Review Good/Bad vs Collingwood

[growly]

Heads can be held high, umps did u guys over. Dawson a gun. Another 12-18 months you will be top 2. Don't think Collingwood are as good as they think, for a top side they don't often play 4 qtrs and their midfield can float in and out of games, granted they are better with degoey in the side. But I can see either the power or lions getting them in the end.

 

[Geoffa32]

They do, but we made plenty of mistakes too. The worst thing the club can do is say "we would have won if it wasn't for the umpiring" and chalk it up to being screwed over.

They need to focus on what they can control. Umpiring is out of their hands, so all efforts must be made to fix the things they can fix. Rule should always be you put the game in a position the umpiring can't influence the game, that's the only attitude that should be taken.

Wouldn't even be in the mindset of the club to blame the umpires given how bad we played for most of the first half.



On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Scorpus]

MOD NOTE: Reminder to all Collingwood supporters that trolling through laugh reacts is not acceptable and will be met with an infraction

Adelaide supporters can use the report feature on their own posts to notify the mod team of this behaviour

 

[Red mist]

They do, but we made plenty of mistakes too. The worst thing the club can do is say "we would have won if it wasn't for the umpiring" and chalk it up to being screwed over.

They need to focus on what they can control. Umpiring is out of their hands, so all efforts must be made to fix the things they can fix. Rule should always be you put the game in a position the umpiring can't influence the game, that's the only attitude that should be taken.

Third quarter crushes this enabler. It’s the mistakes we made during. And for that it’s two losses for a combined three points.

 

[brucetiki]

Wouldn't even be in the mindset of the club to blame the umpires given how bad we played for most of the first half.



On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Nor should it be in the mindset of the club.

Focus on what we can control - our inconsistent goal kicking

 

[Bearded Clam]

Ugly: Some blokes in Gameday bagging Hinge.

Yep..

its laughable.

hinge is a bloody solid player.

sure.. he makes the odd mistake here and there but defenders under immense pressure always will.

his hack of a mate who came from brisbane at the same time gets to run around like a headless chook, fxxking up everything he touches, like some reverse Midas, and many here love him!

 

[MsTopG]

So does poor skills and fumbling and not being clean first take

Yes for sure but is it too much to ask for the game to be umpired the same for both sides? It happens too often for it to be coincidence.

 

[FR0GGY]

Yep because we got * all free kicks, had a massive comeback from 27 points down and played and scored well enough to win, we were robbed by green maggots. Like they were paying high contact all game, and then Dawson getting smashed in the face isn't high contact???

Away game against the best performing Vic club at the G

 

[WetCrow1991]

Crows are definitely good enough, like the way you guys go about it.
Was a few dodgy calls both ways and wasn't the deciding factor.
Hope to see you guys in September.

from my Delorean

It was literally the deciding factor.

 

[Red mist]

MOD NOTE: Reminder to all Collingwood supporters that trolling through laugh reacts is not acceptable and will be met with an infraction

Are we that fragile? I’d admit that’s fragile.

 

[Geoffa32]

It was unprofessional. Had to call it a goal.

The problem is the third umpire has to be 100% confident to reverse the umpires call.



On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[radiojake]

Too fumbly and not clean enough at crucial contests throughout the game

 

[WetCrow1991]

Away game against the best performing Vic club at the G

We won it, we were incorrectly not given the 4 points.

 

[cleanhands]

Yes for sure but is it too much to ask for the game to be umpired the same for both sides. It happens too often for it to be coincidence.

And effects all sides

 

[dplggr47]

Good:

• Third quarter comeback
• Jordan Dawson in his 100th game
• Walker with 5 goals
• Laird
• Hinge
• Worrell had a lot of almost great marks and then finally took a great one running back. Just needs more games.

Bad:

• Umpiring
• Sholl - did he do anything good today? was terrible all game
• Murphy - he ran hard but didn't have any effect on the game
• Keays - should not be playing midfield again or tag anyone in the midfield
• Keays ripping off Cox's glasses; thought it was uncalled for

Ugly:
- Our goal kicking in the first half

 

[Scorpus]

Are we that fragile? I’d admit that’s fragile.

You will absolutely get carded if you do this on another team's board in a thread like this

 

[MsTopG]

Good:

• Third quarter comeback
• Jordan Dawson in his 100th game
• Walker with 5 goals
• Laird
• Hinge
• Worrell had a lot of almost great marks and then finally took a great one running back. Just needs more games.

Bad:

• Umpiring
• Sholl - did he do anything good today? was terrible all game
• Murphy - he ran hard but didn't have any effect on the game
• Keays - should not be playing midfield again or tag anyone in the midfield
• Keays ripping off Cox's glasses; thought it was uncalled for

Ugly:
- Our goal kicking in the first half

His glasses coming off was pretty funny though.

 

[The Perfect Stranger]

We said Sholl would get found out in a high-pressure finals like game due to his lack of physicality.

Rule a line through him..

 

[FR0GGY]

His glasses coming off was pretty funny though.

Coming off

 

[Samcro24]

We said Sholl would get found out in a high-pressure finals like game due to his lack of physicality.

Rule a line through him..

Yep. Delist.

 

[Red mist]

Honestly, a lot of Sydney supporters would be surprise with the trajectory of his improvement.

Dawson told the club his game is more than a half back defence intercept. He likes to get amongst it, is ambitious. You’d want a captain who is ambitious. We got one. Same with Hinge. Awesome.

You will absolutely get carded if you do this on another team's board in a thread like this

yeah but we are not those boards and that is a boon to our tolerances.

 

[1990crow]

Yep. Delist.

Nah. Trade. Someone would take him for a third Rounder.

 

[Burtonsgottago]

Good - the fighting 2nd half comeback
Bad - the AFL for systematically ruining the game I love

 

[Multiballz]

Dawson told the club his game is more than a half back defence intercept. He likes to get amongst it, is ambitious. You’d want a captain who is ambitious. We got one. Same with Hinge. Awesome.

yeah but we are not those boards and that is a boon to our tolerances.

Or do we just mirror the Club we support?

 

[MsTopG]

How many weeks off for Murray? Maybe back for bombers.