![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/sydney.png)
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Or another 100,000 1 line posts and as for your mateOnly to dream about you![]()
You are the best poster on here and I admire your footy knowledge
Brandon Jack is no genius - if he could see certain things I'm sure opposition coaches would've seen the same. In fact, they may have noted the same things from R1 but we were playing so well (especially Heeney and Chad) that it didn't really matter. When particular players are at the top of their game eg Bont, Cripps, Neale, Naicos, there's really not much that can be done to stop them and Heeney and Chad were at that level earlier in the season.Lol the Jack hate is so over the top, seen plenty of ex players dissect their own teams, who gives a flying ****.
Some here just want to be angry about everything
Good summary caesar88, thanks.I read the Brandon Jack article on CODE. It's no secret I am a midfield nuffy (NOT an expert, as I have been accused of considering myself to be!!), so I absolutely loved it. He added no hyperbole and paid everyone their dues, and pretty much just analysed a bunch of different scenarios from the Geelong & Adelaide games, explained how our mids set up in them, and how he would try to prevent those scenarios if he were an opposition coach.
I'll try to summarise it as best as I can for those who don't have CODE:
Starts by going through the personnel and introduces them with one sentence: Heeney ("Main hit-to at stoppages"), Warner ("Starts more defensive side at stoppages and runs through"), Gulden ("Works back hard"), Rowbottom ("Disciplined, selfless"), Grundy ("Full 360-degree ruckman"), Papley ("will usually sweep at centre bounces") & Adams ("will let you get sucked into the contest")
Describes our strengths as ruck dominance & pro-active mids (mentions how formerly reactive we were), balanced & clearly defined roles, and multiple weapons at forward 50 stoppages.
Describes our weaknesses as "can get caught running forward and leaving the stoppage early", susceptible to elite opposition pressure, our slow starts & lapses in games (this is nothing new), and we become predictable when Grundy's out.
He then starts analysing the various examples of our set-ups, and goes on to offer tactics he'd deploy to hurt us. Hard to quote them here as he's gone so in-depth but if there's two constant themes throughout it would be: Stop Heeney from being the hit-to by blocking his run at the ball, and try to take Rowbottom where you want him at the contest, not where the Swans want him. Because Heeney's the "focal point" you need to try and make the ball drop where he is not. And because Rowbottom is the "anchor" you need to try and take him towards the other mids so he can't hold firm and keep the space for them.
(Jack does note multiple times that even in doing the above, you're likely opening up another bit of space for an alternative mid like a "sweeper" like Adams to get to the ball instead, but at least then it's not the Swans "dictating the terms.")
He also makes an interesting note that Grundy seems to rarely tap over his head, so whichever way his body is facing is where the ball will go.
That's about the best I can do folks. Hopefully someone can find a way to get around the paywall and share it, was a really interesting read. (Well at least I thought so.)
![]()
And more succinctly put....Good summary caesar88, thanks.
Brandon Jack is a polarising figure on here. For a variety of reasons.
Personally - I see him as just another journo trying to raise his profile - whether it’s by writing articles that appeal to the more progressive elements of society, or dissecting the Swans.
This latest article isn’t anything that opposition analysts wouldn’t have figured out ages ago. But I still suspect it’d make him just that little bit less welcome at the club.
His smug twitter comments do annoy me. Wish he’d learn to tone that aspect down.
I don't really have a problem with him. I assume he's probably still a Swans fan anyway.Good summary caesar88, thanks.
Brandon Jack is a polarising figure on here. For a variety of reasons.
Personally - I see him as just another journo trying to raise his profile - whether it’s by writing articles that appeal to the more progressive elements of society, or dissecting the Swans.
This latest article isn’t anything that opposition analysts wouldn’t have figured out ages ago. But I still suspect it’d make him just that little bit less welcome at the club.
His smug twitter comments do annoy me. Wish he’d learn to tone that aspect down.
Not a groundbreaking article by any means, but a refreshing read. Any article discussing our midfield that places more importance on Grundy & Rowbottom than Warner & Gulden gets my full kudos. And I reckon there's been a grand total of 1 of them.Good summary caesar88, thanks.
Brandon Jack is a polarising figure on here. For a variety of reasons.
Personally - I see him as just another journo trying to raise his profile - whether it’s by writing articles that appeal to the more progressive elements of society, or dissecting the Swans.
This latest article isn’t anything that opposition analysts wouldn’t have figured out ages ago. But I still suspect it’d make him just that little bit less welcome at the club.
His smug twitter comments do annoy me. Wish he’d learn to tone that aspect down.
I haven't read bj's article yet. Did he really offer any kind of ground breaking advice or was it all pretty basic stuff?I don't really have a problem with him. I assume he's probably still a Swans fan anyway.
If "don't tap it near Heeney" is the key wisdom he offered to opposition clubs after the first half of the season... I might just have a coaching career yet.
No current season stats available
Do not pass go, do not collect COLA!
Can see it now...
The last sentenceGood summary caesar88, thanks.
Brandon Jack is a polarising figure on here. For a variety of reasons.
Personally - I see him as just another journo trying to raise his profile - whether it’s by writing articles that appeal to the more progressive elements of society, or dissecting the Swans.
This latest article isn’t anything that opposition analysts wouldn’t have figured out ages ago. But I still suspect it’d make him just that little bit less welcome at the club.
His smug twitter comments do annoy me. Wish he’d learn to tone that aspect down.
This just confirms to me that nobody in the media actually watches our games.No one tipping Pies. What do we have to do to become the underdog ?!:
Waterworks is the 22GFCan see it now...
Parker Lane, Playfair the prime properties.
Piccadilly Stephens being unpopular.
Jesse Whitehall.
Why call it "Monopoly", can't have everyone.....
Can we just get the underdog tag again i like it like that rather than this favourite thingWe now return to our normal programming
![]()
Swans come from the clouds to snuff out Pies' flag defence
Sydney kicks the last five goals of the game to overrun Collingwood in a classicwww.afl.com.au
![]()
'One for the ages': Sydney's remarkable fourth-quarter heist deals hammer blow to Collingwood's finals hopes
Sydney's worrying form slump looked like it was set to continue until the AFL's ladder-leaders awoke from their slumber to stage an incredible comeback against Collingwood at the SCG.www.abc.net.au
![]()
Swans forge EPIC last quarter win amid umpiring controversy to sink Pies’ finals hopes
Swans forge EPIC last quarter win amid umpiring controversy to sink Pies’ finals hopeswww.foxsports.com.au
![]()
Swans win a thriller against Collingwood to keep their premiership hopes alive
The Sydney Swans have breathed life back into their season by staging a spectacular fourth-quarter comeback against Collingwood.www.theage.com.au
If anyone has us as favourites right now they are delusionalCan we just get the underdog tag again i like it like that rather than this favourite thing
I'm a fan of BJ's (usually) intelligent and thoughtful writing. It makes for a refreshing change from all the regular numpties who mostly just parrot each other.Not a groundbreaking article by any means, but a refreshing read. Any article discussing our midfield that places more importance on Grundy & Rowbottom than Warner & Gulden gets my full kudos. And I reckon there's been a grand total of 1 of them.
He should've just let it be and let his article speak for itself.