Changes v GWS

[JSA11]

Kern plz.

I mean he's made some awful decisions this year, but god this is just outrageous.

I am sorry, I have lost complete faith in Ken, this has just finished me. Look for another coach.

He has got everything wrong this year, he's stubborn, his tactics are very ordinary, the players didn't play for him for parts of the year, he has consistently got it wrong at selection.

Bye Ken, maybe it was the assistants who were the real drivers in the previous successful years.[/QUOTE


Who were u expecting to be picked?

 

[Finest of Wines]

Ken on 5AA tonight stated he would not gift games to players.

Picks Jonas.

 

[Powerstufff]

..... Lets play Mitchell who is fu**ing useless and will never be an AFL standard footballer ...

Mitchell is as good as any of our borderline players and he's flat out earnt his spot. And in any event there's better, more productive ways to say you disagree with someone's selection.

..... Lets bring unco Jonas back into the team for Clurey the kid who has played MUCH MUCH better than Jonas did ....

Jonas was an undroppable star of our defence not too long ago. Ken's entitled to ease him back in if he thinks that's part of the process of getting him back into form. Yep it's hard on Clurey but that's his place in the hierarchy and 8 games isn't bad for where he is.

 

[JSA11]

Hey Robbie,

Who were you expecting to be picked.

 

[Andre]

Now look, I'm all for creative sponsorships for the club, but whoever thought having Dan Murphy's as 'The official selection night liquor sponsor' has to be sacked.

 

[Robbie4PM]

Mitchell is as good as any of our borderline players and he's flat out earnt his spot. And in any event there's better, more productive ways to say you disagree with someone's selection.
Jonas was an undroppable star of our defence not too long ago. Ken's entitled to ease him back in if he thinks that's part of the process of getting him back into form. Yep it's hard on Clurey but that's his place in the hierarchy and 8 games isn't bad for where he is.

Mitchell should not be playing over a kid. The season is over, he should not be playing.

Jonas should not be playing AFL football until he starts moving and kicking better. I don't care how well he played in 2014, this is 2015 and he should not be in the team over Clurey

 

[El_Scorcho]

Hey Robbie,

Who were you expecting to be picked.

Clurey

A tall to replace Lobbe

Not Kane Mitchell

Not Cameron O'Shea

 

[port always]

Jonas has been great in the sanfl and deserves his chance to return and prove he is absolutely useless

 

[Us against the rest]

Hey guys, I haven't looked at the selections yet.

Which talls did we bring in for Lobbe and Clurey?

It will

Kern plz.

I mean he's made some awful decisions this year, but god this is just outrageous.

I am sorry, I have lost complete faith in Ken, this has just finished me. Look for another coach.

He has got everything wrong this year, he's stubborn, his tactics are very ordinary, the players didn't play for him for parts of the year, he has consistently got it wrong at selection.

Bye Ken, maybe it was the assistants who were the real drivers in the previous successful years.

Who did you have in mind??

 

[Forzaport]

Only 5 recognised KPPs this week, our fewest for the year.

 

[Coobk001]

2 WORDS!

FINALS QUALIFICATION

 

[woffy]

Jonas has been great in the sanfl and deserves his chance to return and prove he is absolutely useless

Hope that was sarcasm, 'cause his SANFL form has been woeful as well.

 

[Portology]

Now look, I'm all for creative sponsorships for the club, but whoever thought having Dan Murphy's as 'The official selection night liquor sponsor' has to be sacked.

Why not, I feel like a drink.

Also, excellent like to username ratio for poster "Finest of Wines"


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[El_Scorcho]

Mitchell is as good as any of our borderline players and he's flat out earnt his spot. And in any event there's better, more productive ways to say you disagree with someone's selection.

Mitchell has proven that he doesn't offer anything at AFL level. Amon has. Clurey has. Butcher has shown more. Why not play a debutant? What possible advantage do we gain by playing him?

Jonas was an undroppable star of our defence not too long ago. Ken's entitled to ease him back in if he thinks that's part of the process of getting him back into form. Yep it's hard on Clurey but that's his place in the hierarchy and 8 games isn't bad for where he is.

It's an enormous mixed message to everyone else at the club. Play poorly all year and you'll get dropped for a couple of weeks late in the season and come straight back in without doing anything to deserve a spot.

 

[Alyx]

And you just know Arch is going to be the sub. It should be Mitchell.

*Neade. Has done very little and was lucky to keep his spot.

 

[Robbie4PM]

this is what i posted a while back

Out: Moore, Lobbe, Schultz, O'Shea, Hammer
In: Ah chee, Palmer, Harvey, Krak, DBJ

and i said to delist moore.

 

[Kingfish73]

Jonas, you cannot be farkin serious!

 

[Schulzenfest]

MItchell had to be picked on that performance regardless of previous AFL form

No he didn't. The season is shot and so is Mitchell's career. He has a history of smashing it at SANFL level and then coming up to AFL level and not being up to standard. I don't care if he had 100 touches.

 

[Lewy69]

I'm okay with Kane Mitchell in the side. He is playing outstandingly in the SANFL and deserves a crack at it. If we don't reward that, we're just setting a bad precedent

 

[Premiers04]

Those same deckchairs must be pretty worn out from the constant shuffling. We got some new ones sitting there waiting to be shuffled.

4 weeks left.... can we not waste them playing the same players so we dont find ourselves in the same spot of bother this time next season? We already know Mitchell isnt AFL standard, regardless of his SANFL form.

Wait until the season is shot to drop Lobbe as a token statement to the rest of the lazy plodders who wont get the message anyway.

 

[Janus]

2013 - Jack Hombsch - 6 games. Everyone loses their shit when dropped/not selected.
2014 - Jack Hombsch - 25 games. Everyone says what a great player he is and how much better our defense looks.

2015 - Tom Clurey - 8 games. Everyone loses their shit when dropped/not selected.
2016 - Tom Clurey - ?

 

[HaroldOliver]

f

 

[edgie]

Jonas has been great in the sanfl and deserves his chance to return and prove he is absolutely useless

Butcher is currently on form a better defender than Jonas. Butcher is also a better forward.

In: Jonas

Which also, what is the ****ing point of Butcher as an emergency? If it is to reward form, great, another defender. If it is for possible structure as a forward regardless of form, why not Harvey, and why not just play him, rather than this hypothetical tall forwardline in case of emergency?

Ken
We have problems

 

[PAFC66]

This club is a ****ing joke again..

Why wouldn't you blood a youngster this week? The seasons gone..

 

[AJJPAFC]

Clurey

A tall to replace Lobbe

Not Kane Mitchell

Not Cameron O'Shea

If we are picking our best AFL side, which tall replaces Lobbe? Because none of them are in our best AFL side right now.