List Mgmt. Trade & F/A - 2018/2019 - Part 3

[grayza2018]

There are no points attached to compensation picks. So 57 will need to be traded before the draft, possibly to whoever has 58. They come down 1 in the draft position and we get some points.

Whoops my bad!

 

[Unknown Identity]

Just once i'd love to leave a trade period feeling like we have underpaid for a player.

Clubs always seem to extract that little bit more out of us.. The Collingwood Tax.

 

[left at home]

I'm not convinced a bid will come for IQ before 18, I guess time will tell. Wouldn't it be funny if the Bears make a bid with 18.

Not totally convinced either, but going off the club they seem to be.
Well my interpretation anyway. Later the better or not at all would be my preference about the bids.

 

[Boogy]

We got Dayne “top 10 in the Brownlow” Beams and people are complaining.. Jesus wept.

We literally have the best midfield of all time. Let that sink in.

Discarding pick 18 this year was always a gamble worth taking and IQ and Kelly plus a gun list of depth mean we can step out of the first round next year.

We got Sier and Maynard for 30s picks. Hine is better at nailing talent late in the draft (DeGoey excepted).

Not to mention all the posters critical of where Cal Twomey named our academy/FS boys in his phantom and several posters saying those picks were over inflated, yet now crying foul.

Sheeesh!

Like this twice! Couldn't agree more.
If we have any luck with injuries and get Elliott back....look the F$#k Out!

 

[nahnah]

It’s just plain funny now that Lynch didn’t pick us, what an idiot. Regret incoming

 

[Port Magpie]

Like this twice! Couldn't agree more.
If we have any luck with injuries and get Elliott back....look the F$#k Out!

Yep, a year out is a long time in football. We are going to get an injection of A grade talent in the form of Elliot and Beams. So long as Bucks maintains and can instill this years game plan into the 22 next year, we are sooo much better placed for a tilt at the flag.

 

[Sunbot]

Just once i'd love to leave a trade period feeling like we have underpaid for a player.

Clubs always seem to extract that little bit more out of us.. The Collingwood Tax.

You mean like 4 years ago when we traded Beams

 

[Unknown Identity]

You mean like 4 years ago when we traded Beams

5, 25 and a fringe player wasn't overs at the time.

Only seems that way now because of nailing the draft selection (DeGoey) at 5 and Crisp's substantial improvement.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Fremantle's forward line is going to be handfull next season, especially if they get Bennell up and running however unlikely that is.

Kudos to them, really rate their trade period.

HF: Bennell* - Lobb - Matera
F: Walters - Hogan - McCarthy

 

[Albert Parker]

Yep, a year out is a long time in football. We are going to get an injection of A grade talent in the form of Elliot and Beams. So long as Bucks maintains and can instill this years game plan into the 22 next year, we are sooo much better placed for a tilt at the flag.

I think, most likely, we get a lot more games out of Moore this year. He has the potential to be a great footballer too.

 

[Albert Parker]

While those noting that the Beams trade only really works if Quaynor gets taken before pick 18, that pre-supposes that we aren't very happy to take Quaynor with pick 18 anyhow.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

To sum up:

Did we bring in real quality A grade talent in the draft?

Yes.

Good. Successful.

Roughead spare parts at no cost, ok as depth for position.

 

[wicksy]

With Beams in the side competition for midfield spots will be TIGHT next season.

Right now you would think:

Phillips, Sidebottom, Beams
Grundy, Adams, Treloar
With Pendles and Sier on the bench (Aish and Thomas rotating).

I like Mayne, and I think he had a ripper season, but with Beams coming in I think that they may need to find another position to player other than winger.

Wasnt he playing mainly in defense in our finals series? I'd drop Aish a long time before we dropped Mayne.

 

[Soups]

I hope this random bloke is bluffing.

There is no way in this world Kelly is rated in the top 10. He’s having a lend.

 

[Port Magpie]

There is no way in this world Kelly is rated in the top 10. He’s having a lend.

If they go Kelly top 10 then we pass on him. Can’t jeopardise our drafting if they are gonna just run interference.

 

[Baltimore Jack]

There is no way in this world Kelly is rated in the top 10. He’s having a lend.

Plus those people have no idea how the points system works

 

[Crazy Tails]

Trading 41 & 44 to North for 47, 48 and 49 would net us an extra 130 points

North need bid points for Tarryn Thomas, Bailey Scott and Darren Crocker's kid (they are likely to go into deficit too) so they won't help us.

 

[Bored_Pie]

I hope this random bloke is bluffing.

God you get sucked in easily

 

[Crazy Tails]

If we clear more list spots we'll be allocated later picks as well.

Yeah understood; hoping for a couple of late Hine smokey's there.

I was more thinking along the lines of what picks we had left with points attached (ie: less than 74).

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

So I guess we won't be picking up Riley Grundy this year.

 

[bencoop]

So I guess we won't be picking up Riley Grundy this year.

If he is there for the rookie draft potentially? But I assume one of the SA clubs will get him as a ploy to eventually get Brodes back to SA

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

If he is there for the rookie draft potentially? But I assume one of the SA clubs will get him as a ploy to eventually get Brodes back to SA

Yeah I think that will be the case. Crows most likely.

 

[unplugged]

I can't wait to win the race for Tomlinson as a FA when St Kilda have been chasing him for 4 years. Going to be great.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

I can't wait to win the race for Tomlinson as a FA when St Kilda have been chasing him for 4 years. Going to be great.

Gotta land one soon surely.

 

[Mongo Ming]

I’m confused.. can we still do a pick swap during live trading on draft day to get the Monopoly deal?