kane249
Wibble
- Oct 27, 2006
- 53,028
- 71,565
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Sth Freo, Liverpool, Chicago Bulls
Have at it
Autopsy Positives and Negatives vs Port Adelaide
- Thread starter kane249
- Start date
- Tagged users None
HoneyBadger35
They're not going to pick him, Mitch.
- Aug 11, 2011
- 28,483
- 80,789
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Moderator
- #2
- Connor West is fun to watch.
- I like Tim Kelly. I like Tom Barrass.
- Jack Darling showed a bit more I suppose.
- 1st round pick will be massive.
- 2nd round pick will be slightly less massive.
- Also everything else.
Covid/Injuries/whatever reasons, legitimate or otherwise, the club had early to explain the output, the target for the season has to shift now. It’s folly to not embrace where we are at this point, club simply cannot ignore it and act like they’re just building up to a more ‘to script’ back end of the season.
Loved your work boys. Some great times had. Cheers for everything, on to the next.
- Oct 9, 2009
- 12,608
- 14,331
- AFL Club
- West Coast
We are completely cooked for the year, and there's nothing we can do to change that with the current personnel.
- Jun 7, 2015
- 1,289
- 4,903
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Negatives-
Matera92
Brownlow Medallist
- May 28, 2017
- 8,431
- 12,046
- AFL Club
- West Coast
-ve. That the club though we were in premiership calculations
+ve. Pick 1
+ve. Pick 1
RichmondEshays
Team Captain
- Sep 9, 2017
- 381
- 1,171
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, Larissa
How did naishy play?
Chump Change
Club Legend
- Apr 16, 2022
- 2,248
- 3,221
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Banned
- #12
- I'm calm. I don't even get slightly upset.
- Player X
+ve
We will see Clark next week hopefully.
Junk time goals.
Strad's looks better than Williams in the ruck.
-ve
The entire team is clueless about the game plan.
Team of 2018 has run out of puff. Time to hit the draft.
We will see Clark next week hopefully.
Junk time goals.
Strad's looks better than Williams in the ruck.
-ve
The entire team is clueless about the game plan.
Team of 2018 has run out of puff. Time to hit the draft.
Decent debut from Strnadica. The more youth we blood the better tbh.
The_Gambler
Club Legend
Positives
- Making it easy to move Shuey, Reddan, Kennedy, Hurn, Simpson on
- Unlikely to read a post from the Simpson Fan Boi's until teams are released Thursday
- Simpson's Fan Boi's being proved wrong again
- Number 1 draft pick
- Number 1 pick in the PSD
- Not many of the young or mid level players showing anything of promise for a career, many to get the chop at end of year
- No synergy
- All this talk of tackling practice all summer, absolutely pathetic
- No endurance or speed, got to at least have one
- Still have to listen to the press conference
+ I didn't watch the game as I went to the beach and brewery instead
+Surely the club will have to make changes after a few more weeks of this
-getting pumped by bottom teams mean this will be a long year
-being a seated member, I've pre-paid for all the home games
+Surely the club will have to make changes after a few more weeks of this
-getting pumped by bottom teams mean this will be a long year
-being a seated member, I've pre-paid for all the home games
Positives
An abundance of credits in the bank
An abundance of credits in the bank
Positives:
Negatives:
WC really need to nail at least a few high draft picks and bring real A-grade talent in over the next few years to avoid a sustained period towards the bottom of the ladder. If only 1 or 2 stars are drafted over the next few years then they'll not be contending for a decade.
- potential for the first top 5 pick in a longgggg time
- there were players out there trying their best (West, Redden, Kelly off the top of my head)
Negatives:
- most of the senior players are done and none of the younger players are lighting the world on fire.
- our best 22 more like the blorst 22. Three years of 'oh they finally have most of their best mids playing at the same time' only for said mids to be so ineffectual it's borderline hilarious.
WC really need to nail at least a few high draft picks and bring real A-grade talent in over the next few years to avoid a sustained period towards the bottom of the ladder. If only 1 or 2 stars are drafted over the next few years then they'll not be contending for a decade.
+
Kelly and Barrass. Darling is an idiot with self inflicted unfitness but kept at it.
It is a positive fact that we lack pace and aggression and have done so for years. As an easy beat club we have to play on the edge for 100 minutes.
-
Too many young players on a 10 year plan to make it. They will never get there. We need to replace XON, West, Waterman, Williams, Jones, Edwards, Foley, Witherden, and a few others.
Need a quality ruckman.
Coaching, tallent identification, fitness, medical and club leadership is below AFL standard.
Retire mid year JK and Hurn - cooked and going down hill fast.
Retire end of year Shuey and Redden, done.
Kelly and Barrass. Darling is an idiot with self inflicted unfitness but kept at it.
It is a positive fact that we lack pace and aggression and have done so for years. As an easy beat club we have to play on the edge for 100 minutes.
-
Too many young players on a 10 year plan to make it. They will never get there. We need to replace XON, West, Waterman, Williams, Jones, Edwards, Foley, Witherden, and a few others.
Need a quality ruckman.
Coaching, tallent identification, fitness, medical and club leadership is below AFL standard.
Retire mid year JK and Hurn - cooked and going down hill fast.
Retire end of year Shuey and Redden, done.
+no sign of Bomber Thompson eating a sandwich in the coaches box
-Aliir and Co on the Port bench laughing it up like its no worries. A team that's 0-5.
-Aliir and Co on the Port bench laughing it up like its no worries. A team that's 0-5.
+
Rozzee acceptance speech one of the worst I've heard
Kelly, Barass and Witho tried to carry the team.
West and Strnadica decent
-
Time to start rewarding games on form and not on credits. Love the premiership stars, but there is a real lack of leadership and intent, especially in the older players.
Front to back we are looking terribly low on confidence.
Still can't see the new game plan and our forward structure looks nonexistent.
Our tackling technique is horrible to watch. Rarely pin the opposition players' arms or disrupt the play.
Backing the club to turn it around, but it's getting harder to see how.
Rozzee acceptance speech one of the worst I've heard
Kelly, Barass and Witho tried to carry the team.
West and Strnadica decent
-
Time to start rewarding games on form and not on credits. Love the premiership stars, but there is a real lack of leadership and intent, especially in the older players.
Front to back we are looking terribly low on confidence.
Still can't see the new game plan and our forward structure looks nonexistent.
Our tackling technique is horrible to watch. Rarely pin the opposition players' arms or disrupt the play.
Backing the club to turn it around, but it's getting harder to see how.
Similar threads
