Oppo Camp Non Geelong football (AFL) discussion 2024, Part I

[D BRIDGE]

Steady on.

One of those players has had a 40 goal year, the other is Nate Caddy.

Promising signs, yes..but that's all it is so far, like most youngsters across the league. Get back to us in 3-5 years and we'll re-evaluate.

Also, weren't you the one banging the table last year for COS anyway?

Def can't get a full read on kids for a few years... no doubt.

I'd swap Henry for Caddy though... even though Caddy is just a pup and Henry is a knack of kicking goals.

I just think Caddy will be a player.

And yeah I was happy with COS or Caddy last year... Wasn't sure If we'd even have the option to get one of them.

I'm not potting COS... but I do think Caddy has more talent than him but there's more to it than just pure talent.

Hopefully Caddy is a gun and COS is even better.

 

[Gunf]

Only 3 goals since quarter time for Coll pathetic

 

[D BRIDGE]

Pies game day page is a delight to read.

 

[Gunf]

Pies game day page is a delight to read.

TBF most game day threads would be a delight to read when the side has only kicked 4 goals in 2 and half quarters

 

[CatToTheFuture]

Daicos pinged for an insufficient intent. Tell your kids you saw it happen

 

[Gunf]

Daicos pinged for an insufficient intent. Tell your kids you saw it happen

I call bullshit the footage was doctored

 

[Baudolino]

FINALLY one of those is paid!!!!

Those "walk the ball over the boundary" deliberates happen all the time, they're just slightly better disguised. Should ALWAYS be paid.

 

[Cataholic]

Daicos pinged for an insufficient intent. Tell your kids you saw it happen

Who?

 

[Gunf]

Still time for ESS to choke

 

[Baudolino]

Nick Daicos is a gun but he's not as exciting to watch compared to other great players.

 

[CatToTheFuture]

Def can't get a full read on kids for a few years... no doubt.

I'd swap Henry for Caddy though... even though Caddy is just a pup and Henry is a knack of kicking goals.

I just think Caddy will be a player.

And yeah I was happy with COS or Caddy last year... Wasn't sure If we'd even have the option to get one of them.

I'm not potting COS... but I do think Caddy has more talent than him but there's more to it than just pure talent.

Hopefully Caddy is a gun and COS is even better.

Yeah but Henry for Caddy wasn't a choice we were ever presented with.

 

[Baudolino]

Nick Daicos is a gun but he's not as exciting to watch compared to other great players.

Also can I just pre-emptively say to Vdubs that I don't care what your opinion on this is.

 

[cats_09]

Will this be a draw cats_09 ?

No idea

But at the time of my earlier post I knew nothing of the scoreline and just typed a team

 

[CatToTheFuture]

Pies have the opportunity to do something very, very funny here

 

[Strange Cat]

Please please happen for the lulz

 

[Strange Cat]

Pies have the opportunity to do something very, very funny here

Might not be enough time sadly

 

[Gunf]

Good win by ESS apart from the first quarter they were easily the better team

 

[CatToTheFuture]

High called for Lipinski 30 seconds after identical not called for Caldwell. Lock up your tinfoil woolies!

 

[CatToTheFuture]

Might not be enough time sadly

Happy to see Collingwood lose regardless.

 

[Lana]

High called for Lipinski 30 seconds after identical not called for Caldwell. Lock up your tinfoil woolies!

Caldwell made the contact. So no free

The Lipinski one had no head high contact, it shouldn't have been a free

 

[Strange Cat]

Good win by ESS apart from the first quarter they were easily the better team

Still a shocking 99% …frauds

 

[Lana]

Bloody hell this is an ordinary year

 

[Strange Cat]

Happy to see Collingwood lose regardless.

Doesn’t worry me either way wanted to laugh at Ess more than anything else …still they won’t be a threat that’s for sure

 

[CatToTheFuture]

Caldwell made the contact. So no free

The Lipinski one had no head high contact, it shouldn't have been a free

Yeah I thought Caldwell went looking for it so happy with that not being called. Lipinski the call would be justified either way I think.

It would be fun if they lost and had some more umpiring to cling to though

 

[Footy Smarts]

Impressive by the dons. You'd have to be a very good team to beat them.