If Carlton are going to have a swing at Petracca using #3 you'd think they would need to clean up some fringe player cash & add some more draft capital.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. 2024 Trade Thread - No.3
- Thread starter SainterinSydney
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Mar 14, 2011
- 15,656
- 82,559
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Leeds united, Chicago Bulls
HeavenlySources
Team Captain
- Jul 17, 2024
- 594
- 1,685
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
We are a bit hamstrung until draft night, depending on what we do if we have late picks they could get eaten up or reduced by bids. We can still trade back in after using futures for late 40s-50s picks like we did last year
There's two components to it, decision making and execution. What he lacked in skill he made up for by playing within his limitations. We have Sinclair and Nas for our play-making out of defence, all we'd need from somebody like Kemp is for him to not turn it over, hence why Bonner isn't on the list anymore.
Having said that, I know nothing about Kemp, have literally never noticed him on the field before so I have no opinion on whether he'd be a wise pick up or not.
HeavenlySources
Team Captain
- Jul 17, 2024
- 594
- 1,685
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Well I guess we offered a F3 haha
Barrett is getting more and more ridiculous. He literally just picks a random position on any issue and then defends it until the cows come home.
"When all's said and done, this year's trade period is all about next year."
"When all's said and done, this year's trade period is all about next year."
HeavenlySources
Team Captain
- Jul 17, 2024
- 594
- 1,685
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Damo and Josh Jenkins, I don't think you could get a worse trade radio pairing
I'd rather Robbo chatting to himself for 2 hours
ha ha.. very true!
Correct.
Presumably a 3 way deal.
Macrae - Saints
Kennedy - Bulldogs
Pick ? - Carlton
Blues searching for trade capital cashing out Kennedy and Kemp.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Don't know. For my part I am sceptical about the importance of line coaches in setting strategy. The sport has moved a hundred miles away from there being three fragmented siloes on the ground which can be delegated to three different tacticians. I assume that Ross sets the whole of ground strategy, in consultation with the other coaches, and then line coaches are responsible for the day to day coaching of particular players, but consistently with the overarching strategy. For that reason, pinning blame on Harvey for the forward entries seems very naive to me.
Returning then to your question, I like the Bolton appointment because he comes from some very successful clubs, will have valuable intel about other teams and players, and seems like a good likeable personality to boot. It's very important for coaching panels to get this sort of regular cross-fertilisation from other clubs, which has not happened for us for two years.
Diehard Saint
Brownlow Medallist
Jason Blake, #27 wasn’t he?
Nothing to do with the price of anything, but still…we all loved Blakey too
HeavenlySources
Team Captain
- Jul 17, 2024
- 594
- 1,685
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
A quote from the Philosopher Josh Jenkins: "Be careful, if something is obvious it might be obvious for a good reason."
We'll be back with more wisdom from the great man shortly.
We'll be back with more wisdom from the great man shortly.
akaifu
Club Legend
- Feb 4, 2023
- 1,730
- 5,499
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
They are doing that because they have given up on O'Halloran
- Mar 14, 2011
- 15,656
- 82,559
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Leeds united, Chicago Bulls
18 minutes ago
BLUES UNLIKELY TO BOW TO SAINTS' KEMP INTEREST
Jon Ralph
Carlton is keen on keeping third defender Brodie Kemp despite St Kilda’s interest but might have their arm twisted if the Saints can come up with a quality 2024 national draft selection.
Carlton’s former list boss Steven Silvagni, now at St Kilda, is keen to bring across a player he drafted at the Blues with pick 17 in the 2019 national draft to replace departing free agent Josh Battle.
Kemp has not requested a trade and is happy at the Blues, having played 38 games for Carlton in the past two years as a mobile marking defender.
But the Blues are not totally ruling out a trade with the Saints so the chance of him moving is are alive until Wednesday’s 7.30pm trade deadline.
Having just secured pick three in the national draft, the Blues are content to secure an elite midfield talent with their earliest pick and then match bids on the Camporeale twins later in the draft.
St Kilda would need to offer up an early pick in the 2024 national draft to even have Carlton’s list management team considering whether Kemp was worth trading.
Carlton’s Jacob Weitering has just signed a new six-year deal and Lewis Young has had no takers so far, with Nick Haynes on a one-year deal as a free agent and Mitch McGovern still on the list.
So there is a key role for Kemp to play if he remains at the Blues.
St Kilda’s draft hand is picks seven, eight, 32, 45 and 47 after trading their pick 27 for the Lions 32 and 45 on Tuesday.
By the time rival clubs bid for academy players that No.32 draft selection will be only a handful of picks away from the 27 they traded away, so they secure more draft capital at the outlay of very few picks.
But the Saints would likely need to offer a top 25 pick for Kemp so the Blues could be sure they could take a pick to the draft before any bid for Camporeale
BLUES UNLIKELY TO BOW TO SAINTS' KEMP INTEREST
Jon Ralph
Carlton is keen on keeping third defender Brodie Kemp despite St Kilda’s interest but might have their arm twisted if the Saints can come up with a quality 2024 national draft selection.
Carlton’s former list boss Steven Silvagni, now at St Kilda, is keen to bring across a player he drafted at the Blues with pick 17 in the 2019 national draft to replace departing free agent Josh Battle.
Kemp has not requested a trade and is happy at the Blues, having played 38 games for Carlton in the past two years as a mobile marking defender.
But the Blues are not totally ruling out a trade with the Saints so the chance of him moving is are alive until Wednesday’s 7.30pm trade deadline.
Having just secured pick three in the national draft, the Blues are content to secure an elite midfield talent with their earliest pick and then match bids on the Camporeale twins later in the draft.
St Kilda would need to offer up an early pick in the 2024 national draft to even have Carlton’s list management team considering whether Kemp was worth trading.
Carlton’s Jacob Weitering has just signed a new six-year deal and Lewis Young has had no takers so far, with Nick Haynes on a one-year deal as a free agent and Mitch McGovern still on the list.
So there is a key role for Kemp to play if he remains at the Blues.
St Kilda’s draft hand is picks seven, eight, 32, 45 and 47 after trading their pick 27 for the Lions 32 and 45 on Tuesday.
By the time rival clubs bid for academy players that No.32 draft selection will be only a handful of picks away from the 27 they traded away, so they secure more draft capital at the outlay of very few picks.
But the Saints would likely need to offer a top 25 pick for Kemp so the Blues could be sure they could take a pick to the draft before any bid for Camporeale
Rogue Warrior
Senior List
- Mar 23, 2024
- 227
- 934
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Surely there is no way we give up a top 25 pick
Bulldogs upgrade 35 to 32, 48 to 45, and get 47.
Equivalent of pick 41.
They might do that if they can get Kennedy at the equivalent price.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
The dogs midfield is actually starting to look a bit shallow after being their strength for a decade. Bont is still the man, but Libba is one head knock away from retirement, Dunkley is gone, MacRae is past it/potentially gone, Sanders was a bit over hyped (for how ready he was, not necessarily his ceiling).
Kennedy wouldn't be a bad option for them, as he's probably better than MacRae in the position he was being played in.
Mat Mann
significantly pleased himself
St Kilda - Marcus Windhager Player Sponsor 2024
Veteran
St Kilda - Marcus Windhager Player Sponsor 2023
St Kilda - James Frawley Player Sponsor 2021
St Kilda - Doulton Langlands Player Sponsor 2020
Saints Pledge Contributor
St Kilda - Robbie Young Player Sponsor 2019
St Kilda - Nathan Freeman Player Sponsor 2018
- May 14, 2009
- 4,053
- 8,888
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Red Bull
- Moderator
- #923
Goddard out of line coaches at now Coach of Sandy and Development role - was mids coach
Rivers is in and will be Defensive line coach
Enright, I haven't heard, but It would make sense if he became Mids coach and takes on a more overarching role, with a view to his development as a future senior coach.
Bolton is out of the blue
maybe Bolton will take a directing role like he did at Pies
Similar threads
