Opinion Sack Hinkley 3 - 2021 is worse than 2020 already

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
How could anyone revere Hinkley? I suppose it's possible to like him or respect him or even think he does a good job, but revere? Lol.
 
PowerLil said:
Everyone who works with Hinkley reveres him. This is not true.
Click to expand...
Do you have any evidence that it isn't true? Players very rarely leave unless they are pushed or get massive offers at other clubs. Any player that comments on him in the media is overwhelmingly positive. Just recently I saw Jack Watts say he is a "great coach" and heaped praise on him. Players have openly said they came to Port Adelaide because of Hinkley (Dixon, Mckenzie) or stayed at Port because of him (Wines).

Assistant coaches very rarely leave, and when they do its a result of going into a senior gig (Richo, Walsh) or getting pushed out the door (Rehn, Carr, Thompson etc.).

The media loves the bloke. Rucci, Whately et. al. all think he is the reincarnation of Norm Smith.

Granted there is some sampling bias here, but you rarely see the outpouring of positivity about a coach like Hinkley gets.

The only group of people that openly dislike him are a group of fans, seemingly mostly confined to this forum lol.
 
JakeNeadeFan said:
Everyone who works with Hinkley reveres him. ....
Click to expand...
If someone asks you what you think of your boss and you know your answer will not only reach your boss but many, many people what would you say?

Even given that, I have heard nothing from any of our assistant coaches that sounds like reverence towards Hinkley.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

JakeNeadeFan said:
Do you have any evidence that it isn't true? Players very rarely leave unless they are pushed or get massive offers at other clubs. Any player that comments on him in the media is overwhelmingly positive. Just recently I saw Jack Watts say he is a "great coach" and heaped praise on him. Players have openly said they came to Port Adelaide because of Hinkley (Dixon, Mckenzie) or stayed at Port because of him (Wines).

Assistant coaches very rarely leave, and when they do its a result of going into a senior gig (Richo, Walsh) or getting pushed out the door (Rehn, Carr, Thompson etc.).

The media loves the bloke. Rucci, Whately et. al. all think he is the reincarnation of Norm Smith.

Granted there is some sampling bias here, but you rarely see the outpouring of positivity about a coach like Hinkley gets.

The only group of people that openly dislike him are a group of fans, seemingly mostly confined to this forum lol.
Click to expand...
1620374692121.jpeg
 
Steve Dore said:
If someone asks you what you think of your boss and you know your answer will not only reach your boss but many, many people what would you say?

Even given that, I have heard nothing from any of our assistant coaches that sounds like reverence towards Hinkley.
Click to expand...

www.youngwitness.com.au

Port's Hinkley tips test from AFL protege

Port Adelaide's Ken Hinkley says his coaching duel with one-time protege Matthew Nicks will have little influence on...
www.youngwitness.com.au www.youngwitness.com.au

1620374891283.png

1620375426839.png
 
Last edited:
JakeNeadeFan said:
Do you have any evidence that it isn't true? Players very rarely leave unless they are pushed or get massive offers at other clubs. Any player that comments on him in the media is overwhelmingly positive. Just recently I saw Jack Watts say he is a "great coach" and heaped praise on him. Players have openly said they came to Port Adelaide because of Hinkley (Dixon, Mckenzie) or stayed at Port because of him (Wines).

Assistant coaches very rarely leave, and when they do its a result of going into a senior gig (Richo, Walsh) or getting pushed out the door (Rehn, Carr, Thompson etc.).

The media loves the bloke. Rucci, Whately et. al. all think he is the reincarnation of Norm Smith.

Granted there is some sampling bias here, but you rarely see the outpouring of positivity about a coach like Hinkley gets.

The only group of people that openly dislike him are a group of fans, seemingly mostly confined to this forum lol.
Click to expand...
It's not a matter if we like or dislike him, this is not personal I am sure he's a nice bloke, this is about results and his capabilities to get us to a flag. Surely if we don't go all the way this year you would have to ask the question, 9 years and nothing and over 60 players have come and gone in that time.
 
Slightly off track to this hate thread but of all of our coaching staff, management etc I reckon the bloke who would make the best coach of all of them is CD. CD just oozes wanting to be the best at everything he touches and would never accept anything but ultimate success.
Anyway, just spitballing.
 
Harris Milstead said:
Slightly off track to this hate thread but of all of our coaching staff, management etc I reckon the bloke who would make the best coach of all of them is CD. CD just oozes wanting to be the best at everything he touches and would never accept anything but ultimate success.
Anyway, just spitballing.
Click to expand...
#cdforcoach
 
Us against the rest said:
It's not a matter if we like or dislike him, this is not personal I am sure he's a nice bloke, this is about results and his capabilities to get us to a flag. Surely if we don't go all the way this year you would have to ask the question, 9 years and nothing and over 60 players have come and gone in that time.
Click to expand...

CC0BCCBF-6DF1-471F-9856-90992689D585.jpeg
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

PowerLil said:
Nicks coached his team to their first wooden spoon and Richardson got the sack from St Kilda with 43 W 81 L record. Not exactly glowing endorsements if they are your protege's.
Click to expand...
If you recall, that was my point. No Hinkley disciples!
 
JakeNeadeFan said:
Do you have any evidence that it isn't true?
Click to expand...

Carn.

It's a tiny little industry. You've got less than 1000 people in the playing and coaching ranks at any given time. Unless players have proven themselves as very good, it's career suicide to tell anyone publicly if you dislike your coach. And even then it'll likely affect your chances of getting a gig as an assistant or within the media because the media rely on access.

The media love Hinkley because he gives them plenty of time and access.

In any case, none of this makes him a good coach. Do you think the likes of Clarkson, Bomber Thompson or Leigh Matthews were universally liked? Sure, some great coaches are, but it's certainly not a prerequisite.

That said, I absolutely agree with your original point that internal coaching appointments are a big risk, even if you're coming from a successful program and culture and have been grooming a coach for some time. I certainly don't think our current program and culture has been successful and i'd rather go an get a mastermind from a club with a successful culture.
 
manureid said:
Imagine a world where you kept your job despite being a failure over almost 10 years, and the reason you keep it is because a few people at work like you.
Click to expand...

Sounds like most public servants (I’m one myself fwiw)
 
El_Scorcho said:
Carn.

It's a tiny little industry. You've got less than 1000 people in the playing and coaching ranks at any given time. Unless players have proven themselves as very good, it's career suicide to tell anyone publicly if you dislike your coach. And even then it'll likely affect your chances of getting a gig as an assistant or within the media because the media rely on access.

The media love Hinkley because he gives them plenty of time and access.

In any case, none of this makes him a good coach. Do you think the likes of Clarkson, Bomber Thompson or Leigh Matthews were universally liked? Sure, some great coaches are, but it's certainly not a prerequisite.

That said, I absolutely agree with your original point that internal coaching appointments are a big risk, even if you're coming from a successful program and culture and have been grooming a coach for some time. I certainly don't think our current program and culture has been successful and i'd rather go an get a mastermind from a club with a successful culture.
Click to expand...
Even if you discount the dialogue about Hinkley, actions speak louder than words. The club has very good retention of players and staff. The club is able to attract high quality players and staff from other clubs. Yes, no one is going to go out on their own in the media and bag him, but on the weight evidence you would say he is one of the more liked and respected coaches in the afl. When Watts, Wines, Boak etc talk about him they seem genuine enough anyway.

Yes I agree being a good bloke and respected doesn't make him a good coach. In fact I'm sure there are elements of being so affable and empathetic with the players that is to the detriment of his coaching ability. My argument was that because he is respected he has a lot of influence on the people around him. They get many 'learnings' from him as Nicks says.

And I don't want a Nicks type as our coach after Hinkley. Which I think we agree on.
 
Macca19 said:
hmmm.

R19 2000 - 67 point loss
R16 2001 - 34 point loss
QF 2001 - 32 point loss
R7 2002 - 57 point loss
PF 2002 - 56 point loss
R17 2003 - 1 point win
R11 2004 - 37 point loss
Click to expand...

Wonder what other club was sent to the Gabba every year from 2000-2004. We get a very raw deal with travel and the fixture most years.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

Alyx
  • Locked
Certified Legendary Thread Sack Hinkley 12 - Finals Are Scary
396 397 398 399 400
Replies
10K
Views
332K
rogerjames
rogerjames
Alyx
  • Locked
Opinion Sack Hinkley 11 - Gentlemen, this is democracy manifest
395 396 397 398 399
Replies
10K
Views
382K
PowerLil
PowerLil
KrispyKremeMullanikka
Certified Legendary Thread Sack Hinkley 13 - Another Crack At This
77 78 79 80 81
Replies
2K
Views
69K
Duckimus Prime
Duckimus Prime
GremioPower
Universal Love The “Sack Hinkley” >199-Post Club
2
Replies
49
Views
3K
GremioPower
GremioPower
sobrave
  • Locked
Opinion Sack Hinkley 10 - UnTENable
396 397 398 399 400
Replies
10K
Views
394K
Kickpuncher
Kickpuncher
SonOfKek
PAFC - Questionable signings under Hinkley
2 3
Replies
72
Views
3K
longdonkey
longdonkey
RussellEbertHandball
Coach Ken Hinkley - A Kim Beazley coach, a Dr Seuss game plan and BEREFT of ideas
2
Replies
41
Views
2K
RussellEbertHandball
RussellEbertHandball

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top