Preview Round 5, 2024: GWS v St.Kilda - Manuka Oval, Saturday 13 April, 1:45pm AEST *GARCIA DEBUT*

[littlecreatures]

Silly thing is, that your somehow forgetting Sinclair, or are you seeing him as a permanant mid. now? And my suggestion that Windhager 185cm for Stocker 184cm is truly annoying some people, takes my cake?

I would be hardly including a running halfback as a defender, but perhaps that’s just my thoughts. If you’re expecting Sinclair to actually defend a small to medium forward, you’re absolutely having a laugh, which is where lies the issue if you drop Stocker

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

I would be hardly including a running halfback as a defender, but perhaps that’s just my thoughts. If you’re expecting Sinclair to actually defend a small to medium forward, you’re absolutely having a laugh, which is where lies the issue if you drop Stocker

Running half back is a defender or am I

I would be hardly including a running halfback as a defender, but perhaps that’s just my thoughts. If you’re expecting Sinclair to actually defend a small to medium forward, you’re absolutely having a laugh, which is where lies the issue if you drop Stocker

I kinda get your point on the running half-back but you still might wanna have a chat with Corey Enright on that one haha. And I'm getting tired of people making stuff up for their own agenda. No I didn't suggest Sinclair play on Toby Green. That's in your mind only.

 

[sammm]

Dow should be straight in gone are the days you run players in the 2s for weeks, have a look at Carlton Sam Walsh straight in & he had a debilitating back injury.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Sam Walsh had runs on the board, and Dow hasn't been at the club more than '2 minutes'

 

[littlecreatures]

Running half back is a defender or am I

I kinda get your point on the running half-back but you still might wanna have a chat with Corey Enright on that one haha. And I'm getting tired of people making stuff up for their own agenda. No I didn't suggest Sinclair play on Toby Green. That's in your mind only.

Who’s going to play on Toby Greene, Bedford and Daniel’s without stocker, noting Cordy, Battle and Wilkie will alternate with either Cadman and Hogan?

We’re not talking about Enright, we’re talking about the current structure and setup with Sinclair having never been an accountable defender, but perhaps you know something the rest of the AFL world doesn’t know.

 

[The Punter]

Last year's final aside, we have a recent good record against GWS and the ground suits us as well.

We play like we did against Collingwood we are every chance. Hopefully a nice, still, dry day.

 

[Klaatu]

Sam Walsh had runs on the board, and Dow hasn't been at the club more than '2 minutes'

No differance the club & RTB rate him & believe he is in our best 22, he mentions his break away speed many a times & our midfield as he said is spluttering.

 

[SteeleSaints]

Wow the matchups in this game are scary. GWS are absolutely flying so we are going to have play our best footy just to remain competitive IMO.

We havent played a 4 quarter game yet this year, it would be a great time to start Sainters.

 

[Dr Spaceman]

Would love to see GWS rest Kingsley this week and give Cameron another run.

 

[Jade Buddha]

Windhager, Stocker, Owens are our hard edge players. Under captain Steele.
None of them are going anywhere.

 

[Joffaboy]

Sam Walsh had runs on the board, and Dow hasn't been at the club more than '2 minutes'

Sorry, that has nothing to do with is he fit enough to play a full game of AFL.

Regardless of when he plays it will be his first game for us.

On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[beside the seaside]

Dow might have one run in the 2s, but he'll be into the first team very quickly. We didn't sign him to play VFL footy he's exactly what we need in the 1s.

 

[pebblesofsand]

Who’s going to play on Toby Greene, Bedford and Daniel’s without stocker, noting Cordy, Battle and Wilkie will alternate with either Cadman and Hogan?

We’re not talking about Enright, we’re talking about the current structure and setup with Sinclair having never been an accountable defender, but perhaps you know something the rest of the AFL world doesn’t know.

Not that our defence is man on man but defensively it would be

Cordy - Hogan
Battle - Cadman/Riccardi
Wilkie - Greene
Stocker - Bedford

The only problem with that is that that means either Sinclair or NWM will need to be playing on Callum Brown

 

[BrutThough]

Not that our defence is man on man but defensively it would be

Cordy - Hogan
Battle - Cadman/Riccardi
Wilkie - Greene
Stocker - Bedford

The only problem with that is that that means either Sinclair or NWM will need to be playing on Callum Brown

After the bath Cordy got in the final, Wilkie has to take Hogan.

 

[The Punter]

After the bath Cordy got in the final, Wilkie has to take Hogan.

So Cordy goes to Toby Greene?

Also, keep in mind that Dougal Howard may be available for selection this week.

 

[BrutThough]

So Cordy goes to Toby Greene?

Also, keep in mind that Dougal Howard may be available for selection this week.

I'd go

Wilkie - Hogan
Cordy - Cadman/Riccardi
Stocker - Greene
Sinclair/NWM/Bonner - Bedford

Battle can play loose/on Callum Brown

 

[akaifu]

I didn't state that Garcia would play on Greene haha. Actually suggested Windhager could in one of my posts.

Windhager as a lockdown medium defender? You've tried to justify stupid with stupid.

Silly thing is, that your somehow forgetting Sinclair, or are you seeing him as a permanant mid. now? And my suggestion that Windhager 185cm for Stocker 184cm is truly annoying some people, takes my cake?

Using height as a measure for likeness shows how much more you have to learn of the game.

 

[borderbarry]

I thought Cordy had a good game for us against Richmond.

 

[Remboy]

I thought Cordy had a good game for us against Richmond.

He did but he didn’t have much to beat. It will be a different story this week. Especially if he takes Hogan.

 

[akaifu]

I thought Cordy had a good game for us against Richmond.

Against Jacob Koszitchke who is useless and a 3-gamer I think? Just look at what happened in the EF against Giants and that'll tell you why hope Dougs can be back in to replace him this weekend.

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

Against Jacob Koszitchke who is useless and a 3-gamer I think? Just look at what happened in the EF against Giants and that'll tell you why hope Dougs can be back in to replace him this weekend.

The EF had more to do with how our midfield was going than Zlugger.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Klaatu]

Against Jacob Koszitchke who is useless and a 3-gamer I think? Just look at what happened in the EF against Giants and that'll tell you why hope Dougs can be back in to replace him this weekend.

Won't happen Cordy is playing well enough & it really comes down to the mid field pressure.
Kozisichke just played his 50th not 3rd game

 

[g_TRAIN]

Cordy will stand up as long as our midfield does.

 

[The_Steadier]

I reckon they have us well and truly covered on every line.

Me too.

Could we see some old school ross the boss?

Make it a negative scrap and 'park the bus'?

 

[akaifu]

Won't happen Cordy is playing well enough & it really comes down to the mid field pressure.
Kozisichke just played his 50th not 3rd game

3rd gamer comment was referring to Lefau

 

[Tommy Wigs]

GWS by eleventy hundred and nine