VFL Round 10 - Casey vs Collingwood at Casey Fields (Pies lost 53-76 #IrkThisFixture)

Remove this Banner Ad

Our list management and recuiting department need to be shot, we have no key position players coming through or even on the list, you might say McClarty, but he is no where near AFL level, we may have to go into this years draft with Key position players as a must
 
Haha, yeah, I was just being a smartass. He's more than reasonable at VFL level, very underwhelming as an AFL listed player though.

This one will devastate Bigfooty posters but Wills will be delisted at the end of this year. Bookmark it

Contracted for 2019. Could be moved to the rookie list, but they won't cut him loose with a contract signed.
 

Log in to remove this ad.


Yup, to sum up the quarter Pies dominating play but butchering entries into fwd 50 and not looking like scoring. Contrast that with Casey, clean entries with forwards getting separation taking uncontested marks. Luckily for us they’ve been a little wasteful and defenders such as Hore standing up to hold back the tide.
 
Yes. Sier is just flat out better. Wills spread is non-existent and he is so lumbering, can't see him filling a role at AFL level.

I agree his speed hurts him and his chances. But it's been pleasing to see his development this year. Winning far more footy. Reckon he is a touch lighter over the ground. I reckon he's pretty handy inside mid depth myself so can't see him being delisted. But a depth option not best 22 quality player.
 
VFL team struggling a lot due to the AFL listed injuries. We've got 11 AFL listed players on the sidelines at the moment, makes it tough for the VFL team

Contracted for 2019. Could be moved to the rookie list, but they won't cut him loose with a contract signed.

Wow, that's a big surprise to me
 
Our list management and recuiting department need to be shot, we have no key position players coming through or even on the list, you might say McClarty, but he is no where near AFL level, we may have to go into this years draft with Key position players as a must

Yep we're one or two key position sized players short for good list balance. The injuries hurt but that's foreseeable. Bringing in Kelly next year will help. Reckon we needed a few more VFL listed options. Also can't say I agree with your assessment of McLarty, he has great movement for a big guy, but needs to work on his consistency. He'll get there.
 
VFL team struggling a lot due to the AFL listed injuries. We've got 11 AFL listed players on the sidelines at the moment, makes it tough for the VFL team



Wow, that's a big surprise to me

Signed late last season, they just slipped it in under the radar.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Remove this Banner Ad

VFL Round 10 - Casey vs Collingwood at Casey Fields (Pies lost 53-76 #IrkThisFixture)

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top