List Mgmt. 2022 Trade Thread - Part III

[St Neil]

I’m not dressing it up as a good thing.

If we trade Clark. I want a pick this year.

Correct.

 

[stavro#4]

West Coast and gws got reamed in that mega deal.

GWS got exactly what they wanted.

West coast will take Busslinger.

North effectively traded 2 number 1 picks

For pick 2+ 3 and a future first most likely pick 15ish

 

[phantom13]

They went 10-6 after there bad start. I wouldn’t bank on them losing so many games and having so many injuries.

Joffa. I agree.

Let’s see.

Finished 2nd in 2021 as well and haven’t exactly lost too much since then.

 

[Veer Right]

That is a horrible deal for North.

JHF = pick 2
Pick one = pick 3 and something like pick 9 as unlikely Port make next years top 8

Like i said the other day, this lands them Wardlaw, Sheezel and Clark. Big win for them unless Cadman is the next superstar CHF.

So now does our club turn down Ports pick. I'd like to think not.

 

[billings2paddy]

If the Club thinks Clark doesn’t have the commitment or ability to fulfil his role then I trust them to get a good deal for him knowing he is contracted. If he stays, then great, I hope he blitzes, he’s happy and we’re happy and he re-signs wondering why he ever thought about leaving.

I wouldn't ne

They went 10-6 after there bad start. I wouldn’t bank on them losing so many games and having so many injuries.

Joffa. I agree.

Let’s see.

Port have had the second most 1st rounders in the last 4 to 5 years alot of potential a grade talent.
Add jhf will easily by top 6 with or without the 11th easiest draw making it far more challenging with our current list to make the 8

 

[Ads734]

Someone designed his fitness program and he apparently met it. So they are saying that the club sanctioned program is inadequate? Most clubs don't allow players to add extra training onto their individual program so as not to over work the player.

Something about this sounds like a load of bullshit. Players doing the club program but needing to pay their own money to train to AFL standard is the kind of s**t you'd expect at the Suns.

We’ll said Gringo

 

[lewdogs]

Shocking for North. Actually feel sorry for them.

 

[St Neil]

That is a horrible deal for North.

North have effectively traded two 1st RDPs for picks 2, 3 and a future 1st RDP which could be in the 8-12 range.

Chuck in a couple of early 3rd RDPs this year.

Yuck!

 

[_Maximus_12]

I wouldn't ne

Port have had the second most 1st rounders in the last 4 to 5 years alot of potential a grade talent.
Add jhf will easily by top 6 with or without the 11th easiest draw making it far more challenging with our current list to make the 8

They still have a bog average forward mix and a bog average back half.

 

[Joffaboy]

Ablett did it all his time at Geelong, same with Selwood, players from all clubs do it all the time,

Someone designed his fitness program and he apparently met it. So they are saying that the club sanctioned program is inadequate? Most clubs don't allow players to add extra training onto their individual program so as not to over work the player.

Something about this sounds like a load of bullshit. Players doing the club program but needing to pay their own money to train to AFL standard is the kind of s**t you'd expect at the Suns.

Ablett did it all his time at Geelong, same with Selwood, players from all clubs do it all the time, really, if you don't know that this happens at every club you really shouldn't comment.

 

[Nutsngum]

That is a horrible deal for North.

Thats also a horrible deal for West Coast. Lose out on a pick in the real pointy end of the draft and one in the low teens.

 

[_Maximus_12]

Let’s see how much North want Hunter.

 

[Joffaboy]

Shocking for North. Actually feel sorry for them.

Tells you they are desperate, reckon if we hold our nerve they will buckle for at least pick 3.

 

[Tommy Wigs]

Log on .... see there is 12 pages to go through ..... go to the last page and after a few posts come to the realisation no further trades are done and the previous 11 unread pages would be nothing but trivial banter amongst a bunch of hard-core trade news desperados that have nothing to do at work

 

[BrutThough]

That is a horrible deal for North.

Based off this, we might be able to get pick 3 for Clark.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Let’s see how much North want Hunter.

Future 1st and pick 3 for Clark and pick 9 sounds reasonable.... to me.

 

[Dr Spaceman]

I have a sickening feeling about that Port future first North are going to land

If that happens we’re betting on port having a lousy year and loosing 1 of our most talented youngsters. When we have pick 12 or worse and have watched Clark help north improve the mood of supporters should be fantastic. Surely even st kilda aren’t stupid enough to role the dice on that deal.

I don’t put stupid past these guys.

 

[billings2paddy]

They still have a bog average forward mix and a bog average back half.

And with that average forward mix and average back half without Jhf they still beat us this year

 

[Joffaboy]

Future 1st and pick 3 for Clark and pick 9 sounds reasonable.... to me.

Even Norths future first, I would do. Not the one linked to Port.

 

[BrutThough]

Thats also a horrible deal for West Coast. Lose out on a pick in the real pointy end of the draft and one in the low teens.

Puts them in the range for the best WA kid and then get an additional first rounder. That’s a good deal for them.

 

[St Neil]

Tells you they are desperate, reckon if we hold our nerve they will buckle for at least pick 3.

Presumably they would want a pick going back.

It won’t be pick 9 though.

 

[Veer Right]

Was there a firesale on acid today?

 

[Joffaboy]

Presumably they would want a pick going back.

It won’t be pick 9 though.

Clark and 32 for pick 3?

In: 3,Cordy
Out: Clark, Long.

yeah fair enough

 

[TassieSaint]

Funny everyone has a different perspective, I reckon GWS have got reamed there whilst everyone else about broke even. Looking at the ins vs outs of much rather have GWS original hand. Is there really such a big difference between pick 1 and 3 this year ?

 

[_Maximus_12]

And with that average forward mix and average back half without Jhf they still beat us this year

So did 3/4 of the competition, don’t use us a metric for success