List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading

[ClaudeCurlsCrow]

Heeney to the Crows?

View attachment 2043290

why would he come to adelaide?
he is a local sydney boy and a superstar for the swans

 

[1990crow]

why would he come to adelaide?
he is a local sydney boy and a superstar for the swans

 

[Trigger13]

Collingwood does not have a first round pick this year.

Well isn’t that just typical

 

[arrowman]

Collingwood does not have a first round pick this year.

Yes, their picks are currently 26, 44 and 48 according to Zerohanger. We're not getting 26.

 

[Sizzlepack]

ok, what can we realistically get for Keene? Because it sounds like he’s gone. Is there a world where we play hardball and get a late first rounder?

This really could be a good move for all parties.

Why does it sound like he's gone?

Keane is contracted and Collingwood have ~zero draft capital, so unless they're putting McReery or Harvey Harrison on the table, we shouldn't pick up the phone.

 

[ClaudeCurlsCrow]

Why does it sound like he's gone?

Keane is contracted and Collingwood have ~zero draft capital, so unless they're putting McReery or Harvey Harrison on the table, we shouldn't pick up the phone.

trade both to us and they can have Keane back.

 

[Bob Neil]

I actually think Bond is one to keep as we are in need of a tough small/mid one on one defender. At the moment we have Max playing that role but he needs to be released.

If they won't play Murphy in a lock down role then Bond is the one.

I suggested (probably forlornly) that they throw Laird back in that role with Hamill out but assuming that won't happen then I'd also like to see Bond given a go as it is a genuine need and that appears to be his only role so before we give him the flick let's see what he can do.

 

[George Kramer]

Yes, their picks are currently 26, 44 and 48 according to Zerohanger. We're not getting 26.

Well he doesn’t go then, no way should we be taking anything less.

 

[Scorpus]

Yes, their picks are currently 26, 44 and 48 according to Zerohanger. We're not getting 26.

Keane is better than Ratugolea who was traded for pick 25, and Keane is contracted

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Would Collingwood put McCreery or Harrison on the table?

 

[Sizzlepack]

Would Collingwood put McCreery or Harrison on the table?

If they're not willing to cough up their 2025 first, we should definitely ask for one of those guys.

 

[1990crow]

Keane is better than Ratugolea who was traded for pick 25, and Keane is contracted

Pies future first for our future second and Keane?
Then ontrade that with Berry for Phillipou?

Could also trade our 2025 first into this year as well.

Could then have Phillipou, pick 4 (Lalor?) and Pick 8 via GC (Draper)?

 

[Scorpus]

Pies future first for our future second and Keane?

Not sure there will be much difference between those picks

 

[GreyCrow]

Pies future first for our future second and Keane?

Would put that between pick 18 and 10? Is that a fair evaluation of where they are?

 

[George Kramer]

Pies future first for our future second and Keane?

We didn’t give a future second, we have no need, he’s contracted

 

[1990crow]

We didn’t give a future second, we have no need, he’s contracted

I'm trying to be anti playstation and pessimistic.

 

[GreyCrow]

If we are thinking - IF - of trading our future 1st then getting one back is an option

 

[1990crow]

If we are thinking - IF - of trading our future 1st then getting one back is an option

Depends what we can get this year. Lots to play out.

Ie. Does Curtin ask for a trade? He's contracted for another 2 years so you'd ask for West Coasts pick 3 straight up.

Keane, Berry, Phillipou merry go round?

Opportunity to get Draper with a low top 10 pick via GC who don't need that pick, and a pick 4 midfielder on top.

If you could come out of this trade period with Phillipou, Draper, Lalor, Welsh, Cumming and a small forward (Champion?) you'd be happy.

Then solve ruck problem in 2025 with Draper as a free agent, ROB goes home, and get Goad as a developing ruck.

 

[arrowman]

Keane is better than Ratugolea who was traded for pick 25, and Keane is contracted

Oh I agree that it would be fair to ask for it, just that IMO the Pies won't be willing to give up their only pick before 44.

Edit: But having read the latest posts in the Keane thread, maybe they would... Certainly it should be the minimum starting point.

 

[Trigger13]

Why does it sound like he's gone?

Keane is contracted and Collingwood have ~zero draft capital, so unless they're putting McReery or Harvey Harrison on the table, we shouldn't pick up the phone.

Well, he wants to go it seems. Whether he does or not is another story. Agreed. Would love Mcreery

 

[Sizzlepack]

Well, he wants to go it seems. Whether he does or not is another story. Agreed. Would love Mcreery

Yeah, I hadn't heard the SEN interview when I posted that. Agree it sounds like he's got one foot out the door.

 

[Mostyn]

I feel sorry for Butts. He is chained to FB by the coaches and completely constrained. Did you see the determination and enjoyment on his face when he ran freely towards the end of the match and drilled a superb long pass to Fog who goaled?
I reckon he said stuff the coaches, I'm going for the win.

I think it's the opposite. The coaches have been trying to get him to contribute to attacking rebound for years

 

[Eddie Murphy]

Yes, their picks are currently 26, 44 and 48 according to Zerohanger. We're not getting 26.

I reckon Keane for 26 is pretty bang on the money. Both sides probably haggle over steak knives.

To be honest though, pies are looking for a Murphy replacement to allow Moore to roam more freely. If they’re looking for a defensively accountable key back I’m not sure Keane is their answer.

 

[Mutineer]

I think it's the opposite. The coaches have been trying to get him to contribute to attacking rebound for years

Rubbish, the other way around is more likely....never, ever played like that coming through his 3 years at the Murray Bushrangers, the exact opposite.

 

[Mutineer]

I reckon Keane for 26 is pretty bang on the money. Both sides probably haggle over steak knives.

To be honest though, pies are looking for a Murphy replacement to allow Moore to roam more freely. If they’re looking for a defensively accountable key back I’m not sure Keane is their answer.

Nope, he's contracted, we hold the aces.