- Mar 1, 2010
- 24,274
- 17,689
- AFL Club
- Richmond
[We OTE="theflea, post: 35381206, member: 96345"]Did you edit my post? I didn't mention O'Keefe? Anyway you said the swans never beat up on anyone, so all I did was highlight this assertion was wrong.[/QUOTE]
We are talking about the 2014 Swans team , pros and cons, and why they got beat in the GF, including midfield composition. O'Keefe didn't play this year, that is what's relevant. So sure Swans won in 2012 with Okeefe but they had a different team then so that is apples and Oranges. I have highlighted I believe 2014 Swans weakness is their midfield as a group is too short. IMO not having O'Keefe like in 2012 supports this idea!
Apart from all that the 2012 GF was a close match which could have gone either way IMO so it couldn't be called a beat up surely!
We are talking about the 2014 Swans team , pros and cons, and why they got beat in the GF, including midfield composition. O'Keefe didn't play this year, that is what's relevant. So sure Swans won in 2012 with Okeefe but they had a different team then so that is apples and Oranges. I have highlighted I believe 2014 Swans weakness is their midfield as a group is too short. IMO not having O'Keefe like in 2012 supports this idea!
Apart from all that the 2012 GF was a close match which could have gone either way IMO so it couldn't be called a beat up surely!
Last edited: