Our last flag was 31 years ago
We have 10
Current Brownlow medalist forever tainted with a Drug scandal
You probably should start.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Essendon and their failed rebuild
- Thread starter blaisee
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Our last flag was 31 years ago
We have 10
Current Brownlow medalist forever tainted with a Drug scandal
You probably should start.
Best rebuild decision for the Tigers was Tambling instead of Franklin
Our last flag was 2010 if its me your asking.
Dunno how many flags Richmond have, they won a lot in the 60's 70's just like Essendon won a lot in the 80's. All a long time ago now.
Current Brownlow medallist is Jobe Tainted. Good player, such a shame his name has been dragged through the mud by James Hird.
You no longer know how to win premierships otherwise you'd have had more than four finals appearances in the past 12 years.
Agree with your last point, I much prefer that you are an Essendon supporter.
Yet we still got 100 games out of him and basically traded him for Maric. Not as bad as Gumbleton ahead of Selwood or Riewoldt.
If he didnt have injuries he could of possibly been better than both but we will never know unless he gets his body right
Tambling on the other hand
First picks for Essendon since their last GF appearance (Rich in brackets, who got the better player at the end
2001 Shane Harvey (first round pick traded for Stafford) R
2002 Jason Laycock (Jay Schultz) R
2003 Kepler Bradley (first round traded for Nathan Brown) R
2004 Angus Monfries (Brett Deledio) R
2005 Patrick Ryder (Jarrad Oakeley Nicholls) E
2006 Leroy Jetta (Jack Riewoldt) R
2007 David Myers (Trent Cotchin) R
2008 Micheal Hurlley (Tyrone Vickery) E
2009 Jake Melksham (Dustin Martin) R
2010 Dyson Heppell (Reece Conca) E
2011 Kavanagh (Ellis) R
Richmond despite being terrible with their drafting have still done better than Essendon with their first choice picks in 8 of the last 11 years. I have omitted the past few years because its too early to call
- Banned
- #233
Tygar_maanpls!
Drug scandal? And yet no AFL doping rules were broken by players. Now if you are talking about drugs, I could talk about 3 strikes Dustbin Martin but I wont
Win a day premiership and then come back and we can chat.
- Banned
- #234
What question? ever since i've posted in this thread, I've never seen you ask me a question.
Are you sure you are posting to the right person or even in the right thread?
06 should be Gumbleton not that it changes the result. Your comparison should at least include what pick they were taken because it's not exactly a great achievement to get the better player when you have pick 1 compared with pick 14.
2002 Jason Laycock pick10 (Jay Schultz pick12) R
2003 Kepler Bradley (first round traded for Nathan Brown) R
2004 Angus Monfries pick14 (Brett Deledio pick1) R
2005 Patrick Ryder pick7 (Jarrad Oakeley Nicholls pick8) E
2006 Scott Gumbletom pick2 (Jack Riewoldt pick13) R
2007 David Myers pick6 (Trent Cotchin pick2 ) R
2008 Micheal Hurley pick5 (Tyrone Vickery pick8) E
2009 Jake Melksham pick10 (Dustin Martin pick3 ) R
2010 Dyson Heppell pick8 (Reece Conca pick6 ) E
2011 Kavanagh pick 19 (Ellis pick 15) R
this tells me that they got two really right 2002 and 2006 <[But possibly cause of his injuries ]
2004, 2007, 2009 you would want to hope they are better picks with pick 1, pick 2 and pick 3
2011 you cant really judge yet still to early
What question? ever since i've posted in this thread, I've never seen you ask me a question.
Are you sure you are posting to the right person or even in the right thread?
The Question
You know the one you squibbed?
I didn't say My Question
- Thread starter
- #238
The Hurley vs vickery one is just wrong.
Hurley is the most overrated player in the league
Forward Press
Hall of Famer
Thread's done.
- Status
Similar threads
- Poll
