Autopsy Roast & Toast vs Carlton Rd 21 & Changes for West Coast Rd 22, 2019

[caddyshack]

Any mathematicians out there know how much we need to beat west coke by to over take them?

~30 points.

 

[Daveeee_12]

Ok, I haven't read any of this thread yet but correct me if I'm wrong, we're locked in for an interstate QF now. The only way of getting Geelong "away" is extremely remote, it would require...

Geelong would have to beat Brisbane at the Gabba

West Coast would have to beat Richmond at the G

Adelaide would have to beat Collingwood.

...The likelihood of all that happening is less than 5% IMO

Not if we lose a game and Collingwood wins both

 

[AlorraVex]

Reckon Stack needs to go back to defence. His 4 goals against the Saints were great when he caught the opposition off-guard, but let’s be honest, he’s a natural defender.

After watching the VFL today, I don’t think Pickett is any chance to play AFL this year. That’s okay, just get a proper pre-season into him.

Out: Chol, Bolton, Short/Baker
In: Soldo, Cotchin, Martin

 

[biaseddustyfan]

Any mathematicians out there know how much we need to beat west coke by to over take them?

on ladder predictor 20 pt win they are still 3rd, 30 point or more win we overtake them

 

[captain blood 17]

jiewoldt wouldn't be driven to that s**t if the umps actually called frees properly

It wasn’t a chicken wing though. It’s pure gutter trash from a gutter trash specialist in Tom Browne.

 

[Roksman]

Not if we lose a game and Collingwood wins both

That's why I said Adelaide beat Collingwood

 

[pirate_tiger]

Any mathematicians out there know how much we need to beat west coke by to over take them?

About 30 points

 

[Waca Jr]

In: Martin, Naish, Balta, Garthwaite. Out: Baker, Chol, Broad, Rioli I just have a feeling west coasts talls will get a hold of us with broad. I’d rather Garth as a match up. I think naish’s field kicking is sublime I want games in him over Baker. I reckon Balta would run riot if given a shot on the big stage of finals. Cotchin needs another rest.

Broad haters. Different breed. Garth will get rag dolled. Back six is fine.

 

[RobsJourney]

How much game time did Chol play?

Anyway, I suggest:

Out: Chol, Baker, Bolton, Short
In: Soldo, Cotchin, Martin, McIntosh

Grimes, Astbury, Vlastuin
Houli, Broad, Stack
Ellis, Cotchin, Lambert
Caddy, Riewoldt, Edwards
Castagna, Lynch, Rioli
Nankervis, Martin, Prestia
Graham, Ross, McIntosh, Soldo

Though is that a bit slow?

I reckon we could use KMac's size vs. West Coast...

 

[NaturalDisaster]

Reckon Stack needs to go back to defence. His 4 goals against the Saints were great when he caught the opposition off-guard, but let’s be honest, he’s a natural defender.

After watching the VFL today, I don’t think Pickett is any chance to play AFL this year. That’s okay, just get a proper pre-season into him.

Out: Chol, Bolton, Short/Baker
In: Soldo, Cotchin, Martin

I prefer him in defense as well but remember also, he is a first year player, he is going to have down games.

He has been very consistent and people forget he is only in his first year.

 

[biaseddustyfan]

It wasn’t a chicken wing though. It’s pure gutter trash from a gutter trash specialist in Tom Browne.

yep you're right but still jiewoldt being driven to raging at defenders and pushing them around because he doesn't ever get given the frees he deserves

 

[biaseddustyfan]

reckon Cotch dusty kmac need to come in before finals. Potentially balta or Naish as well

 

[captain blood 17]

yep you're right but still jiewoldt being driven to raging at defenders and pushing them around because he doesn't ever get given the frees he deserves

Yeah, the umps were shit today, but to be fair, i thought they were shit for both teams. It evened out.

 

[Roksman]

Ok, I haven't read any of this thread yet but correct me if I'm wrong, we're locked in for an interstate QF now. The only way of getting Geelong "away" is extremely remote, it would require...

Geelong would have to beat Brisbane at the Gabba

West Coast would have to beat Richmond at the G

Adelaide would have to beat Collingwood.

...The likelihood of all that happening is less than 5% IMO

Sorry, we could finish 2nd if we beat both West Coast and Brisbane by decent margins and Geelong beat Brisbane

 

[Marcel Proust]

I prefer him in defense as well but remember also, he is a first year player, he is going to have down games.

He has been very consistent and people forget he is only in his first year.

and he was apparently coming off an injury

Stack is a natural inside mid ftiw ...

 

[Oprah From Tigerland]

She’s lucky she’s a stunner because she makes Higgins sound like a rhodes scholar

Shaun Edwards likes this.

 

[BKM78]

K Mac play well in the 2s?

 

[chriso11]

It’s big Boy season from here on out
Next 2 games will prep us well for the finals

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

Thought Chol was ineffectual...no impact!
Short bombed long which worked once for Cut Lunch!
Stack was a butter fingers...
JR just lost it...

 

[chriso11]

Out: Chol, Ross (stiff), Baker
In: Cotchin, Martin, Soldo

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

Prestia "no chance" of Brownlow top ten?
Take a hike, see a shrink.

Exactly!

 

[_RT_]

Workman like is the only way to describe the game today. Opened up a first half lead and then a combination of them tightening up and us not taking our chances kept them at arms length and with a sniff of stealing a win.

Positives:
- The Jacks Graham & Ross stood up and filled the void left by Cotchin and Martin missing from the midfield. Graham hit the scoreboard early on and then was more defensive in the second half. Ross looked like he hadn't misses a beat in the first half and then naturally ran out of petrol in the second half a little but will be better for the run. Having Martin Cotchin Ross Graham & Prestia in the middle next week is an enticing prospect.

- Defensive unit is so well organised they just seamlessly move from opponent to opponent regardless of the situation. Vlastuin has stepped up into a real leader down back along with Grimes, while Baker after some shakiness early is becoming more sure about himself.

- Midfield dominance smashed the Blues 13-4 in the centre clearances and while they got us on the stoppages around the ground it was our ability to get first hands on it in the middle that allowed us to gain easy entries into the F50. Need to be on it again next week against the Eagles

Negatives:
- The weather, haven't been that cold at the footy in years. Thankfully that should be the last time for a while.

Changes:
Hard calls are going to be made this week, with Dusty and Cotchin due back next week against the Eagles and as harsh as it is I can see Stack and Rioli being the unlucky ones to miss out.

Out - Rioli Stack
In - Cotchin Martin

B: Astbury Broad Grimes
HB: Houli Vlastuin Short
C: Ellis Cotchin Edwards
HF: Bolton Castagna Lambert
F: Lynch Martin Riewoldt
R: Nankervis Ross Prestia
INT: Graham Baker Caddy Chol

 

[Bobsleder]

take the 4 points, no injuries, move on.

Thumbs up Prestia, Edwards, Graham, Grimes and Tigger.

100m penalty against Bolton may have cost him his spot when he was having a quiet day, silly stuff.

Bring in Dusty and Cotch. Good luck working out who goes out.

 

[Tigertot]

Umpires seemed confused at times

Umpires almost looked like they knew what they were doing at times - even scarier

 

[biaseddustyfan]

Do we try Nankoldo next week or is Nalta/Chonkerivs the way to go for the rest of the year. I don't think we should just go Chonkervis for another week we need to experiment now before finals

Biggest headache for KiwiTiger and his match commitee at the moment