List Mgmt. 2022 Trade Thread - Part III

Remove this Banner Ad

Yes but you’re back to A needing a very good trade for Clarke and B those players being available. I can see both being around our pick and yes I rate them both. I’m not sure north have what we need and I don’t see then trading pick 3 so some mystery to finish the trade period. If they fold then happy days but anything less than a top 10 pick free and clear is a loss for us Imo.

No matter which way this falls with Clark stav is going to get a holiday for over use of the whip, haven’t seen a jokey use the whip like this in decades.
Trade our future first. Get into a position to take 2 top 10s.

Clark doesn’t have to get traded.

What holiday am I taking?
 
nicksplat GIF
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Yeah but north are in such good shape that you can forgive even a committed clubman for being helplessly drawn away.

Begs the question, what happened in-between the game when he got a compound fracture of the nose, was publicly loved by all Saints supporters, coaches and the media. Now he is seemingly on the outer... in the eyes of our esteemed brains trust.
 
Begs the question, what happened in-between the game when he got a compound fracture of the nose, was publicly loved by all Saints supporters, coaches and the media. Now he is seemingly on the outer... in the eyes of our esteemed brains trust.
Two different things, no doubt the brains trust would love his courage.

This does however not mean that he simply does not prepare himself in a manner to be the best footballer he can be .

Is he skilled yes is he tough yes is he courageous yes but if he won’t put the required work then maybe that is issue.
 
Two different things, no doubt the brains trust would love his courage.

This does however not mean that he simply does not prepare himself in a manner to be the best footballer he can be .

Is he skilled yes is he tough yes is he courageous yes but if he won’t put the required work then maybe that is issue.
it's only been explained 100 times
 
Trade our future first. Get into a position to take 2 top 10s.

Clark doesn’t have to get traded.

What holiday am I taking?
That’s interesting let’s see what happens. Overuse of the whip riding this Clark deal. I suggested trading our future first weeks ago so I’d be happy with that especially if it’s around the top 10. If nas wants out next year Adelaide will find a way or port have players we want.
 
We need more than that. We need our first round pick to be next level good. We need a Daicos, Rachele, Sonsie type of hope personified. We need to get the others right. Blowing picks on Allison types will waste another 5 years. As good as Nas, Windy and Owens were last season, that should be a level of expectation of most draftees not a special event. It's been a pretty spartan decade at the draft. King is pretty much the only high end player drafted in that period. Gresham probably the next best.

If we are going to mini rebuild we can't afford to get anything wrong or it could literally be 20 years gap between making prelims. 12 already gone in a competition that is designed to equalise. If we can do it inside a 15 year gap we will have done well from where we are now.
I agree with where you're coming from we need elite guys but Windhager has actually shown more than Sonsie hasn't he?
 
Let this be a lesson to everyone on how s**t the trade period really is. It's a fizzer every year.

Painful waiting for this to be over, like a night out with Dard Ball Get
When are you two gonna bone and get it over with?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Haha all I've been doing the past 2 weeks has been refreshing this page. That's why I was lost!
Currently caring for my wife who is recovering from neurosurgery.
Though I don't have a great deal to do. This thread has been used to waste some time!
Best wishes to you and your wife. I hope the recovery is going well.
 
Freo Adelaide Richmond were wins because of King.

He broke each of those games apart

Infact you can directly correlate our losses to his poor games. In fact in games King scores less than 2 goals, our record was: 1 win 5 losses.

In games were king kicked 3+: 7 wins 1 loss.

Simple view. But if King fires weekly. We win most weeks


Which is why you can't have one avenue to goal. It's pretty much the early Plugger years where one guy has to perform miracles to be competitive and if he doesn't we lose.
 
How will it make us better under any counts? He is a starting 22 player.

Even if we get pick 3, then it's still a gamble that the player selected turns out to be what we want or even need.

It also gives any St Kilda player the sign that they once they get to be of any value then they may be traded. Where's the loyalty?
Loyalty is a thing of the past unfortunately. You’ve got number one picks going home after a year, guys on million dollar seven year contracts being traded after two years and third year players on back ended deals being shafted. It’s purely business now.
 
Last edited:
Haha all I've been doing the past 2 weeks has been refreshing this page. That's why I was lost!
Currently caring for my wife who is recovering from neurosurgery.
Though I don't have a great deal to do. This thread has been used to waste some time!


Send her our best wishes Shags. That must be tough.
 
When are you two gonna bone and get it over with?
We could use a rotund, barrel-like man such as yourself to add a bit of extra flavour to the festivities. We've been together for so long that the standard lifting the leg over becomes a bit monotonous.

Please PM if interested.
 
I agree with where you're coming from we need elite guys but Windhager has actually shown more than Sonsie hasn't he?


Probably so far. I'm saying that should be an expectation. We are the only club that gets an Allison with our first pick and it's just normal recruiting for us. Hopefully that was what got Libba the arse.
 
Send her our best wishes Shags. That must be tough.
I would advise against it, if she's seen anything posted here she'll probably think we're part of an asylum. Could make her condition worse having to live through our well wishes.
 
Gringo wants the guys who were hyped on draft night.
Guys like Jack Martin.

Then he can brag to his mates until the season starts.

I don't get to brag much. :(
 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2022 Trade Thread - Part III

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top