VFL VFL v Essendon - Sunday April 23rd @ Vic Park. 12pm.
- Thread starter Jen2310
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Pies_Iceman
Senior List
- Feb 28, 2014
- 256
- 350
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I think they're talking about Tomasiello.
- Mar 28, 2023
- 16,277
- 31,710
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
he was good yesterday. My comments about Reef still stand anyway 
- Mar 28, 2023
- 16,277
- 31,710
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Yep, okay. Got it now.
I was reading another thread about Reef and got a bit defensive and protective about Reef 
Kirby
Knee Deep in Hell's Sewerage
Veteran
Collingwood - Beau McCreery Player Sponsor 2023
10k Posts
Collingwood - Caleb Poulter Player Sponsor 2022
Collingwood - Josh Daicos Player Sponsor 2021
Collingwood - Tyler Brown Player Sponsor 2020
Collingwood Magpies - Brayden Sier 2019 Player Sponsor
Collingwood - Jaidyn Stephenson Player Sponsor 2018
Yes I think he played a very similar game, particularly in the second half.
He won quite a bit of footy in tight too (like JDG) but I think it's fait to say that he was largely positioned in an offensive manner and 80% of his possessions would have been in our forward 2/3s of the ground.
3 likely AFL players and 2 maybes.
To replace Pendles, Steele, Howe, Elliott, Adams, Mitchell, WHE over coming seasons.
Most teams would have a lot more then that to list as developing ins.
I thought myself he looks a likely lad,there was a piece of play where he showed great strength to hold off a tackler,what is he 18 I think a few people will be watching him with interest.
sr36
TheBrownDog
That's 7 players whose departures will probably be spread out over 4 years with a lot more draftees and more mature recruits to come in during that time. We've just added 4 ready mades in an off season and a couple of talented kids without spending a bomb. Getting the quality is the issue rather than the quantity and as always, development is going to be key for those currently inside and outside the team and those who land on the list over the coming years.
Last edited:
RobJD
Club Legend
- Oct 1, 2021
- 1,676
- 3,149
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Bit harsh I reckon - add an additional 12 listed players to yesterday's side and you've got a very good VFL team.
Kelly
Bianco
Markov (depth don't rate his disposal for position currently in favour but scepticalon long term).
Wilson
Ruscoe is 50/50 seemingly not rated by coaches.
Richards
Big questions on Draper, Murley, Harrison, Begg, Dean for various reasons, although some have showing glimpses at stages.
Pendles and sidey aside. We traded in adams, treloar, Mitchell and lipinski. If we need high quality mids we can just trade them in. Ryan and Allan look good, I’m still bullish on macrae and Carmy. Add to that 1st and 2nd rounders this year. It’s talls we need IMO, unless kreuger and dean miraculously become best 22
sr36
TheBrownDog
If you're looking for top end AFL talent, the VFL ain't a great place to look. You get a bit at this stage of the year with first year players, but 2nd or 3rd year top level talent is usually already playing AFL.
Mollythedolly
Norm Smith Medallist
- Oct 21, 2021
- 6,901
- 8,347
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I just think you’re being a bit harsh. Had 14 disposals and a couple of goals. Against the Saints, his senior contemporaries had 12 & 3 (Hill), 12 & 1 (McCreery), 13 & 1 (Ginnivan), and 11 & 1 (Elliott). His numbers stack up and general forward pressure is okay and are ballpark what you’d expect from a small forward.
Mollythedolly
Norm Smith Medallist
- Oct 21, 2021
- 6,901
- 8,347
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Half the guys that are still standing and playing VFL have had interrupted preseasons. I think we need to give them a bit of time to build into the season before we start drawing these sorts of conclusions. A lot of footy still to be played this season.
Ok - so I don’t see how your comment “that the cupboard is bare” is justified given the only clear prospects at risk of delisting are Kelly, Wilson and probably Richards.
“Big questions” on the others is a premature call - much like those calling for Murphy to be delisted in 2021.
So I can’t support your “cupboard is bare”, comment.
Last edited:
Yeah, Charlie Dean is contracted for 2024. The club must have been very impressed with what they saw of him from the start, and I don't think there's any chance they'll axe him when he's had such a bad run with injuries. That would be a "bad look"! I think the likes of Draper (especially) and possibly Harrison as well will be given more time. Same with Begg, especially given our recent issues with talls, though I agree with those that think he might have a better future as a key defender. Even Murley showed a bit the other day, and (while being re-rookied is not a good sign) if he can keep that up for the rest of the season he might somehow survive the cut.
Richards should be contracted for next year as well, and even though he's not shown a lot (being injured at the moment doesn't help), I'd expect him to be on our list in 2024, even if he ends up being demoted to the Rookie List. Finding enough players to delist may not be an easy task. Wilson might be let go, but as a Cat. B Rookie he doesn't really count, and removing him wouldn't really help the list numbers situation. The fact that we have Markov as an "extra player" (brought in due to Dean's injury - giving us a total of 43 Primary list and Cat. A Rookies, instead of the standard 42) should make it even harder to get the list in order at the end of the season. I'm pretty happy with the state of our list, think we have a couple of very exciting (untried) prospects in Allan and Ryan, others like Macrae and McInnes hopefully will get there, and Steene may well do down the track. Then we have the likes of N. Daicos, Ginnivan, Hill, McCreery, Murphy and Quaynor who are all 23 or under and playing regular senior football, so I think we're quite well placed.
I think that’s being a little bit overly optimistic. Essendons VFL side was v ordinary, as were a lot of their senior listed players. Zach Reid and Lewis Hayes are both head scratchers, and potential bullets dodged. Whilst we are obv lacking in a lot of key position depts, and have only a couple of young players with genuine A grade potential, to replace a lot of star power in the coming years. Hence why GW will have to go back to the trade and FA table again this year.
Ie we have NO young KPFs coming through, and our young KPB stocks are reliant on Deane, who isn’t athletic enough to replace Howe, and too small to backup Darcy or Frampton. Whilst struggling with injury. Begg is also v slow and lacking in agility, so will not make it imo. Kelly has had 4 years to prove himself, and is another bust. Steene is 18 months away from being ready to judge. So that’s no big man depth at the moment, none.
For mids, Allan has the X factor, but there almost endeth the star factor. Carmy seems the next most likely imo, with big boy skills, whilst Macrae has taken longer to develop than expected, and is quite vanilla tbh. Draper still has work to do to get some actual runs on the board, as does Harrison, whilst Murley looks a VFL level FP, and Richards has struggled to impact, despite being a mature ager.
Reef looks a v good third tall forward, but has no tank, so midfield hopes are v slim imo. & Ryan is the other one with senior level potential, but also needs to continue to improve.
So a couple of mids with work to do, a HBF, a third defender who needs to overcome injuries, a third tall forward, plus an undrafted developing young ruckman. The rest could honestly be delisted at years end.
Sadly, too many poor or traded away draft picks, plus fire sale trades have left our young stocks quite bare, with virtually no young talls coming good, our recent Irish experiments not working, plus the Stevenson and Poulter picks also hurting.
Ie we have NO young KPFs coming through, and our young KPB stocks are reliant on Deane, who isn’t athletic enough to replace Howe, and too small to backup Darcy or Frampton. Whilst struggling with injury. Begg is also v slow and lacking in agility, so will not make it imo. Kelly has had 4 years to prove himself, and is another bust. Steene is 18 months away from being ready to judge. So that’s no big man depth at the moment, none.
For mids, Allan has the X factor, but there almost endeth the star factor. Carmy seems the next most likely imo, with big boy skills, whilst Macrae has taken longer to develop than expected, and is quite vanilla tbh. Draper still has work to do to get some actual runs on the board, as does Harrison, whilst Murley looks a VFL level FP, and Richards has struggled to impact, despite being a mature ager.
Reef looks a v good third tall forward, but has no tank, so midfield hopes are v slim imo. & Ryan is the other one with senior level potential, but also needs to continue to improve.
So a couple of mids with work to do, a HBF, a third defender who needs to overcome injuries, a third tall forward, plus an undrafted developing young ruckman. The rest could honestly be delisted at years end.
Sadly, too many poor or traded away draft picks, plus fire sale trades have left our young stocks quite bare, with virtually no young talls coming good, our recent Irish experiments not working, plus the Stevenson and Poulter picks also hurting.
Last edited:
Apex36
Hall of Famer
- Mar 26, 2014
- 41,144
- 88,593
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I wonder if they gave him a free cheeseburger voucher as a part of his encouragement award?
Similar threads
