List Mgmt. 2019 Draft and Trade Hypotheticals Thread

[Cadsky]

Tucker - he came, he rehabbed, he left.

He didn't rehab. That's why he got delisted

 

[Cadsky]

And contracted so won’t be delisted!

Won't delist. Papley' s replacement

 

[swansfan51]

Very concerned about the lack of delistings. There are plenty more draft spots that should be opened up

 

[TheMase]

Tucker - he came, he rehabbed, he left.

Shame, looked like he had decent upside from his predraft footage.

 

[BruceFromBalnarring]

And contracted so won’t be delisted!

Yes. I checked after I posted but wanted to be quick on the smartarse.

Here's this year's list with a few suggested outcomes.

Thoughts?

Contract Expires - 2019:
Joel Amartey (Cat A Rookie - 2nd Year)
James Bell (Cat B Rookie - 2nd Year) Will be upgraded
Darcy Cameron To be traded
Robbie Fox
Cody Hirst (Cat A Rookie - Grundy Replacement)
Zak Jones To be traded
Michael Knoll (Cat A Rookie - Tippett Replacement)
Jack Maibaum (Long Term Injury List)
Hayden McLean (Cat A Rookie - Maibaum Replacement)
Daniel Menzel
Toby Pink (Cat A Rookie - 3rd Year)
James Rose
Durack Tucker (Cat A Rookie - 1st Year)
Sam Wicks (Cat B Rookie - 1st Year) Will be upgraded

 

[TheMase]

Pink will need to be upgraded if retained. He can’t be a 4th year rookie.

Wicks might stay Cat B if we don’t fill that list out.

I think we can have up to 3? If Bell gets upgraded and the Irish fellow comes in, I think we can have another (or two if Wicks is upgraded).

 

[The King!]

keep menzel

rest can go

 

[tombomb]

Yes. I checked after I posted but wanted to be quick on the smartarse.

Here's this year's list with a few suggested outcomes.

Thoughts?

Contract Expires - 2019:
Joel Amartey (Cat A Rookie - 2nd Year)
James Bell (Cat B Rookie - 2nd Year) Will be upgraded
Darcy Cameron To be traded
Robbie Fox
Cody Hirst (Cat A Rookie - Grundy Replacement)
Zak Jones To be traded
Michael Knoll (Cat A Rookie - Tippett Replacement)
Jack Maibaum (Long Term Injury List)
Hayden McLean (Cat A Rookie - Maibaum Replacement)
Daniel Menzel
Toby Pink (Cat A Rookie - 3rd Year)
James Rose
Durack Tucker (Cat A Rookie - 1st Year)
Sam Wicks (Cat B Rookie - 1st Year) Will be upgraded

i think (hope) menzel will get another 1 year deal

 

[Membling]

Very concerned about the lack of delistings. There are plenty more draft spots that should be opened up

With our retirements, have a few.

Also only need to delist one more IIRC.

That'd be seven list spots

 

[TheMase]

keep menzel

rest can go

I’d keep Wicks, Pink, Hirst, McLean and maybe Menzel. Not that fussed on the rest.

 

[Superstar swan]

Bit rough on tucker

 

[tombomb]

kind of glad we have nothing to do with the Kelly trade, some of the discussion around that is completely deranged.

 

[Cadsky]

Bit rough on tucker

Not if his body can't cope after the op. The club has had 12 month's to work it out

 

[Opts]

I’d keep Wicks, Pink, Hirst, McLean and maybe Menzel. Not that fussed on the rest.

Agree with that but I like Maibaum. He's never had a clear run but was doping well in the magoos prior to getting injured. Give him one more year to see if he remains injury free and can get into the side.

 

[TheMase]

Agree with that but I like Maibaum. He's never had a clear run but was doping well in the magoos prior to getting injured. Give him one more year to see if he remains injury free and can get into the side.

I have really like Maibaum as well, but I am not sure (nor am I in the position to determine) whether to persist with him.

It will be his 4th year on the list, one that might take a number of weeks or months into the year before he is fully fit (*assuming no complications). Therefore he may get towards the end next year / into his 5th year with no or very little senior football to his name.

Do you get a draftee and put that time into them instead? I guess that is the conundrum with my thoughts on Maibaum.

Pink has complicated things further by becoming a decent and improving defender (who is faster than Maibaum) throughout the year. He is entering his 4th year as well but will be able to do a full preseason and put himself in line for senior games early in the year potentially.

 

[Opts]

I have really like Maibaum as well, but I am not sure (nor am I in the position to determine) whether to persist with him.

It will be his 4th year on the list, one that might take a number of weeks or months into the year before he is fully fit (*assuming no complications). Therefore he may get towards the end next year / into his 5th year with no or very little senior football to his name.

Do you get a draftee and put that time into them instead? I guess that is the conundrum with my thoughts on Maibaum.

Pink has complicated things further by becoming a decent and improving defender (who is faster than Maibaum) throughout the year. He is entering his 4th year as well but will be able to do a full preseason and put himself in line for senior games early in the year potentially.

Good point. It might come down to Pink vs Maibaum (not both) and given Pinks form this year he wins hands down.

 

[FreeAgent1]

kind of glad we have nothing to do with the Kelly trade, some of the discussion around that is completely deranged.

2000% their coach and list manager said “there is some talk with how good Tim is that we should even be contemplating trading him”

Wtf line is that? Let him go to the draft? Shoot yourselves in the foot. Crazy times!!!

 

[BruceFromBalnarring]

Agree with that but I like Maibaum. He's never had a clear run but was doping well in the magoos prior to getting injured. Give him one more year to see if he remains injury free and can get into the side.

So what you're saying is the injury was a cover up?

Third strike?

 

[tombomb]

2000% their coach and list manager said “there is some talk with how good Tim is that we should even be contemplating trading him”

Wtf line is that? Let him go to the draft? Shoot yourselves in the foot. Crazy times!!!

Dwayne Russell said yesterday that they should hold onto him for 12 months.

He wasn't joking ...

 

[mtooler]

Very concerned about the lack of delistings. There are plenty more draft spots that should be opened up

I don't mind it too much as it conceals our hand better with trades and trade targets I feel.

 

[BruceFromBalnarring]

I have really like Maibaum as well, but I am not sure (nor am I in the position to determine) whether to persist with him.

It will be his 4th year on the list, one that might take a number of weeks or months into the year before he is fully fit (*assuming no complications). Therefore he may get towards the end next year / into his 5th year with no or very little senior football to his name.

Do you get a draftee and put that time into them instead? I guess that is the conundrum with my thoughts on Maibaum.

Pink has complicated things further by becoming a decent and improving defender (who is faster than Maibaum) throughout the year. He is entering his 4th year as well but will be able to do a full preseason and put himself in line for senior games early in the year potentially.

Melican has a year to go. I'd be extending Maibaum for a year (and Pink) then deciding next year between the three.

There are already 5 coming off the senior list.

 

[FreeAgent1]

Dwayne Russell said yesterday that they should hold onto him for 12 months.

He wasn't joking ...

I just hate their holier than thou attitude as though the eagles did something wrong.

Then when danger wants to move home the crows are holding him hostage.

The cats are media darlings and it gives me the shits that no1 calls them on it

 

[mtooler]

To be fair, fans on Sydney's Facebook page believe Longmore is indisputably the greatest coach of all time.

To be fair I have pursued a multi year jihad on Swans facebook fans pages against Longmire, trying to restore balance to the force.

 

[SSwans2011]

To be fair I have pursued a multi year jihad on Swans facebook fans pages against Longmire, trying to restore balance to the force.

Not all heroes wear capes.

 

[GotTheGoodes]

To be fair I have pursued a multi year jihad on Swans facebook fans pages against Longmire, trying to restore balance to the force.

Ohhhh... That was you? I see....