Depends Rok has probably 3-4 years left if your club/recruiting believes next year and beyond you are capable of challenging for a flag and see Rok as the final piece of the jigsaw then pick 6 is worth it.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Ryan O'Keefe Wants to Leave Sydney for Melbourne - All Discussion Here!
- Thread starter bedford
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Depends Rok has probably 3-4 years left if your club/recruiting believes next year and beyond you are capable of challenging for a flag and see Rok as the final piece of the jigsaw then pick 6 is worth it.
If Carlton is indeed giving up their second rounder for Warnock then it has to be pick 6.
grimlock
Hall of Famer
So we trade ROK for Kelly and downgrade our 2nd rounder?!
- Moderator
- #205
So your saying Kelly is better than ROK
.You might want to add your first round to Kelly instead of the third round.
grimlock
Hall of Famer
Apparently when a player turns 28, his abilities magically halve. That's my only explanation for some of these proposed trades.So your saying Kelly is better than ROK
You might want to add your first round to Kelly instead of the third round.
- Banned
- #207
NO, how does that work for ya.
I would be very interested in that. If we swap the Ablett's also.
So your saying Kelly is better than ROK
You might want to add your first round to Kelly instead of the third round.
i am saying kelly is better than o'keefe at this point but we have alot of midfielders and could afford to lose one, he's got another four years longer to play than o'keefe and he's been part of back to back grand final sides. i'd suggest you need midfielders and we could use rok on a hff.....
but from suggestions you think he is worth more than that.... good luck getting it
_Interpol_
Club Legend
You are no longer the premiership team, average players like Kelly are no longer over rated by opposition fans. Deal with it
What would you fans be wanting from the saints?
3rd rounder + player for mine is what I think we will be offerng, draft picks are too important this year... The player will of course have to be of value, duh.... Name a layer swannies?
- Banned
- #212
I would rather get pick 6 from the blues. We're only looking for draft picks this year i'm afraid. Thanks for coming though.
FYI ROK has also been part of back to back grand final sides. If you think Kelly is so good then ask yourself this, who would you rather have had on Saturday? I think the answer is pretty obvious. Trying to upgrade a pick on this deal is simply insulting.
_Interpol_
Club Legend
Since when is kelly a dud. i'm offering up suggestions for discussion. seems like little interest. no worries. maybe your overated lists will make it to a granny next year.....
_Interpol_
Club Legend
You won't be getting pick 6 for a 28 year old, plain and simpleI would rather get pick 6 from the blues. We're only looking for draft picks this year i'm afraid. Thanks for coming though.
Unless freo had pick 6.... but seriously, 2nd rounder will get this deal done, he is out of contract, swans have no bargaining power
_Interpol_
Club Legend
This is the sydney board, don't start a slag fest here. I was only saying what everyone else here already said, kelyl is nowhere near rok. And i think he is quite average anyways. Good in a good side, heck, I could look good in that midfield. See my point?Since when is kelly a dud. i'm offering up suggestions for discussion. seems like little interest. no worries. maybe your overated lists will make it to a granny next year.....
grimlock
Hall of Famer
If opposition supporters could stick to posting their deluded valuations of their own players to their own boards that would help me keep my sanity thanks.
- Banned
- #219
His worth is dependent on his potential use in different teams. He wouldn't be worth a first round pick for the bombers because they're not in the flag market for atleast another 3 years but a team like carlton would have to seriously consider someone like ROK. He could put them in flag contention. He's a consistent hard worker who rarely is injured, he would be loved there.
I WISH okeefe would consider living in perth, imagine what we could get in a freo trade.
Since when is kelly a dud. i'm offering up suggestions for discussion. seems like little interest. no worries. maybe your overated lists will make it to a granny next year.....
Maybe we will? I am sure if we do it will be considered OVER achieving which is something you certianly won't be seen as after choking on the weekend.
RoK is a superstar, I really hope Sydney don't get burned here. Unfortunately, you have little bargaining power, and a Nick Stevens situation would really crush you guys.
He is worth a round 1 pick + x. No doubt to me. Random potential or AA champion for three years, there is no question you take RoK.
It all comes down to which club needs him. I think at Geelong would be scary. But I doubt they can fit him in the salary cap. Hawthorn have no need for him unless we trade you something like Williams or Osborne, but they are loyal to the club and vica versa.
I see St. Kilda bidding, but Milne and Schneider are already filling that role, so perhaps Milne may be moving...
Collingwood have Thomas, Didak, and Medhurst, so a Didak trade + Pick for RoK would be the most likely scenario in my book. Not sure how I would feel about picking up Didak if I were you guys though.. is vomit an emotion?
He is worth a round 1 pick + x. No doubt to me. Random potential or AA champion for three years, there is no question you take RoK.
It all comes down to which club needs him. I think at Geelong would be scary. But I doubt they can fit him in the salary cap. Hawthorn have no need for him unless we trade you something like Williams or Osborne, but they are loyal to the club and vica versa.
I see St. Kilda bidding, but Milne and Schneider are already filling that role, so perhaps Milne may be moving...
Collingwood have Thomas, Didak, and Medhurst, so a Didak trade + Pick for RoK would be the most likely scenario in my book. Not sure how I would feel about picking up Didak if I were you guys though.. is vomit an emotion?
Really tired of reading the old "no bargaining power" line from every Big Footy expert.
Do you really believe RoK will tell Sydney "Trade me to x or I'll go in the PSD and play for Melbourne" ? No, he wont. If a suitable trade isn't found he'll be playing for Sydney next year. I'm 99% sure of this!
Do you really believe RoK will tell Sydney "Trade me to x or I'll go in the PSD and play for Melbourne" ? No, he wont. If a suitable trade isn't found he'll be playing for Sydney next year. I'm 99% sure of this!
- Banned
- #223
NathanMurray
Debutant
I think three players will be involved in the trade.
Farren Ray
Ryan O'Keefe
Daniel Kerr
obviously draft picks will come involved ..but them players will be in it.. (I think)
Farren Ray
Ryan O'Keefe
Daniel Kerr
obviously draft picks will come involved ..but them players will be in it.. (I think
)
- Status
