Autopsy Roast & Toast vs GWS R8 & Changes for Bulldogs, R9

[HTT]

The aim of the game is to score more than the other team. At some point a line needs to be drawn between a good defensive game and a bad offensive game

The turnovers created lead to scores.
Don’t get blinded by the ‘forward’ part of ‘defensive forward’.
Some players are there mainly for when we have the ball. Do we drop Dusty because he doesn’t get involved heavily defensively?
Others are there mainly for when we don’t.
If you want to say a specific player could provide the same defence while also providing more on offence, that’s fine. But you have to have a player in mind. Not ‘drop Rioli, figure out who for later.’

 

[tunksy]

The turnovers created lead to scores.
Don’t get blinded by the ‘forward’ part of ‘defensive forward’.
Some players are there mainly for when we have the ball. Do we drop Dusty because he doesn’t get involved heavily defensively?
Others are there mainly for when we don’t.

How many turnovers led to scores from Dan's work?

 

[HTT]

How many turnovers led to scores from Dan's work?

****ed if I know. With 6 tackles and 17 PAs you’d expect a few.

 

[mauricerioli]

How many turnovers led to scores from Dan's work?

He had 3 score involvements for the game, 6 of our players had more than him but they were pretty much all midfielders.

Not sure if they were from turnovers.

 

[Drofder]

Stackman and Chimpa back in.

 

[VB_longneck]

Stackman and Chimpa back in.

why is the club leaking selection 6 hours early ?

 

[mauricerioli]

Stackman and Chimpa back in.

 

[Hoos]

Stackman and Chimpa back in.

Did they say who went out?

 

[SumTingWong]

Did they say who went out?

Squib and probably soft ****

 

[Hoos]

Squib and probably soft ****

Hmmm...Naish and Egg?

 

[Grrr]

Hmmm...Naish and Egg?

A tad harsh, think the bloke above might have set you up there.

 

[Grrr]

Stack to play mid, along with Cotchin means two mids go out. Interesting.
Hope Stack, Bolton and Pickett all line up there at the opening bounce, just to hear Bruce McAvaney bang on... and on.

 

[mopsy]

yep. it's rinse and repeat of last year with Egg performing well when there is no pressure, and then going missing when against a good side. Houli probably has 30 last week.

What you mean the ten he would get out the back and the other ten he would get playing on from a kick in. Never mind the panic attacks that still happen when under real pressure. Give me the ball in DE-S hands every day of the week.5 freakin games in and people writing a kid off.Of course hes going to have some quite games.

 

[Hoos]

A tad harsh, think the bloke above might have set you up there.

I was trying to work out who he meant.

FWIW, I think they will be the two to make way.

 

[Charlie Pannam]

What is this the feel good thread

 

[Grrr]

I was trying to work out who he meant.

FWIW, I think they will be the two to make way.

Well he put the words in your mouth. Reckon with Stack back and in the mids, Naish will probably go out. Reckon DES might stay in, it's not like he was bad last week just lacked a bit of heat around the ball, but was close to best the week before. Cotchin for ...

 

[mopsy]

for me this week my outs would go
Rioli - putrid
McIntosh - just not up to the standard.
Aarts - just a battler.
Chol - what does he give us? answer usually very little.
Naish - Harsh on the kid here he deserves a block of games but i have others id prefer see get a game.

Team would go like this

B/ Vlastuin - Garthwaite - Grimes. Imo Garthwaite is more suited to a kp role than Broad thus freeing Grimes up.
HB/ Pickett - Balta - DE-S. HB is Picketts natural position id like just once for them to give him a go there. Des stays done more than enough for a 5 gamer.

C/ Lambert - Ross - Bolton. Pace combined with size Bolton gets shuffled to a wing and Lambert we know is suited there. IMO Better THEM than McIntosh
R/ Soldo - Martin - Cotchin. With out Nankervis no option but play Soldo but cant Play both Soldo and Chol they just dont give enough.

HF/ Stack - Riewoldt - Higgins. Prefer Stack at HB but he cant be worse than Rioli and Aarrts up fwd.
F/ RC-D - Lynch - Castagna. RC-D at 190cm plus gives us a sort of Dusty option up fwd rotating with Dusty on ball. A third tall option without Chol offering nothing.

INT/ Graham - Short - Broad - Baker. Would like to see what Broad has to offer further up the ground or even as a run with type.Short provides outside run and the other two are midfield rotations.

 

[cairo tiger]

What is this the feel good thread

nothing more than feelings.....

 

[Grrr]

for me this week my outs would go
Rioli - putrid
McIntosh - just not up to the standard.
Aarts - just a battler.
Chol - what does he give us? answer usually very little.
Naish - Harsh on the kid here he deserves a block of games but i have others id prefer see get a game.

Team would go like this

B/ Vlastuin - Garthwaite - Grimes. Imo Garthwaite is more suited to a kp role than Broad thus freeing Grimes up.
HB/ Pickett - Balta - DE-S. HB is Picketts natural position id like just once for them to give him a go there. Des stays done more than enough for a 5 gamer.

C/ Lambert - Ross - Bolton. Pace combined with size Bolton gets shuffled to a wing and Lambert we know is suited there. IMO Better THEM than McIntosh
R/ Soldo - Martin - Cotchin. With out Nankervis no option but play Soldo but cant Play both Soldo and Chol they just dont give enough.

HF/ Stack - Riewoldt - Higgins. Prefer Stack at HB but he cant be worse than Rioli and Aarrts up fwd.
F/ RC-D - Lynch - Castagna. RC-D at 190cm plus gives us a sort of Dusty option up fwd rotating with Dusty on ball. A third tall option without Chol offering nothing.

INT/ Graham - Short - Broad - Baker. Would like to see what Broad has to offer further up the ground or even as a run with type.Short provides outside run and the other two are midfield rotations.

Garth out with groin issues.

 

[mopsy]

At least Kamdyn won some contested possessions! Not even close if you were aiming to name bottom 4 tonight.

When?

 

[Meteoric Rise]

for me this week my outs would go
Rioli - putrid
McIntosh - just not up to the standard.
Aarts - just a battler.
Chol - what does he give us? answer usually very little.
Naish - Harsh on the kid here he deserves a block of games but i have others id prefer see get a game.

Team would go like this

B/ Vlastuin - Garthwaite - Grimes. Imo Garthwaite is more suited to a kp role than Broad thus freeing Grimes up.
HB/ Pickett - Balta - DE-S. HB is Picketts natural position id like just once for them to give him a go there. Des stays done more than enough for a 5 gamer.

C/ Lambert - Ross - Bolton. Pace combined with size Bolton gets shuffled to a wing and Lambert we know is suited there. IMO Better THEM than McIntosh
R/ Soldo - Martin - Cotchin. With out Nankervis no option but play Soldo but cant Play both Soldo and Chol they just dont give enough.

HF/ Stack - Riewoldt - Higgins. Prefer Stack at HB but he cant be worse than Rioli and Aarrts up fwd.
F/ RC-D - Lynch - Castagna. RC-D at 190cm plus gives us a sort of Dusty option up fwd rotating with Dusty on ball. A third tall option without Chol offering nothing.

INT/ Graham - Short - Broad - Baker. Would like to see what Broad has to offer further up the ground or even as a run with type.Short provides outside run and the other two are midfield rotations.

LOL, in Mopsy’s world you don’t need to prepare to play in a position within an AFL team system. Mopsy just has one look at you and says you will be more suited to a completely different position without preparation....along with 7 of your teammates.

And with one set of casually conceived Mopsy decisions that is it, every problem that led to two premierships and a minor premiership in the last 3 seasons is fixed in a oner.

Vote 1 Mopsy.

 

[Hoos]

Well he put the words in your mouth. Reckon with Stack back and in the mids, Naish will probably go out. Reckon DES might stay in, it's not like he was bad last week just lacked a bit of heat around the ball, but was close to best the week before. Cotchin for ...

Like for like (or as close as there is) it will possibly be Graham.

Rioli should be dropped but we all know he won't.

 

[Grrr]

Like for like (or as close as there is) it will possibly be Graham.

Rioli should be dropped but we all know he won't.

I wonder if Higgins could do with a rest, just a game. He hasn't played a lot of footy. Might save Rioli, who has looked a bit more lively in the last half of the last two games.

 

[Grrr]

When?

Last week he may not have gotten a lot of ball but he was strong when it was in his area. Don't remember his opponent getting it much. The week before he has 24 good possessions. Also the Dogs are a hard running side, will need MacIntosh's size and strength and straight ahead style.

 

[tunksy]

Rioli out. Who'd have thought!