Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[Thrawn]

I actually would like to know how many of our Carlton friends have seen a flag?

I know Arrow has seen 13 but I’m not too sure about the others!

I've seen two in my lifetime.

 

[kreuze_missile]

Cripps only had 14 kicks tonight. Quite pathetic really

Only got 3 Brownlow votes too.

Daicos would have got 4.

 

[Jimthegreat]

I actually would like to know how many of our Carlton friends have seen a flag?

I know Arrow has seen 13 but I’m not too sure about the others!

I'm on 8 from 13 Grand Finals.

@#$# i'm old....lol.

 

[Mr Meow]

Interested to hear from "THE NEUTRALS" Mr Meow and Grand Uncle Horace - Collingwood posters are feeling let down jilted and all lonely tonight come and give them a big sympathy cuddle - make them feel better.

I mean show me where, before or during the season, I've had Cartlton less than top 4 or a genuine contender.

 

[Jimthegreat]

Ha, keep telling yourself that, I’ve always stated I think Carlton will be in the PF this season.

Carlton’s flag to lose. Pop the champers!

Only if Sydney can somehow vanish...lol.

Handy if Collingwood could too...haha.

 

[Arr0w]

I mean show me where, before or during the season, I've had Cartlton less than top 4 or a genuine contender.

Nice try, hilarious when you tagged a number of us after our previous outing

 

[Thrawn]

Interested to hear from "THE NEUTRALS" Mr Meow and Grand Uncle Horace - Collingwood posters are feeling let down jilted and all lonely tonight come and give them a big sympathy cuddle - make them feel better.

Nah I'm more interested to hear My Tilly take on things. Might hear a cat whimper.

 

[carlton_99]

Haha, you can if you need too !

Too many to count then. Plus all those trade periods we won

 

[Mr Meow]

Nice try, hilarious when you tagged a number of us after our previous outing

Show me the receipts where I dismissed Carltons credentials. I called out sooking and excuse making early in the year, said they would turn things around and so it turned out. They're playing the smooth, top 4 level football I predicted of them before the season.

Unsurprosingly, the whinging has stopped so we are all getting along famously. Except you. You're an antagonistic odd ball.

 

[Thrawn]

Show me the receipts where I dismissed Carltons credentials. I called out sooking and excuse making early in the year, said they would turn things around and so it turned out. They're playing the smooth, top 4 level football I predicted of them before the season.

Unsurprosingly, the whinging has stopped so we are all getting along famously. Except you. You're an antagonistic odd ball.

I poke cat beans to annoy them. It's hilarious.

 

[Arr0w]

Show me the receipts where I dismissed Carltons credentials. I called out sooking and excuse making early in the year, said they would turn things around and so it turned out. They're playing the smooth, top 4 level football I predicted of them before the season.

Unsurprosingly, the whinging has stopped so we are all getting along famously. Except you. You're an antagonistic odd ball.

Nice backtracking

 

[Mr Meow]

Nice backtracking

No receipts looks like you conceded.

 

[Arr0w]

A game and percentage clear

Blues v Tigers

Suns v Pies

 

[Arr0w]

No receipts looks like you concded.

Conceded? Funny

 

[Mr Meow]

Conceded? Funny

Relax and smile. There's no point being a manic saddo after a win like an ex Nazi with PTSD.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

What do Pies and Blues folk think about the general standard of footy this season? I find it poor.

I find it truly odd my mob is so far ahead. I reckon we are decent enough but this is absurd. We have umpteen holes to fill and must improve to be competitive… if there is One area we’ve improved it is the ruck. (We are grateful to Lapband Eddie for bequeathing the Grundy subsidy. Does not make up for his racism or being a low life but the subsidy amuses a lot of people)

Yep the Blues finally had a dominant win tonight and good for them but the Cats look completely gone. The Blues in most other years would not be a top 4 team but there you are.

The Pies are down some decent players but are still getting wins. But they too are unimpressive. Their game v nmfc provided a lot of comedy but little else, beyond suburban std footy.

I’ve maybe watched the Dons 4 times but have not been impressed at all. They look like a Blues mid table standard team and produce a unique level of ennui footy that is bad for mental health.

Port under Hinkley are just wack jobs. Giants and Lions are decent enough but chuck in a lot of inexplicable sub par performances.

Footscray are again threatening to be the media, Ump and AFL darlings.

Hawks are the one team that seems to have improved. As for the others meh.

What to do? Bringing in a 19th team, as much as TAS deserve to be here, is heading in the wrong direction. We need to eliminate or amalgamate sufficient Melbourne teams to get us to 16 teams. The quality of footy would markedly increase.

 

[ITCHY EYEBALLS]

I actually would like to know how many of our Carlton friends have seen a flag?

I know Arrow has seen 13 but I’m not too sure about the others!

68, 70, 72, 79, 81, 82, 87, 95 for me….geez Arr0w must be old.

 

[Thrawn]

68, 70, 72, 79, 81, 82, 87, 95 for me….geez Arr0w must be old.

He was found in an archeological dig, very rusty.

 

[SpiritOfCarlton]

I actually would like to know how many of our Carlton friends have seen a flag?

I know Arrow has seen 13 but I’m not too sure about the others!

I've only been alive for six premierships. Young-un at 52.

 

[Aphrodite]

Nah I'm more interested to hear My Tilly take on things. Might hear a cat whimper.

 

[Mister Dog]

What do Pies and Blues folk think about the general standard of footy this season? I find it poor.

I find it truly odd my mob is so far ahead. I reckon we are decent enough but this is absurd. We have umpteen holes to fill and must improve to be competitive… if there is One area we’ve improved it is the ruck. (We are grateful to Lapband Eddie for bequeathing the Grundy subsidy. Does not make up for his racism or being a low life but the subsidy amuses a lot of people)

Yep the Blues finally had a dominant win tonight and good for them but the Cats look completely gone. The Blues in most other years would not be a top 4 team but there you are.

The Pies are down some decent players but are still getting wins. But they too are unimpressive. Their game v nmfc provided a lot of comedy but little else, beyond suburban std footy.

I’ve maybe watched the Dons 4 times but have not been impressed at all. They look like a Blues mid table standard team and produce a unique level of ennui footy that is bad for mental health.

Port under Hinkley are just wack jobs. Giants and Lions are decent enough but chuck in a lot of inexplicable sub par performances.

Footscray are again threatening to be the media, Ump and AFL darlings.

Hawks are the one team that seems to have improved. As for the others meh.

What to do? Bringing in a 19th team, as much as TAS deserve to be here, is heading in the wrong direction. We need to eliminate or amalgamate sufficient Melbourne teams to get us to 16 teams. The quality of footy would markedly increase.

It’s hard to disagree with any of that. Really bang on.

I still think Collingwood and Brisbane are both set to find some stellar form as the season goes on.
Especially Brisbane but it’ll be too late to make too 4. Pies would be 7-12 side without Nick Daicos.

Blues are a good side, not great compared to sides of other years and I worry what will happen when they become the hunted or if they cop some top end injuries to the KPPs.

Cats are a rabble.

Sydney need a loss to release the pressure valve.

 

[JustaBattler]

I mean show me where, before or during the season, I've had Cartlton less than top 4 or a genuine contender.

The only 'altercation' I've had with you is you disagreeing with me regarding who was going to win the rematch - and why.

as for my post it was in jest since you and GUH have been solid "friends of fudgey" in this thread.

Cheers anyway and all the best for the rest of the year.

For my part - I think Carlton are a good chance to finish the year ahead of Collingwood - and the most emphatic proof of that I wish happens in a final at the G - with teams fielding their best 22.

 

[Arr0w]

Very quiet in here, Pies on a bye holiday?

 

[Worm4]

I'm on 8 from 13 Grand Finals.

@#$# i'm old....lol.

Oh goodie. Role Call
5 for me and I was there for every single one of them.
Do I get extra points for being conceived during the 1970 GF ?

 

[Worm4]

What do Pies and Blues folk think about the general standard of footy this season? I find it poor.

I find it truly odd my mob is so far ahead. I reckon we are decent enough but this is absurd. We have umpteen holes to fill and must improve to be competitive… if there is One area we’ve improved it is the ruck. (We are grateful to Lapband Eddie for bequeathing the Grundy subsidy. Does not make up for his racism or being a low life but the subsidy amuses a lot of people)

Yep the Blues finally had a dominant win tonight and good for them but the Cats look completely gone. The Blues in most other years would not be a top 4 team but there you are.

The Pies are down some decent players but are still getting wins. But they too are unimpressive. Their game v nmfc provided a lot of comedy but little else, beyond suburban std footy.

I’ve maybe watched the Dons 4 times but have not been impressed at all. They look like a Blues mid table standard team and produce a unique level of ennui footy that is bad for mental health.

Port under Hinkley are just wack jobs. Giants and Lions are decent enough but chuck in a lot of inexplicable sub par performances.

Footscray are again threatening to be the media, Ump and AFL darlings.

Hawks are the one team that seems to have improved. As for the others meh.

What to do? Bringing in a 19th team, as much as TAS deserve to be here, is heading in the wrong direction. We need to eliminate or amalgamate sufficient Melbourne teams to get us to 16 teams. The quality of footy would markedly increase.

Grand Uncle Horace- the gift that keeps on giving.
You get told off in here for getting ahead of yourself.