-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
changes for Melbourne
- Thread starter bigman
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I dont think Sauce is going to be done, he tried to bump and his arm slipped due to the height difference, it wasn't deliberate, maybe just a reprimand.
Tambling should be done, was bloody stupid and Tipp is probably gone. IMO.
Davis seems to be have brought back in too quickly!
Out: Davis, Tambling, Tipp.
In: Gunston, Young, Sloane.
Tambling should be done, was bloody stupid and Tipp is probably gone. IMO.
Davis seems to be have brought back in too quickly!
Out: Davis, Tambling, Tipp.
In: Gunston, Young, Sloane.
Sloane if ready to go. Aiden Riley is worth considering if we need to replace a quick (or to let Martin geet some form in the SANFL?). We need to see how things pan out injury and report wise. The only one out at this stage is Davis. Scott Stevens would be the logical replacement but probably still not ready. We will have to see how everyone goes in the SANFL. Not a big fan but Sellar needs to put in a big one. Would be great to see young put in a grat game. No, not Maric please...anything but Maric!
- Banned
- #4
Tippet wont be out going on current afl trends he also has a good record.
Tambling is borderline could go either way, high elbow after being provoked but st kilda player acted a fair bit.
Jacobs not out either pure accident bumped his shoulder first before the head and with the height differnce he never lifted his elbow.
Tambling is borderline could go either way, high elbow after being provoked but st kilda player acted a fair bit.
Jacobs not out either pure accident bumped his shoulder first before the head and with the height differnce he never lifted his elbow.
So what did Tippett do? I cannot recall the incident.
Tambling will probably get a week or a reprimand. Pretty soft but it was a stupid move by Richard.
Sauce was a victim of his own height. Unlucky if he gets suspended.
fanfooty.com.au are claiming Johncock will "get weeks" for his contact on Riewoldt. Surely that was accidental. Riewoldt basically fell onto Johncock's shoulder.
Tambling will probably get a week or a reprimand. Pretty soft but it was a stupid move by Richard.
Sauce was a victim of his own height. Unlucky if he gets suspended.
fanfooty.com.au are claiming Johncock will "get weeks" for his contact on Riewoldt. Surely that was accidental. Riewoldt basically fell onto Johncock's shoulder.
All safe IMO. Tippett and Tambling may end up with reprimands but I'd expect both to be thrown out for the impact being too low to constitute a reportable offence. If ****ing Waite can get off with that mule kick then these guys will get off.
Already been said but others but Sauce's bump got a little big because of his height. Common sense should see this one thrown out too. Having said this, if we're relying on common sense from the MRP then he'll probably be outed for 6 weeks
Already been said but others but Sauce's bump got a little big because of his height. Common sense should see this one thrown out too. Having said this, if we're relying on common sense from the MRP then he'll probably be outed for 6 weeks
Cheap shot to Fisher's guts. Off the ball but very low impact.
cammo6556
Cancelled
10k Posts
Baghdad Bombers - Sweet F.A.
BeanCoiNFT Investor
Podcaster
Zombie Lover
A Star Wars Fan
that is ridiculous... Ive just lost respect for frequenters of that site...
Yeah, Riewoldt slipped and Johncock covered up - nothing he could've done. People are stupid though...I saw someone claim that Chaplin should get weeks for pushing Hansen when he ended up in the fence. The only thing that Chaplin should be charged with is impersonating a footballer...
- Sep 11, 2009
- 5,245
- 4,153
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Some Aints fan is saying Johncock should get 4 weeks plus 1 week for the gwilt hit.
I thought Tambling had more of a push action than a swinging action with his arm?
The rest will be fine.
As for changes, will Stevens be back?
Sloane for Hendo
Stevens for Davis
I thought Tambling had more of a push action than a swinging action with his arm?
The rest will be fine.
As for changes, will Stevens be back?
Sloane for Hendo
Stevens for Davis
OK, now I recall the incident. There was a bit going on back and forth between the two. Unlucky if he gets anything more than a reprimand. If Kurt gets suspended for that, surely whoever hit Knights in the opening minutes should get exactly the same.
Martin and Henderson very quiet, you'd let Martin off this week because he was quite good last week, but surely this is Henderson's last straw until he tears apart some games for Centrals.
the only thing Stiffy is guilty off is standing his ground, he did not move an inch and it would be an absolute disgrace to see him rubbed out
re Tambling, some concern there however given Judd got off last year for throwing an elbow Tambling might get lucky
can't recall the Tippett one however Sauce too would be unlucky to get rubbed out
re Tambling, some concern there however given Judd got off last year for throwing an elbow Tambling might get lucky
can't recall the Tippett one however Sauce too would be unlucky to get rubbed out
Bit harsh, seen worse games, Since hes been here he at least gives his all to get the pill. Im fine with his form. Give hima bit of time in our system he'll be great
Dawson
surely the umpire being right there in front of Tambo's incident and saying there was nothing in it will help his cause.
I know it means nothing, but if Campbell Brown trying to take off *insert Bulldog player's name here* 's head only got 2 weeks, then our boys should all be fine.
Tambling is the only one in a little trouble I think.
Tambling is the only one in a little trouble I think.
Would also love to see Bernie tear it up for WWT Eagles and force his way back in next week....
Sloane and Vince would be two huge inclusions for us as our midfield has been very ordinary before this week. Provided of course Bernie is ready to perform, which is a big 'if'.
But we need both those guys in and playing at their best.
Sloane and Vince would be two huge inclusions for us as our midfield has been very ordinary before this week. Provided of course Bernie is ready to perform, which is a big 'if'.
But we need both those guys in and playing at their best.
NTRabbit
Brownlow Medallist
Davis is gone for the season.
Henderson picked up a bad corkie, and may miss. Wright picked up a milder corkie, should be fine.
Johncock no case to answer. Jacobs no case to answer. Tippett reprimand with a guilty plea. Tambling 2 weeks.
OUT: Davis, Tambling
IN: Sloane, no idea
Ask me again on Wednesday
Henderson picked up a bad corkie, and may miss. Wright picked up a milder corkie, should be fine.
Johncock no case to answer. Jacobs no case to answer. Tippett reprimand with a guilty plea. Tambling 2 weeks.
OUT: Davis, Tambling
IN: Sloane, no idea
Ask me again on Wednesday
TubbsFarquhar
TheBrownDog
Davis will probably gone for the season. Tambling will most likely get a couple but I think Jacobs, Tippett and Johncock will get off with a reprimand at worst.
In: SloaneD), Sellar/Young, Petrenko (at the expense of Tambling)
Out: Davis, Tambling, Henderson
Vince did nothing to warrant a recall against the Dees
. Tambling will most likely get a couple but I think Jacobs, Tippett and Johncock will get off with a reprimand at worst.In: Sloane
D), Sellar/Young, Petrenko (at the expense of Tambling)Out: Davis, Tambling, Henderson
Vince did nothing to warrant a recall against the Dees
Macca
given Melb's forward line I'm not convinced on the Sellar's selection, subsequently I would play LT at CHB and if Young has a good game tomorrow bring Will in to play in the back pocket
