its more that they dont pull the trigger at the right time.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Autopsy Versus Melbourne
- Thread starter "The Roar Is Back"
- Start date
- Tagged users None
its more that they dont pull the trigger at the right time.
- May 8, 2007
- 48,686
- 71,373
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Banned
- #27
Conca, White and McGuane all were great as inclusions in a tough week, Batch was half decant and Derickx first up AFL game was good.
Dont get the criticism of the win. Might have been a scrappy, but with almost a third of the team new it was a great effort. We have the Suns next, and with further fine tuning and tweaking should see us good to go against North and the Cheats.
Dont get the criticism of the win. Might have been a scrappy, but with almost a third of the team new it was a great effort. We have the Suns next, and with further fine tuning and tweaking should see us good to go against North and the Cheats.
Grockadoc
Brownlow Medallist
- Jul 25, 2008
- 25,945
- 50,172
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Fighting Furies, Man Utd, Cavaliers
Thought Derickx was ok in the first quarter. Didn't do much afterwards, but his first quarter has been better than what Miller and Vickery have dished up all year. Worth persevering with next week, and with GC's backline, might cause a bit of damage.
I have a feeling if the Dee's had Jamar and Clark, they might have gotten over the line.
I have a feeling if the Dee's had Jamar and Clark, they might have gotten over the line.
- Apr 21, 2012
- 4,115
- 5,124
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Whoever's playing Carlton.
- Banned
- #29
I apologise - broke my own number one rule there.
As for Rance's deficiencies, I think I already explained on the first page of this thread.
Sorry, poorly worded. We were up at qtr time by 24 & won by 23
- May 8, 2007
- 48,686
- 71,373
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Banned
- #32
I got the feeling if we had a fit Vickery, Martin, Grimes, Jackson, King and even Connors as sub we still would have won.
Tony shaw would be livid he couldn't have put his 2c in on whites errant fist and jacks hit on frawley which had all the commentators getting their nooses out yet hardly a wimped for the behind play whack to mcguanes guts!
- Thread starter
- #34
Might be wrong but thought I heard them say he had 5 tackles in the first quarter ?
- Apr 21, 2012
- 4,115
- 5,124
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Whoever's playing Carlton.
- Banned
- #35
So you dont see him getting constantly outmarked, particularly when the ball is coming in? You think he manages to stay with his opponent enough in the same situation and they never manage to lose him? He has the same problems Moore had, but whereas Moore was too slow & too short, Rance just lacks a bit of nouse and timing.
- Banned
- #36
Foley?
- Thread starter
- #37
Pretty sure Connors won't ever be sub again ?
Could have been, not sure. Either way his pressure early was great for a 200cm beast. Watts shat himself when he saw X coming for him.
peejay
Brownlow Medallist
Just cried all day about the umps today on MMM what a pussy he is. Him and the guy whose cousin plays fullback for Melbourne just whined all day about the umps.
Makes me feel happy that they wasted a number one pick on nancy watts.
We were average but there is something to be said for winning ugly.
Makes me feel happy that they wasted a number one pick on nancy watts.
We were average but there is something to be said for winning ugly.
Yeah wasn't to bad in the ruck either. Bye bye miller
- May 8, 2007
- 48,686
- 71,373
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Banned
- #41
You missed the bit where i said "had" Cool nit picking though
Barnzy
Premium Platinum
Didn't listen to MMM but he normally whinges a lot about Richmond so I'm not surprised.
The Goon
Norm Smith Medallist
Was a both a disappointing win, and a good win.
The good:
Played reasonably well despite 1/3 of the team being turned over from last week.
Despite accuracy being a problem, this week it was largely from missing sitters (rather than speculative snaps).
Mr.X, White, Conca and McGuane all had decent games.
The Bad:
White will get 1-2 weeks for a stupid act.
Kicking accuracy - could / should have been in the 8.
Would have lost handsomely to a top 8 side, in particular North.
The good:
Played reasonably well despite 1/3 of the team being turned over from last week.
Despite accuracy being a problem, this week it was largely from missing sitters (rather than speculative snaps).
Mr.X, White, Conca and McGuane all had decent games.
The Bad:
White will get 1-2 weeks for a stupid act.
Kicking accuracy - could / should have been in the 8.
Would have lost handsomely to a top 8 side, in particular North.
Dustin Credible
Club Legend
Didn't listen to MMM. But the umps (whilst abysmal) didn't lose it for Melbourne.
They are horrific, as bad if not worse than we were in 2010. Lyon should stop whinging and try to figure out what's wrong at Melbourne.
They are horrific, as bad if not worse than we were in 2010. Lyon should stop whinging and try to figure out what's wrong at Melbourne.
jko'neal
Cancelled
4 Points was what we needed and got them, should have been by more but like a couple of times this year the opposition brought us down to thier level. Terrible game, horror week for the club and poor goal kicking, wrap it up and move on. As seen last night, even the very top teams have poor games.
Then if you had to watch it on fox, you had to listen to Dwayne "Come on Dees" Russell ..... there not out of it yet.
- Thread starter
- #47
Richo and Jack dyer also once played for the club , would you like to add them . Not nit picking just sick to death of the disruption Connors has always brought to the club and after this week was hoping we wouldn't have to endure him being linked to what is happening at the club .You missed the bit where i said "had" Cool nit picking though
I was very impressed with a couple of Riewoldt's marks - he's in good form at that part of his game.
Not sure why his kicking has dropped off so significantly since 2010 when he was automatic. Lots of reasons spouted by the media experts - all worth much the same.
Not sure why his kicking has dropped off so significantly since 2010 when he was automatic. Lots of reasons spouted by the media experts - all worth much the same.
Agree. No Martin, Grimes, Jackson, King etc. Four points are ours. Not to mention the loss of Foley. Had we kicked a little straighter we'd have murdered the hapless Dees.
Barnzy
Premium Platinum
We needed 4 points and %.
We've been poor since the GWS game so can't just put it down to 1 bad game.
#1 team for disposals but consistently can't finish teams off and take advantage of our dominance. Coaches seriously need to look at this and how we play. I knew as soon as we opened up a small lead early on but couldn't put our foot down past the 5-6 goal mark that it would be a frustrating day and Melbourne would be with us all the way.
On some player notes:
Dea- Don't think he is up to it. Just don't see it with him. Has zero awareness.
Deledio - Was okay. Has played better games.
Cotchin -Was okay. Has played better games.
Tuck - Very good.
Grigg - Very good.
A Maric - Again showed he isn't up to it.
Conca - Very good. 23 touches, 6 clearances. Natural midfielder who should've played against Adelaide.
Ellis - Best game of the year. 21 touches. Ripper kid.
I Maric - Tired.
McGuane - Handy in a new role. Can take a mark and doesn't move like an ocean liner so is an upgrade on Miller. I've always hated him as a player but happy to give him a chance in the side as a forward. True test will come against North, Carlton, etc not Melbourne and GC.
Derickx - Despite some calls of an impressive debut I thought he struggled. Has state league experience and is 24. 6 touches, 0 marks. Not enough.
Horrible performance which probably again showed why we aren't there yet. Worst win of the year. Move onto next week.
Similar threads
- Locked
