The Trade Thread (Part 2)

[saintsrfreak]

Re: The Trade Thread

Just created a twitter account to do that Stay Tommy!

 

[Simple Jack]

Re: The Trade Thread

What deal?

It was put up that we would give them Walsh for Armstrong and some pick or something in a 3 way w/ Adelaide.

 

[saintsrfreak]

Re: The Trade Thread

It was put up that we would give them Walsh for Armstrong and some pick or something in a 3 way w/ Adelaide.

Well Armstrong can't be traded again.

 

[thomas_m18]

Re: The Trade Thread

Armstrong wanted to go to NSW, didn't he?

 

[Squizz]

Re: The Trade Thread

Yep that's it

Up the top just type in something like

Stay at the Saints @tommywalshkor we don't want you to go #stayTommyW

...and hit tweet

Done (I think).

Ta.

 

[Persevering Saint]

Re: The Trade Thread

Squizzy1970 Squizzy
First ever tweet. Too important not to. Stay at the Saints @tommywalshkor we don't want you to go #stayTommyW

Feel the man-love.

 

[Defacto]

Re: The Trade Thread

It's official, Johnston for Armstrong, 33 and a late pick

sydney get adelaides 35 pick, which is going to cause us a host of problems when trying to keep walsh.

we need to make some trade for a pick higher than 35 fast, or we do a straight swap for rohan.

 

[Membling]

Re: The Trade Thread

Straight swap for Rohan? Yeah been r*ped once this trade period. Pick thirty five and maybe fringe player but who knows what'll happen

 

[saintsrfreak]

Re: The Trade Thread

Lewis Jetta please.

 

[stkildathunda]

Re: The Trade Thread

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...-and-tommy-walsh/story-fn69a32t-1226167495031

Walsh, who is yet to make his AFL debut since crossing from Ireland in 2009, wants to join the Swans after they promised him greater opportunity.

But the Saints insist they won't let him leave, declaring Walsh a required player who they have tried to re-sign since the middle of the year.

Pelchen also dismissed speculation that Sean Dempster, who finished third in this year's best-and-fairest, had not been offered a new contract.

St Kilda's head of football, Chris Pelchen, said the Saints wanted to keep Gram, but suggested they might have their price.

"Because Jason is contracted our preference is for him to stay at the club. He certainly hasn't been put on the table ... but we're mindful of the fact that we've got restrictions and constraints," Pelchen said.

"There's certainly been interest shown. We've made it clear to clubs who have made inquiries that he is contracted. If they want to discuss Jason, OK, we'll listen to what they put forward."

Gram, who returns from Bali tomorrow, is believed to have attracted interest from North Melbourne, while Carlton has made preliminary inquiries.

 

[CHBench]

Re: The Trade Thread

As long as we don't budge on TW. That's my biggest fear over the next 2 days.

Im pretty confident Scotty can at least convince him to stay for 1 more year. A vote of confidence from the coach kind of thing, something that obviously wasn't provided before.

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Re: The Trade Thread

sydney get adelaides 35 pick, which is going to cause us a host of problems when trying to keep walsh.

we need to make some trade for a pick higher than 35 fast, or we do a straight swap for rohan.

Serious post?

 

[Defacto]

Re: The Trade Thread

Serious post?

very serious. theres no way we'll give him up for nothing or even an equal trade. you want him then your paying overs. otherwise we redraft him.

 

[BarneyBent]

Re: The Trade Thread

very serious. theres no way we'll give him up for nothing or even an equal trade. you want him then your paying overs. otherwise we redraft him.

You honestly think Tommy Walsh is of equal value to Gary Rohan? Seriously?

 

[Defacto]

Re: The Trade Thread

You honestly think Tommy Walsh is of equal value to Gary Rohan? Seriously?

no. as i said the saints should make sydney pay overs for him if they want him.

 

[Danair]

Re: The Trade Thread

very serious. theres no way we'll give him up for nothing or even an equal trade. you want him then your paying overs. otherwise we redraft him.

You better be prepared to use pick 25 for a guy who doesn't want to be at your club anymore.

 

[Defacto]

Re: The Trade Thread

You better be prepared to use pick 25 for a guy who doesn't want to be at your club anymore.

who said we'd have to? that implies sydney will use pick 35 on walsh.

i have a feeling a trade will happen between saints and freo that will give us a high 20's low 30's pick.

 

[BarneyBent]

Re: The Trade Thread

no. as i said the saints should make sydney pay overs for him if they want him.

Pick 35 would be paying overs. Gary Rohan would be repeated anal rapage.

Besides which, why on earth would we pay overs? Walsh is a 23 year old rookie listed player that wants out. You guys don't have any bargaining power at all. We can just offer him an immense 1 year deal and pick him up in the PSD. Nobody else will touch him if he wants to go to Sydney and his price is that high. We can then pay him peanuts for the next two years.

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Re: The Trade Thread

very serious. theres no way we'll give him up for nothing or even an equal trade. you want him then your paying overs. otherwise we redraft him.

Not here to troll at all, we've had enough smug Crows supporters on our board tonight.

On a totally serious note, we'd never trade Rohan for Walsh and the Saints wouldn't ask because they'd already know the answer. I have a feeling he'll stay with the Saints, but if we used pick 35 on him I'd be thrilled.

 

[saintsrfreak]

Re: The Trade Thread

Not here to troll at all, we've had enough smug Crows supporters on our board tonight.

On a totally serious note, we'd never trade Rohan for Walsh and the Saints wouldn't ask because they'd already know the answer. I have a feeling he'll stay with the Saints, but if we used pick 35 on him I'd be thrilled.

Lewis Jetta?

 

[Defacto]

Re: The Trade Thread

Lewis Jetta?

i'd jump at that, but could we fit him under the cap?

 

[Simple Jack]

Re: The Trade Thread

Lewis Jetta?

Christ no.

We've got enough players who can't get the ball through the two big sticks thank you very much.

It cost us the ultimate prize

 

[saintsrfreak]

Re: The Trade Thread

i'd jump at that, but could we fit him under the cap?

Wouldn't be on too much you'd think.

 

[saintsrfreak]

Re: The Trade Thread

Christ no.

We've got enough players who can't get the ball through the two big sticks thank you very much.

It cost us the ultimate prize

That was last year, he kicks goals now.

 

[Defacto]

Re: The Trade Thread

he would bring some much needed pace,run and creativity. my worry is he might be a bit like peake. great during the h/a season. terrible during finals.