-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Autopsy Roast & Toast vs Brisbane and changes for off season
- Thread starter NaturalDisaster
- Start date
- Tagged users None
peterbuch74
Norm Smith Medallist
- Oct 10, 2007
- 5,777
- 10,842
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Denver Broncos, Liverpool
I’ve watched the replay of Lynch’s kick and the arc review about 10 times and I still don’t understand how they could 100% unequivocally decide to overturn the goal umpire who was under the ball. Lynch’s kick spins in towards the goal, but the arc footage was a single still from three different angles with not one of them along the goal line to see at what point the ball travel was knowing if it was already past the goal line or not. Having said that, how the f*** can’t Nank, Tarrant, Vlastuin and Balta simply spoil the ball through for a point at the end and let the ball fall into Danihers lap to kick a goal, at least have one of them on the f***ing goal line!!!
Here's a still of where the goal umpire was, directly under the ball/goal post... he called it a goal from that view... with the ball spinning in towards the goal.
Here's a still of where the goal umpire was, directly under the ball/goal post... he called it a goal from that view... with the ball spinning in towards the goal.
Tiger_Of_Old
THE_GUN:"Why don't you use your reg acc"7/9/24
Tend to agree.
I put Balta down as a dissapointment this year.
Does everyone actually think the AFL will let us win one even if we are good enough? I am really worried about topping up and losing draft picks when our list profile suggests we need a refresh down the bottom like Sydney did for a couple years then trade in your Tarantos. Am I missing the point here?
How does the afl not have a camera that is in lin with the goal posts to see if it was behind the line
- Aug 15, 2015
- 10,413
- 33,662
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Yep for someone with his ability he’s been average.
Hopefully he pushes himself preseason and comes back super fit next season. To me seems to be carrying a few extra pounds.
Balta took it harder then any other player last night. Genuinely beat the shit out of the ground.
I hate losing, but we just blooded 6 first time finals players. Young kids playing under the highest amount of pressure and for the most part, they stood up. I bloody love this football club.
I hate losing, but we just blooded 6 first time finals players. Young kids playing under the highest amount of pressure and for the most part, they stood up. I bloody love this football club.
He actually took a couple good intercept marks. We leaked too many goals and would have been blown out of the water in a prelim with battered young kids anyway.
Where the **** is this angle in the score review?
IT would have been used, but not shown the us on the TV. Isn't that what they said the ARC does? They get all the views and angles but only show a couple of TV?
Lynch should have got closer to the man on the mark and then swung around and snapped on his left instead of going the banana
Still can't over-rule it on what was shown last night. If they have clearer evidence they absolutely have to release it today
Still can't over-rule it on what was shown last night. If they have clearer evidence they absolutely have to release it today
Was a devastating finish to the season. When Prestia went down so did all my hope for a victory. It was the same scenario as the first game of the year against Carlton - Prestia was injuried and our midfield couldn't compete. That was the game in a nutshell.
People would argue that they lost their ruckman too but I would prefer Nank leave the field over Prestia. In terms of structural importance, it goes Lynch then Prestia. Would the Lions have won if Neale was injuried?
So even though we gave ourselves every chance to win, the impact of losing our key midfielder should highlight the utter importance of improving our midfield. If we can't trade in Toranto then we need to invest heavily into the draft to rebuild this crucial section of the ground.
People would argue that they lost their ruckman too but I would prefer Nank leave the field over Prestia. In terms of structural importance, it goes Lynch then Prestia. Would the Lions have won if Neale was injuried?
So even though we gave ourselves every chance to win, the impact of losing our key midfielder should highlight the utter importance of improving our midfield. If we can't trade in Toranto then we need to invest heavily into the draft to rebuild this crucial section of the ground.
Ross has arrived. MRJnr was outstanding. Sonsie will be a jet. Miller was ok after early nerves, Cumbo played sore, Gibcus was toey. Kids will be alright.
Prestia injury ended our season, we wouldn’t have made it through the semi even if we got past the Lions.
Thought Pickett and Riewoldt were mighty. Vlastuin outstanding. Balta up and down.
We’re gonna be ok
Prestia injury ended our season, we wouldn’t have made it through the semi even if we got past the Lions.
Thought Pickett and Riewoldt were mighty. Vlastuin outstanding. Balta up and down.
We’re gonna be ok
All Aust
Avatar for ol' mate
- Oct 29, 2020
- 3,081
- 6,007
- AFL Club
- Richmond
As per season 2022, You just know that something similar is going to occur with a different interpretation and ruling to that applied last night. It is almost like RFC are the oldest child who has to absorb the punishment on behalf of the other siblings. The parents need to be better.
- Feb 14, 2014
- 6,194
- 14,813
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Respect to Barret for going against the AFL. He went hard as well on his AFL podcast with Nat Edwards.
Caveman68
Club Legend
- Apr 27, 2015
- 1,273
- 3,496
- AFL Club
- Richmond
This is what i can’t accept. It’s so arbitrary. Not based on any factual information or evidence, just a hunch from a guy in a booth looking at weird and inconclusive footage. “It appears”. Really? Is that what we’re deciding crucial finals on? I hope it decides this years GF one of these ludicrous decisions. Would this be acceptable in any other sporting code. No way, somehow we have been conditioned to suck it up.
I think your a bit unfair, for the backline. With the ball coming out of the centre so easily, it makes it very tough. Whoever runs the midfield, should get the sack. Possibly Andrew Mc Qualter?I’ll say it again
Richmond won’t win another flag under dimmas reign
Roast:
Gibcus
Baker
Balta
Martin
Ross
Toast:
Shane Edwards, Thank you
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
That Baker 50m penalty where there was no advantage. He was looking right at the umpire who was waving play-on with his arm. brain fart
That goal 'review'. Note to Lynch, even if you kick it out of bounds on the full, celebrate like you nailed it. I want to play poker against you Tom. brain fart
That missed defensive play in the last minute. I have no response, I just, I don't... I uh. group brain fart
Toby's smooth, silky ability to direct the tap from a throw-in....... directly into the arms of an opponent... I uh, ok.
Is there someone in professional sports that specialises in fixing brains so they don't shit the bed in pressure moments?
That goal 'review'. Note to Lynch, even if you kick it out of bounds on the full, celebrate like you nailed it. I want to play poker against you Tom. brain fart
That missed defensive play in the last minute. I have no response, I just, I don't... I uh. group brain fart
Toby's smooth, silky ability to direct the tap from a throw-in....... directly into the arms of an opponent... I uh, ok.
Is there someone in professional sports that specialises in fixing brains so they don't shit the bed in pressure moments?
Sterge
Premium Platinum
You need to chill out we won 3, there isnt this big conspiracy to specifically stop us winning flags.
We just weren't good enough this year, we have found some decent kids and we move onwards and upwards next season.
Emma Murray , is she still with the club?
JackNah_8
Hall of Famer
- Jan 15, 2012
- 49,625
- 51,683
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Balta has gone backwards, very disappointing this year though it didn't help that we tried to play in the forward line.
Hope Rutten returns and improves our backline
