keays
I Curtin - Pick 4 - Taylor - Pedlar
S Dowling
E Crouch - Laird - Milera - Welsh
- Jul 6, 2017
- 31,582
- 45,309
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Has to be close to the best side we could put out for sure. What makes it really work is that Walker can assume the key FF role when TT chips in to help out in ruck to give ROB a break and we don't lose our structure and then Tex can rest and we have some creative goal kickers on the bench to go smaller.
I think this is very close to it. Suspect they still pick crouch ahead of taylor. The rest is probably right unless we snag someone else. And correctly berry nowhere to be seen. So why did we extend him!
- Sep 25, 2014
- 5,261
- 3,816
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Sturt, Adelaide United & Leeds United
Copied and pasted from huludicidal and made slight changes
B: Hinge - Keane - Worrell
HB: Cumming - Murray - Michalanney
C: Nankervis - Soligo - Dawson
HF: Rachele - Walker - Neal-Bullen
F: Keays - Fogarty - Thilthorpe
R: O’Brien - Crouch - Rankine
Int: Curtin - Pick 4 - Sholl - Laird
Sub: Taylor
E: Milera, Pedlar, Dowling, Bond, Butts and Jones.
B: Hinge - Keane - Worrell
HB: Cumming - Murray - Michalanney
C: Nankervis - Soligo - Dawson
HF: Rachele - Walker - Neal-Bullen
F: Keays - Fogarty - Thilthorpe
R: O’Brien - Crouch - Rankine
Int: Curtin - Pick 4 - Sholl - Laird
Sub: Taylor
E: Milera, Pedlar, Dowling, Bond, Butts and Jones.
Kane McGoodwin
Make me an Admin!
- May 21, 2001
- 86,023
- 91,387
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Adelaide Crows
Not sure I like Curtin in defence...
I reckon he looked good up forward with stints around the stoppages.
- Oct 11, 2012
- 4,578
- 7,163
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
You're all forgetting to put Murphy in your teams - because Nicks will!
- Sep 25, 2014
- 5,261
- 3,816
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Sturt, Adelaide United & Leeds United
We are all going to be so pi55ed off but also not surprised when we see number 4 named in Round 1....
My best 22, with only questions being the last picked players in Dowling and Nank
Pedlar Thilthorpe Rachele
Keays Fogarty Neale-Bullen
Dowling Curtin Soligo
Hinge Keane Cummings
Worrell Murray Michalanny
RoB Dawson Rankine
Crouch Walker Pick 4 Nank
E: Taylor Scholl Milera
Pedlar Thilthorpe Rachele
Keays Fogarty Neale-Bullen
Dowling Curtin Soligo
Hinge Keane Cummings
Worrell Murray Michalanny
RoB Dawson Rankine
Crouch Walker Pick 4 Nank
E: Taylor Scholl Milera
- Jul 6, 2017
- 31,582
- 45,309
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Best guess at Nick's preferred R1 team
B: Murphy Murphy Murphy
HB: Smith Murphy Murphy
C: Murphy Murphy Murphy
HF: Murphy Murphy Murphy
FF: Murphy Murphy Murphy
R: ROB Murphy Murphy
B: Cumming, ANB Murphy Murphy
S: Curtin
B: Murphy Murphy Murphy
HB: Smith Murphy Murphy
C: Murphy Murphy Murphy
HF: Murphy Murphy Murphy
FF: Murphy Murphy Murphy
R: ROB Murphy Murphy
B: Cumming, ANB Murphy Murphy
S: Curtin
