Preview Round 14 changes v dogs @marvel Sunday 4:40pm before the bye

[The Nostradamus]

I don't see it either, but I imagine most posters' list of reasons is as follows:
He isn't Aaron Hall

Playing 1 less than having hall would be a great result in itself

So LDU's gone from 'progressing well' with a 3-5 week injury to missing the full five. Brilliant

Where’s this been confirmed

 

[Gasometer]

Who’s going to stop our Perennial Kerridge award winner Bruce?

 

[The Filth Wizard]

He was good today. Rather a kid turning it over than a veteran. Offers better disposal than Hall and is defensively better at a cost to raw numbers.

I agree here, time to phase out Hall like they have Turner. The only thing to remember though is the patience is then required for Perez (or Goater eventually) as it should be for Phoenix and Bobby Jr when he gets in.

 

[Petrie4PM]

Out: Spicer, Hall, McDonald (please send him a message)
In: Simpkin, Greenwood, Perez/Dawson (assuming LDU not avail)

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

Out: Hall, Tucker, Bergman (rest, looked tired)

In: Perez/Young, Simpkin, Greenwood

 

[hellas_johnny]

Out: Hall, Tucker, Bergman (rest, looked tired)

In: Perez/Young, Simpkin, Greenwood

We have a bye the week after what's the point in resting

 

[scottywiper]

Perez was excellent in VFL today. Played with dash and confidence, and used the ball well.
I can't see why you'd stick with Hall.

 

[amaz199]

God help us against this mob. Going to this game with very little, if any, confidence about us being competitive.

 

[giantroo]

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

We have a bye the week after what's the point in resting

Because he only had 4 disposals and I rather we not burn all our kids out.

 

[Roosurgence]

Simply are not the options to cover 2 of them let alone 4 (ignoring spicer because i dont mind playing him and there will be players to cover him when braydon george and bobby H Jr come on),

You could play a 5ft leper and have the same impact as these blokes.

Simpkin comes back so that’s one gone, most likely Corr. Perez could scratch his arse and have Hall’s impact, the same if you brought in Cooper Harvey over Spicer.

As for Ziebell or McDonald why not try someone like Dawson?

 

[King Corey]

That WAS our one crack at a win pissed up out there today.

Lordy lordy what those umpire immune freerunners will do to us next week chills me to the bone.

 

[Horizons_00]

I’ve got zero confidence in this game.

Bulldogs will give us a thumping.

It’s depressing because I can’t see where our next nourishing win comes from. We are giving our full effort but it’s not afl level.

 

[scottywiper]

I’ve got zero confidence in this game.

Bulldogs will give us a thumping.

It’s depressing because I can’t see where our next nourishing win comes from. We are giving our full effort but it’s not afl level.

Its likely West Coast or bust. Surely we get a PP after two spoons and a 2-3 win season...
I'm so sick of losing... And then hearing chat about how it's coming together. Hawks have flown past us.

 

[andana]

Is Logue ok? Had a long break on the bench in the last

 

[Harvs29]

Whilst he has been effective in the middle, if Hall goes out, I'd be putting Thomas to his position.

 

[zoomba23]

God help us against this mob. Going to this game with very little, if any, confidence about us being competitive.

Excluding games involving West Coast, this is potentially the most one sided matchup between any two teams in the league. We're a flat track dream

 

[Mav]

He has been in good form the last 2 weeks

Uses the ball well and cracks in hard

So the complete opposite of Stephenson.

 

[HTPunter]

Not sure what people are seeing in the VFL that makes them want Perez in.

I just don't see it tbh.

It’s not about Perez, it’s just Hall is a complete waste.

If Perez gets the rest of the season we soon see if he has anything to work with. Sure it might be say a 25% chance that he ends up a player but we need to know.

Hall is a 0% chance from here. His best is done, he’s not taking us anywhere, he’s a liability.

 

[HTPunter]

Who’s going to stop our Perennial Kerridge award winner Bruce?

If the Dogs are serious, Bevo will stop him.

Bruce is going as bad as any of our players right now. Lost at FB, his knee has really done a number on him this late in his career.

Expect Jamarra and Cody to kick painful bags of 5 and 4 on us.

 

[Merlin007]

Young was average today.

we were watching different games

 

[HTPunter]

In: Simpkin, Greenwood, Perez

Out: Hall, Corr, Spicer/Curtis, Bergman (to sub)

B: McDonald, McKay, Ziebell
HB: Perez, Logue, Sheezel
C: Scott, Phillips, Ford
HF: Thomas, CCJ, Stephenson
F: Zurhaar, Larkey, Curtis/Spicer
Foll: Goldstein, Simpkin, Greenwood
Bench: Tucker, Shiels, Wardlaw, Powell
Sub: Bergman

Curtis/Spicer and Tucker on notice. But don’t need to upset too much balance in the side.

We can’t carry both Curtis and Spicer as they both spend too long being uncompetitive but at the same time I want one getting extended continued run in the side to give it their best chance at “belonging”.

 

[Merlin007]

We have a bye the week after what's the point in resting

Bergman is dropping the ball in dangerous spots, second week in a row; needs to go back and regain some confidence. Perez and Young are both ready

 

[shinboner magic]

Out
Hall, ziebs ,Bergman ,

In
Greenwood , Jy , Perez
Make sleevo sub and bring corr in

 

[Moti]

Wonder when Bonar is back. Need to give him a block as it is a contract year. Ideally take Jacks spot


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com