-
LIVE: Sydney v Brisbane Lions - 2:30PM AEST Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 61% chance -- What's your tip? -- Ticketing Buy, Sell -- Teams on Thurs »
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Grand Final
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round PF Winner: Still Me
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Ins and Outs against the Bulldogs ....
- Thread starter wallyt99
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Thread starter
- #4
Re: Ins + Outs against the Bulldogs
Good in the second when there was easy space, but he was sloppy in the first half though when the heat was on.
I think he was pretty good overall, but someone has to make way.....
Good in the second when there was easy space, but he was sloppy in the first half though when the heat was on.
I think he was pretty good overall, but someone has to make way.....
Re: Ins + Outs against the Bulldogs
No way in the world will Clinton Young be dropped!!!
No way in the world will Clinton Young be dropped!!!
- Thread starter
- #7
Re: Ins + Outs against the Bulldogs
The question should be raised then.....
Will crawf "pull up sore"
Perhaps letting the kids play the games? Afterall....everyone of those blokes has earnt there spot in the finals.
Is it about who has earnt it?
If that is the case - First to go would be Dew, and Murphy.....
Or is it just about the best 22? (Ask Stephen King???)
Dunno....Tough calls to be made this week.
The question should be raised then.....
Will crawf "pull up sore"
Perhaps letting the kids play the games? Afterall....everyone of those blokes has earnt there spot in the finals.
Is it about who has earnt it?
If that is the case - First to go would be Dew, and Murphy.....
Or is it just about the best 22? (Ask Stephen King???)
Dunno....Tough calls to be made this week.
Re: Ins + Outs against the Bulldogs
Speaking of the players who have earnt it, Shane Crawford has spent 15 years "earning it". Even if he is no longer in the best 22, he must play.
I really don't want to see Clinton Young dropped, but it just may happen. He doesn't seem to be as confident as early in the season. He's dropped a few marks in recent times, which before he would grabbed and would have got on his bike, run 40 metres and kicked it 55 metres.
Many times in the last couple of weeks, he's been in the clear, dropped an easy pass, and had to work hard at ground level to try recover ball, and losing the team its advantage.
It's a confidence thing, and at full flight, he is a real key player, but he may still be struggling with the injuries he took on in the middle of the season, when he was forced to play more inside roles.
Speaking of the players who have earnt it, Shane Crawford has spent 15 years "earning it". Even if he is no longer in the best 22, he must play.
I really don't want to see Clinton Young dropped, but it just may happen. He doesn't seem to be as confident as early in the season. He's dropped a few marks in recent times, which before he would grabbed and would have got on his bike, run 40 metres and kicked it 55 metres.
Many times in the last couple of weeks, he's been in the clear, dropped an easy pass, and had to work hard at ground level to try recover ball, and losing the team its advantage.
It's a confidence thing, and at full flight, he is a real key player, but he may still be struggling with the injuries he took on in the middle of the season, when he was forced to play more inside roles.
Re: Ins + Outs against the Bulldogs
theres no way i would drop young, he was awesome as usual. for crawf to come back in id think dew would be the first out?
good win tonight boys, im a big fan of the hawks.
theres no way i would drop young, he was awesome as usual. for crawf to come back in id think dew would be the first out?
- Jan 28, 2007
- 1,744
- 1,458
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- West Ham United,Green Bay Packers.
Re: Ins + Outs against the Bulldogs
Out Renouf,Dew
In Taylor,Crawford
I think Clinton Youngs run is very important to our structure and i do not think Stuart Dew gets enough of the pill to warrant a game.
Out Renouf,Dew
In Taylor,Crawford
I think Clinton Youngs run is very important to our structure and i do not think Stuart Dew gets enough of the pill to warrant a game.
Re: Ins + Outs against the Bulldogs
I hope the club is a lot more focussed on winning a 10th flag than honouring old soldiers.
Crawf will just have to wait for an injury.
Crawf can clang with the best of them. and if its just experience then Dew has more.
I hope the club is a lot more focussed on winning a 10th flag than honouring old soldiers.
Crawf will just have to wait for an injury.
Crawf can clang with the best of them. and if its just experience then Dew has more.
Re: Ins + Outs against the Bulldogs
On the depth thing the box hill boys wont get a run next week =-could we arrange a scratch match to keep them on song ?
On the depth thing the box hill boys wont get a run next week =-could we arrange a scratch match to keep them on song ?
Re: Ins + Outs against the Bulldogs
Out: Renouf, Mitchell (suspended - attempted strike)
In: Taylor, Crawford.
Out: Renouf, Mitchell (suspended - attempted strike)
In: Taylor, Crawford.
go hawks!!!
Norm Smith Medallist
Re: Ins + Outs against the Bulldogs
sorry guys, but i think renouf stays in, much more mobile and fit than taylor which will be needed. as you saw last night, robbie campbell will spend some time up forward against geelong to expose taylor and scarlett.
as for crawford, he is in, and can't see who is out, on form i would say dew, but we need his hard body. i love young, really he is great, call him "run and carry", but he may be the victim.
mitchell: have not seen the footage
osborne needs to improve, he is a little selfish at the moment.
everybody: 3 cheers for roughie, his last quarter was very important for us, 5 goals, ...amazing, he played crap for the first 3 quarters.
sorry guys, but i think renouf stays in, much more mobile and fit than taylor which will be needed. as you saw last night, robbie campbell will spend some time up forward against geelong to expose taylor and scarlett.
as for crawford, he is in, and can't see who is out, on form i would say dew, but we need his hard body. i love young, really he is great, call him "run and carry", but he may be the victim.
mitchell: have not seen the footage
osborne needs to improve, he is a little selfish at the moment.
everybody: 3 cheers for roughie, his last quarter was very important for us, 5 goals, ...amazing, he played crap for the first 3 quarters.
Changes for the first final?
Very very difficult indeed.
Renouf was solid last night and has a big future at the club but will make way for the bigger bodied more experienced Simon Taylor and rightfully so.
Crawford will be fit and firing for the match...perhaps his last season, so somebody must drop out for him. Murphy was terrific last night and has had a solid season and improved each week and deserves to line up next week. Barring any injuries on the track this week and presuming Brown and Williams come up from their injuries they suffered, who will drop out for Crawf?
Surely Dew will play seeing they included him in the leadership group. However after a solid first half last night...managed just one possession in the entire second half!
Young was good again...two solid performances in a row since coming back into the team. Could he be the unlucky one?
I'd hate to be on the selection panel this week, although, this in itself is an awesome position to be in.
The emergencies will include one of Dew/Young, Dowler/Stokes and one of Morton/Tuck.
Very very difficult indeed.
Renouf was solid last night and has a big future at the club but will make way for the bigger bodied more experienced Simon Taylor and rightfully so.
Crawford will be fit and firing for the match...perhaps his last season, so somebody must drop out for him. Murphy was terrific last night and has had a solid season and improved each week and deserves to line up next week. Barring any injuries on the track this week and presuming Brown and Williams come up from their injuries they suffered, who will drop out for Crawf?
Surely Dew will play seeing they included him in the leadership group. However after a solid first half last night...managed just one possession in the entire second half!
Young was good again...two solid performances in a row since coming back into the team. Could he be the unlucky one?
I'd hate to be on the selection panel this week, although, this in itself is an awesome position to be in.
The emergencies will include one of Dew/Young, Dowler/Stokes and one of Morton/Tuck.
Re: Ins + Outs against the Bulldogs
Tuck is close to our best 22 however he has stiff competition from guys like Stokes and Morton if an injury occurs. Probably just depends which of the trio plays best in the ressies.
Tuck is close to our best 22 however he has stiff competition from guys like Stokes and Morton if an injury occurs. Probably just depends which of the trio plays best in the ressies.
Re: Ins + Outs against the Bulldogs
Radio experts say that Mitchell will be 100% fine.
I take it all back, but jeez I wish he wouldn't do that crap.
Radio experts say that Mitchell will be 100% fine.
I take it all back, but jeez I wish he wouldn't do that crap.
buddylove_23
All Australian
Re: Ins + Outs against the Bulldogs
I went to training on Friday and crawf was out on the ground running and doing drills by himself for a long time after everyone else had come off. He looked pretty goos to me...
I went to training on Friday and crawf was out on the ground running and doing drills by himself for a long time after everyone else had come off. He looked pretty goos to me...
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked
