List Mgmt. 2020 Trade Thread - Part I

[Dr Spaceman]

You could cull a dozen or so off our list and no-one would blink…

Mayo, Langlands, Alabakis, Marsh, Bell, Joyce, Clavarino, McKenzie, Phillips, Webster, Abbott, Austin, Brown, Roberton, Savage

 

[CaptainRisky]

A spot will probably open up with Clark moved to the middle and Geary just about stuffed.

He was stuffed and cooked weeks ago , just waiting for the spuds to brown up a bit more before we serve it up

 

[Premium]

I will be interesting who Gold Coast get rid of , they have 50 on there list and if the have to cut to 40 , it going to hurt considering they have pick 5 , 24 and 36 in this years draft.
With good sized contracts on Fiorini and Peter Wright they could well be forced out even 22yr old Brodie who has only played 1 game this year.

 

[CaptainRisky]

You could cull a dozen or so off our list and no-one would blink…

Mayo, Langlands, Alabakis, Marsh, Bell, Joyce, Clavarino, McKenzie, Phillips, Webster, Abbott, Austin, Brown, Roberton, Savage

Why would you cull Bell ? Although i like Clave if your being ruthless yes he can go with the rest of them

 

[CaptainRisky]

Do you like him

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

You could cull a dozen or so off our list and no-one would blink…

Mayo, Langlands, Alabakis, Marsh, Bell, Joyce, Clavarino, McKenzie, Phillips, Webster, Abbott, Austin, Brown, Roberton, Savage

Webster can seriously play, just needs a clean bill of health and consistency. A few years back he was dominating. Quick, bullet kick, great in the air for his size and agile as a cat.

We literally just drafted Bell... he's a long term ruck prospect

Roberton is a great player and is definitely worth a spot on the list

 

[Keg still on legs]

 

[kernelT]

Why would you cull Bell ? Although i like Clave if your being ruthless yes he can go with the rest of them

I dunno, if you were in a pinch to reduce the list then a 19 year old beanpole ruckmen taken as a rookie may be a long shot and a luxury to keep on your list, he could be 5 years away from seniors and then still no good like Pierce.

 

[Human Person]

I dunno, if you were in a pinch to reduce the list then a 19 year old beanpole ruckmen taken as a rookie may be a long shot and a luxury to keep on your list, he could be 5 years away from seniors and then still no good like Pierce.

All clubs have project players on their list, it's not a luxury. He's had no VFL to show his worth either.

 

[Human Person]

Ben Brown still without a deal for next year. I know we have King, but he could use some help, and there's not much there for when King needs a rest.

 

[BrutThough]

Ben Brown still without a deal for next year. I know we have King, but he could use some help, and there's not much there for when King needs a rest.

I know he is a good player, but I just cant stand the way he plays.

His run up is just embarrassing to watch and I hate the way he lumbers around just throwing his arms around like an inflatable at a used car joint.

I just couldn't cheer for him even if he was in our jumper.

 

[Human Person]

I know he is a good player, but I just cant stand the way he plays.

His run up is just embarrassing to watch and I hate the way he lumbers around just throwing his arms around like an inflatable at a used car joint.

I just couldn't cheer for him even if he was in our jumper.

I'd cheer the wins, the run up is funny but you can't deny it works for him.

 

[Premium]

They are talking about cutting the squads to 39 - if that is the case a few big calls to be made.
UNContracted

6 players will need to be culled and that is before anyone is drafted , so fully expect at least 10 players to be moved on.
Brown retired
Geary retired ?

 

[gringo2011]

You'd hope so.

Up until this shoulder injury he's barely missed a game for years.

He's always been such a flog, I'm not sure I could learn to love him.

 

[gringo2011]

None of them?

Delist all our HBFs and put together a team of wingmen. Should see if Polec is busy too.

 

[Browny2Carlisle]

I know he is a good player, but I just cant stand the way he plays.

His run up is just embarrassing to watch and I hate the way he lumbers around just throwing his arms around like an inflatable at a used car joint.

I just couldn't cheer for him even if he was in our jumper.

I'd hate to have to look at him every week. Flops every time he's near a ball. Won't be getting those free kicks at St Kilda.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

All clubs have project players on their list, it's not a luxury. He's had no VFL to show his worth either.

Under the scenario of a 38 man list it's a luxury, as is a 28 year old who does an ACL , etc etc.
It sucks big time.

 

[st_trav_ofWA]

Seriously though, I hope we keep Robbo for another year, even if he is the last player on the list. If there is any chance he can play again he should be with us.

need to nurse him to 100 games ... potential father/son selections

 

[bird_man]

He's always been such a flog, I'm not sure I could learn to love him.

Isaac Smith?

I thought he was one of those players most people like.

I've met him a couple of times and he seems like an absolute champion.

 

[bird_man]

Delist all our HBFs and put together a team of wingmen. Should see if Polec is busy too.

Isaac Smith isn't only a wingman though.

He's played a heap of footy on the forward flank and done exceptionally well, including through their 3 peat period.

 

[From 45]

I know he is a good player, but I just cant stand the way he plays.

His run up is just embarrassing to watch and I hate the way he lumbers around just throwing his arms around like an inflatable at a used car joint.

I just couldn't cheer for him even if he was in our jumper.

I reckon he's the most overrated player in the league. He moves around the ground like a baby giraffe.

Absolutely woeful below his knees and is useless when the ball hits the ground.

If you allow him to run and jump at the ball, he's impossible to spoil because he's so big but he's been found out and he has nothing else left.

Plus he stinks and I'm sure he married his sister

 

[SaintersUnite]

Isaac Smith?

I thought he was one of those players most people like.

I've met him a couple of times and he seems like an absolute champion.

I think he was referring to Ben Brown.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Joffaboy]

Remember when people were angry we missed Jasper Pittard?

Lol

 

[hayes]

Majak Daw as a CHB get it done. He was awesome in that position in 2018, staggering he wasn’t played there this year.

 

[Human Person]

Shame Caldwel isn't playing tonight. would've liked to have looked at him more closely.