Unofficial Preview Changes Portees v Deesees

[Powerstufff]

Howard suspended for one match in the sanfl

GG!

Stay strong Port fans.

 

[nadsee]

Impey will be a jet just needs to play more midfield minutes he will take whites spot on the wing when he's done. I've said it before ill say it again Impey needs to play as a defensive forward this week and shut down jayden hunts run off half back he is Melbourne's most valuable player this week he gets off the chain there is no stopping him.

Good match up.

 

[FishingRick04]

Like Brodie Smith of recent times tearing us up.

 

[Chachi]

If Amon is to come in then White has to make wayotherwise no change. Lobbe if Ryder doesn't come up.

I can't see the point of Amon for White. If its about iutside pace then its probably Atley.
With regard to Lobbe.................NO.

btw I'm not saying we should make that change.

 

[Nemisis]

Yep agree on both players, I see Impey as a 250+ gamer..Amon, still not sure about him.

Impey would have to increase his output and his decision making by 50% to make 100 games.
Kenny is playing him on potential only. Hoping he 'clicks' soon.

 

[badbeats]

Apparently Broadbent is an in.

 

[Adz2332]

Apparently Broadbent is an in.

argh. back to a dozen HBF players

 

[G3TWOTYAD3S3RV]

I can't see the point of Amon for White. If its about iutside pace then its probably Atley.
With regard to Lobbe.................NO.

btw I'm not saying we should make that change.

I wouldn't replace White either I'm just saying like for like . If Ryder is lame then who would be your replacement? At this stage you'd want experience over experiment is why I'd choose Lobbe.

 

[Byron!!!]

I wouldn't replace White either I'm just saying like for like . If Ryder is lame then who would be your replacement? At this stage you'd want experience over experiment is why I'd choose Lobbe.

For every other position on the ground I'd agree but lobbe has given us all a bad experience. Better off giving frampton the gig and if he struggles in ruck put him forward and Trengove / Dixon can rotate Ruck the rest of the game. Anyway Ryder will be fine!!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[G3TWOTYAD3S3RV]

For every other position on the ground I'd agree but lobbe has given us all a bad experience. Better off giving frampton the gig and if he struggles in ruck put him forward and Trengove / Dixon can rotate Ruck the rest of the game. Anyway Ryder will be fine!!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Frampton is an unknown at afl level. We are trying to cement top 4 is why I'd lean towards experience. Yes Ryder will be fine

 

[Byron!!!]

Frampton is an unknown at afl level. We are trying to cement top 4 is why I'd lean towards experience. Yes Ryder will be fine

The problem is lobbe IS KNOWN, and it's not good. I loved him and defended him for years but last year he broke my heart.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

Broadbent surely coming back via Magpies or Pittard omitted.

 

[Arsene Wenger]

Broady in locked - a best 22 player doesnt came back through SANFL.

 

[Jason K]

Makes me laugh when people say Brogsy to come back via maggies. One of our most consistent performers of the last couple of years. Seriously underrated around here

 

[David Puddy]

Broady in locked - a best 22 player doesnt came back through SANFL.

Interesting.

Hopefully it's a straight swap for Pittard which means Atley gets another run. Gives us more flexibility to allow Wingard to play that roaming role as well.

 

[G3TWOTYAD3S3RV]

The problem is lobbe IS KNOWN, and it's not good. I loved him and defended him for years but last year he broke my heart.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

I'm hearing ya but I'd still go with experience at this stage of the year.

 

[Schulzenfest]

Broady in locked - a best 22 player doesnt came back through SANFL.

We have 7 better defenders than Broadbent. Unless Pittard leaves or Houston/DBJ drops off he's not 'best 22' anymore. He might be in the best 22 players on our list but he's not in our best team.

 

[Arsene Wenger]

We have 7 better defenders than Broadbent. Unless Pittard leaves or Houston/DBJ drops off he's not 'best 22' anymore. He might be in the best 22 players on our list but he's not in our best team.

everyone has their opinion, but i disagree with you mate. I rate Brogsy more than Pittard. Is reliable, can play a bit taller (on a watts type for example), is a great kick and can play higher up the ground.....

 

[Schulzenfest]

If he comes in for Pittard/DBJ, it's not a move I would've made but it's fine I suppose. If he comes in for Atley, White, Impey or any other non-defender, we've ****ed the balance of our side again.

 

[Chrizzt]

We have 7 better defenders than Broadbent. Unless Pittard leaves or Houston/DBJ drops off he's not 'best 22' anymore. He might be in the best 22 players on our list but he's not in our best team.

Yeah I get the strong feeling that if his injury was 2 years ago he wouldn't have missed last week. However given he's not clearly ahead of any of the other defenders they were able to take an ultra-cautious approach and drop him.

 

[Arsene Wenger]

If he comes in for Pittard/DBJ, it's not a move I would've made but it's fine I suppose. If he comes in for Atley, White, Impey or any other non-defender, we've ****ed the balance of our side again.

I am pretty confident Atley will stay in.

 

[Forzaport]

Broady in locked - a best 22 player doesnt came back through SANFL.

I've really enjoyed the balance of our team with Atley in. Hoping it will continue.

 

[Needs Gravy]

Makes me laugh when people say Brogsy to come back via maggies. One of our most consistent performers of the last couple of years. Seriously underrated around here

Would normally agree with this but when he came straight back in against Richmond he looked average, either wasn't over the injury or needed a run the PB before coming into the AFL side.

 

[Byron!!!]

I'm hearing ya but I'd still go with experience at this stage of the year.

Do you think ah Chee or young should be in for Atley? I do because I agree with your principle outside of the extraordinary case of the ordinary lobbe.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Alberton Proud]

If Broady comes back in it'll be for Austin

Pittard will stay in