Rumour 2024 Rumours and Speculation Part 3

[Trigger13]

There is a common feeling across clubland that Tyler Welsh has a very poor attitude and work ethic. This is info ive just been told by someone in player management. And it makes complete sense given his poor testing and body composition. I’m leaning toward us not taking him. Maybe as a speculative rookie. What a fall from grace.

 

[Samcro24]

I guess we don't want to be too committed in case an early bid comes in and we decide we'd rather wait.

I guess there is also the possibility that we orchestrate a pick trade to get back into the draft and just avoid taking him altogether.

Rookie spot seems ideal.

Getting Jarman Edwards vibes.

 

[CrowToon]

Fox Sports will give us a C.

But anyone who has a single clue knows this is an A trade period.

Any other position is not defendable and speaks to your own inability to ever be satisfied.

Or just thinks every trade period should play out like its on a Playstation game

Edit: Reading some comments about ruck depth...seriously that's where people think our season hinges on? Wowee

 

[cleanhands]

There is a common feeling across clubland that Tyler Welsh has a very poor attitude and work ethic. This is info ive just been told by someone in player management. And it makes complete sense given his poor testing and body composition. I’m leaning toward us not taking him. Maybe as a speculative rookie. What a fall from grace.

What a coincidence

 

[FullyBigKPro]

Our Future 1st and 2 x Future 3rds for Richmond's 10 and 18 ?

 

[Cromulant]

No excuse for not using 43 in this draft

Well there is.

Pay out a contract, shift a F1 into this draft and match a late bid for Welsh.

No need for 43

 

[pjcrows]

One of Richmond's firsts will be gettable if you're willing to offload a future first + something.

 

[Trigger13]

What a coincidence

No coincidence. It’s just how recruiters feel. Really disappointing. His dad was similar. But you could rely on natural talent more in those days.

Scott would smoke the darts in season

 

[Mutineer]

There is a common feeling across clubland that Tyler Welsh has a very poor attitude and work ethic. This is info ive just been told by someone in player management. And it makes complete sense given his poor testing and body composition. I’m leaning toward us not taking him. Maybe as a speculative rookie. What a fall from grace.

Don't tell 119others he won't have it, he's still going down that "tanking"road.

 

[Runnin Blue]

B+ still stuck with our shit rucks

That internet rage could be oh so profitable to you focused on something else, Basement.

Take a day off. Get some sun. The world will be turning tomorrow. Lol.

 

[cleanhands]

No coincidence. It’s just how recruiters feel. Really disappointing. His dad was similar. But you could rely on natural talent more in those days.

There’s been a lot of dry humping on here about Tyler, and now

 

[George Kramer]

Well there is.

Pay out a contract, shift a F1 into this draft and match a late bid for Welsh.

No need for 43

Huh? There’s talk Welsh could slip to the rookie draft given that’s how he’s rated. But there would clearly be good players available at 43 who will be in demand more than Welsh, why wouldn’t we choose a better player if we still had that pick?

 

[Mutineer]

There’s been a lot of dry humping on here about Tyler, and now

Not really, he has the talent , the question has always been his attitude and work ethic.

 

[FullyBigKPro]

Fox Sports will give us a C.

But anyone who has a single clue knows this is an A trade period.

Any other position is not defendable and speaks to your own inability to ever be satisfied.

Or just thinks every trade period should play out like its on a Playstation game

Edit: Reading some comments about ruck depth...seriously that's where people think our season hinges on? Wowee

Its a very solid trade period, but outside pick 4, we have nothing in a supposed super draft when we are desperate for elite mids and still haven't addressed anything long term RE our rucks.

We are OVER stocked for half backs (Smith , Cumming, Hinge, Michelanney, Milera, Jones etc) and mid/forward hybrids (Rankine, Rachelle, Peatling, ANB, Keays, Murphy, Pedlar etc) now.

Pick 4 now becomes absolutely massive to this offseason and what we do with it/select.

 

[Cromulant]

Huh? There’s talk Welsh could slip to the rookie draft given that’s how he’s rated. But there would clearly be good players available at 43 who will be in demand more than Welsh, why wouldn’t we choose a better player if we still had that pick?

And I'm saying we could easily trade back in.

Something we've done in the past.

 

[Cromulant]

Its a very solid trade period, but outside pick 4, we have nothing in a supposed super draft when we are desperate for elite mids and still haven't addressed anything long term RE our rucks.

We are OVER stocked for half backs (Smith , Cumming, Hinge, Michelanney, Milera, Jones etc) and mid/forward hybrids (Rankine, Rachelle, Peatling, ANB, Keays, Murphy, Pedlar etc) now.

Pick 4 now becomes absolutely massive to this offseason and what we do with it/select.

It's Rachele FFS

 

[George Kramer]

That internet rage could be oh so profitable to you focused on something else, Basement.

Take a day off. Get some sun. The world will be turning tomorrow. Lol.

lol seems someone is projecting, given your habit of drinking yourself to sleep each night.

And hardly raging, I’ve said we done very well, a B+ even, but to get an A we needed to have addressed our rucks or at least had another pick in a strong draft. If you consider that raging, you need to get out more.

 

[jenny61_99]

Look I don't think these particular jokes were funny but if you can't simply scroll past them then I don't think the internet is for you.

OR, I could ask people to be mindful about what they post. Can’t change the world overnight, but slowly by slowly it’ll change. And clearly you’ve never been traumatised. These things are impossible to unsee and they stab you right in the guts. There are lots of people here who have stories that we don’t know. It doesn’t hurt to think about things - and others - before you post. That’s all.

 

[FullyBigKPro]

It's Rachele FFS

You think he will become an elite mid next year?

 

[George Kramer]

And I'm saying we could easily trade back in.

Something we've done in the past.

Why would we need to trade back in if we already had the pick? What was the purpose of moving into next year? And how many clubs are giving up a spot in this deep draft?

 

[Cromulant]

Why would we need to trade back in if we already had the pick? And how many clubs are giving up a spot in this deep draft?

At 43... probably a few.

 

[krrzr]

There is a common feeling across clubland that Tyler Welsh has a very poor attitude and work ethic. This is info ive just been told by someone in player management. And it makes complete sense given his poor testing and body composition. I’m leaning toward us not taking him. Maybe as a speculative rookie. What a fall from grace.

Swear to god if we keep Chris ******* Burgess over drafting Welsh

 

[George Kramer]

At 43... probably a few.

Cmon, that’s clutching and wouldn’t it have made more sense to trade it out on the night where you get more value if someone wanted a player?

 

[Cromulant]

Swear to god if we keep Chris ******* Burgess over drafting Welsh

Then Tyler only has himself to blame.

 

[George Kramer]

Swear to god if we keep Chris ******* Burgess over drafting Welsh

Well we’ve kept him over using pick 43 in a deep draft…..