Faulks Silvagni Grover
Ibbotson McPharlin Suban
Fyfe Barlow Mzungu
Ballantyne Pavlich Hill
Mayne Johnson McPhee
Sandilands Mundy Broughton
Clarke Lower Crowley
Palmer
Not 100% happy with it, but i think its good enough to deal with the roos...
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Changes vs North
- Thread starter Leslie_Chow
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Faulks Silvagni Grover
Ibbotson McPharlin Suban
Fyfe Barlow Mzungu
Ballantyne Pavlich Hill
Mayne Johnson McPhee
Sandilands Mundy Broughton
Clarke Lower Crowley
Palmer
Not 100% happy with it, but i think its good enough to deal with the roos...
He's in our top 4 or 5 players.
I'm just worried about mundy coming back to early & re-injuring himself again & delaying his pre-season.
FREO are $9.00 to make the finals.
Might be worth pineapple.
Not really worried about Mundy re-injuring.
Not much chance of that(except bad luck).
Sandi is the one who will re-injure and make it worse.
Really needs to be wrapped in cotton wool an resting that foot completely for a few months.
Trouble is hes far too valueable an is able to play at about 80% ability which is still better than a 100% Clarke or Griifin as main ruck.
Not much chance of that(except bad luck).
Sandi is the one who will re-injure and make it worse.
Really needs to be wrapped in cotton wool an resting that foot completely for a few months.
Trouble is hes far too valueable an is able to play at about 80% ability which is still better than a 100% Clarke or Griifin as main ruck.
Reginald Perrin
Shouting at clouds
- Oct 19, 2010
- 18,872
- 25,094
- AFL Club
- Tasmania
- Other Teams
- Coney Island Warriors South Fremantle
What should happen is that Hill should run past Pavlich, Sandilands or McPhee at various points during the game so that those big bodies can pick off the tag and drop them in a massive way. Do it time and again to make the opposition players think a bit. Why is this not done?
In: Mundy, McPhee
Out: Hinkley, Lower
Zac to ruck most of the day with Sandilands playing full forward and relieving in the ruck.
B: Broughton - Silvagni - Faulks
HB: Hill - McPharlin - Mzungu
C: Ibbotson - Mundy - Fyfe
HF: Mayne - Pavlich - Ballantyne
F: Grover - Sandilands - Pitt
R: Clarke - Barlow - Palmer
I: Lower - Johnson - McPhee
S: Suban
OUT: Crowley, Pearce, Hinkley, Duffield
IN: Mundy, Pitt, McPhee, Palmer
A couple of things-
Yes, I realise that's a very tall line-up (8 talls) for a side that just got ran off the oval against Carlton. There isn't much I can do while there is a white powder coated elephant in the room though.
I'd like to see Grover trialled in a Max Rooke style role up forward. We're too tall, slow and lack run with all of Grover, Silvagni, McPharlin and Faulks down back. I'm somewhat thinking long-term and somewhat thinking about just setting Grover free to cause chaos and maybe kick a goal or two in his 200th.
Broughton down back to do what he does best.
Hill and Mzungu down back to provide the drive out of the backline we've been missing all year. I'd prefer Hill to play around the ball, but he's been soooo flat for most of this season that he's lucky to be playing at all.
Ibbotson further up the ground to take advantage of his run. It should also increase our attack/risk taking from the back-line, as he tends to play very safe.
Pitt to provide some class and polish to our forward-line. He's an attacking player, which is something we are really lacking at the moment. I'd go for Walters if he was fit - which would probably have Pitt playing as the substitute - however Walters has been out for a while now.
Despite a poor game last week, I think Lower will be required around the stoppages this week. He just gives us a different look when he's around the contest.
Suban can come in to play either midfield or release Mzungu, Broughton or Hill to do so. I think he needs to play a midfield role on a more permanent basis anyway, so he gets a quarter to show what he can do.
HB: Hill - McPharlin - Mzungu
C: Ibbotson - Mundy - Fyfe
HF: Mayne - Pavlich - Ballantyne
F: Grover - Sandilands - Pitt
R: Clarke - Barlow - Palmer
I: Lower - Johnson - McPhee
S: Suban
OUT: Crowley, Pearce, Hinkley, Duffield
IN: Mundy, Pitt, McPhee, Palmer
A couple of things-
Yes, I realise that's a very tall line-up (8 talls) for a side that just got ran off the oval against Carlton. There isn't much I can do while there is a white powder coated elephant in the room though.
I'd like to see Grover trialled in a Max Rooke style role up forward. We're too tall, slow and lack run with all of Grover, Silvagni, McPharlin and Faulks down back. I'm somewhat thinking long-term and somewhat thinking about just setting Grover free to cause chaos and maybe kick a goal or two in his 200th.
Broughton down back to do what he does best.
Hill and Mzungu down back to provide the drive out of the backline we've been missing all year. I'd prefer Hill to play around the ball, but he's been soooo flat for most of this season that he's lucky to be playing at all.
Ibbotson further up the ground to take advantage of his run. It should also increase our attack/risk taking from the back-line, as he tends to play very safe.
Pitt to provide some class and polish to our forward-line. He's an attacking player, which is something we are really lacking at the moment. I'd go for Walters if he was fit - which would probably have Pitt playing as the substitute - however Walters has been out for a while now.
Despite a poor game last week, I think Lower will be required around the stoppages this week. He just gives us a different look when he's around the contest.
Suban can come in to play either midfield or release Mzungu, Broughton or Hill to do so. I think he needs to play a midfield role on a more permanent basis anyway, so he gets a quarter to show what he can do.
Harvs did mention he may play ibbo further up the ground.
What about running hill with wells?
What about running hill with wells?
Reginald Perrin
Shouting at clouds
- Oct 19, 2010
- 18,872
- 25,094
- AFL Club
- Tasmania
- Other Teams
- Coney Island Warriors South Fremantle
- Aug 27, 2007
- 13,491
- 11,805
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Everton_East Freo_Atalanta_Tranmere
Ibbo isn't as soft as people think - he's been better than most lately and seems to be improving his awareness levels
Woud like to see Palmer and Mundy both back in to the side - but Palmer might be worth holding out on for another week as tendant/ligament/muscle injuries are far more likely to re-occur than bone injuries (especially clean breaks)
Maybe even rest Sandi and bring Griff back?
Des had some strong words for Hill in an article:
http://au.news.yahoo.com/thewest/sport/a/-/afl/10045914/docker-hill-told-to-speak-up-for-himself/
Spot on too - he needs to demand protection. demand the ball and above all else demand a lead when going in to the forward 50. Only then will his true potential be realised
he has(had?) the nickname "Humphrey" around the club for his extremely quiet nature (not because he didn't like to wear pants)
Woud like to see Palmer and Mundy both back in to the side - but Palmer might be worth holding out on for another week as tendant/ligament/muscle injuries are far more likely to re-occur than bone injuries (especially clean breaks)
Maybe even rest Sandi and bring Griff back?
Des had some strong words for Hill in an article:
http://au.news.yahoo.com/thewest/sport/a/-/afl/10045914/docker-hill-told-to-speak-up-for-himself/
Spot on too - he needs to demand protection. demand the ball and above all else demand a lead when going in to the forward 50. Only then will his true potential be realised
he has(had?) the nickname "Humphrey" around the club for his extremely quiet nature (not because he didn't like to wear pants)
I agree with Des, and that's why I think people like De Boer and McPhee are so important to our line up. The protection thing is something the Eagles (with freeing Judd and Kerr) and Geelong did so much better than we do.
B: faulks. SNOS groves
HB: broughts maca duffield
C: hill. Lower Ibbo
HF: mayne. Pav. Mzungu
FF : ballas immunitypin sandi
Ruck : Clarke barra. Barlow
Res: lower, McPhee, Crowley, Suban
Hopefully this team can break our 4 game losing streak.
HB: broughts maca duffield
C: hill. Lower Ibbo
HF: mayne. Pav. Mzungu
FF : ballas immunitypin sandi
Ruck : Clarke barra. Barlow
Res: lower, McPhee, Crowley, Suban
Hopefully this team can break our 4 game losing streak.
Doesn't mean he's wrong though.
Changes for the weekend
Out: Soft tackling, Pathetic running, dismal skills
In: Spine, Heart, Someguts
Wait I think the IN's all play for North so I think we're f****d, oh well throw in Mundy, Mcphee and Schammer (why not) and give it one last crack. If they lose this week then start tanking, if we are not tanking already
!!!
Out: Soft tackling, Pathetic running, dismal skills
In: Spine, Heart, Someguts
Wait I think the IN's all play for North so I think we're f****d, oh well throw in Mundy, Mcphee and Schammer (why not) and give it one last crack. If they lose this week then start tanking, if we are not tanking already
!!!
sportsmaniac89
Persona Non Grata
- Jan 9, 2008
- 15,144
- 23,004
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Dandenong Rangers, Man United
Out: Spineless bullshit, soft football, missing tackles
In: Some ****ing heart and a 4 quarter performance
In any event Fusion @ Crown on Sat night post-game is going to be a much better end to the night. Bring on the dancefloor
In: Some ****ing heart and a 4 quarter performance
In any event Fusion @ Crown on Sat night post-game is going to be a much better end to the night. Bring on the dancefloor
We got showen up last week with the lack of speed. There is no need to have four KPP in our back line where only playing north who use Petrie n Edwards as tall forward tagerts. We need a running team. You can drop Crowley for Fyfe as well
Take two.
Fb: groves SNOS suban
HB: broughts maca ibbo
C: hill lower mzungu
HF: mayne pav fyfe
Ff:ballas immunitypin sandi
Ruck : Clarke barra Barlow
Res:McPhee duffield Crowley faulks
Fb: groves SNOS suban
HB: broughts maca ibbo
C: hill lower mzungu
HF: mayne pav fyfe
Ff:ballas immunitypin sandi
Ruck : Clarke barra Barlow
Res:McPhee duffield Crowley faulks
No Pav? are you expecting him to be injured eh?
I would go:
FB: Grover, Silvagni, Ibbotson
HB: Hill, Macca, Mzzzzzzz
C: Lower, McPhee, Suban
HF: Fyfe, Pav, Johnson
FF: Ballas, Clarke, Mayne
Ruck: Sandi, Barlow, Mundy
Pine: Duffield, Creepy, Faulksy (Keplar)
Might be a bit too tall, so Keplar on the bench might get replaced by Palmer if he is fit.
Don't know if he was that poor on a tag or just plain inconsistant. He was very vocal on the field which Hilly could take note of.
Well if he is better of resting, can't afford any more underdone players, if he's ok then replace KEP at FF
