2017 Trade & FA Targets - The Last Supper #Ameetos

[STK2020]

Peoples thoughts on Rory Atkins ?

 

[Jade Buddha]

Peoples thoughts on Rory Atkins ?

Good player but not a game changer. I wouldn't give up one of our top picks.

 

[Paddy2014]

I need to confess my sin , i spoke the evil , the treacherous talk of NOT renewing my memberships because of our quiet trade week , ranted , threw the toys , melted if you like .
Then .....
My lovely bride to be sat me down and played a music clip of Eddie Vedder's song " All the way " . For those not sure , its a song about Chicago Cubs and ending their 108 year World series drought , the love from their fans for the club , Wridley Park and their childhood growing up supporting their team like the generations before them .
Anyway like Molly ....Do yourselves a favor!
Im Born again , cant wait for Linton Street to be finished , cant wait for our premiership .
"GO SAINTS "

She's a keeper...!

 

[cooperrules]

Peoples thoughts on Rory Atkins ?

Showed his cards gf day

 

[Keg on legs]

I need to confess my sin , i spoke the evil , the treacherous talk of NOT renewing my memberships because of our quiet trade week , ranted , threw the toys , melted if you like .
Then .....
My lovely bride to be sat me down and played a music clip of Eddie Vedder's song " All the way " . For those not sure , its a song about Chicago Cubs and ending their 108 year World series drought , the love from their fans for the club , Wridley Park and their childhood growing up supporting their team like the generations before them .
Anyway like Molly ....Do yourselves a favor!
Im Born again , cant wait for Linton Street to be finished , cant wait for our premiership .
"GO SAINTS "

TESTIFY!

 

[Yawkey way]

When talking about our rucks please stop saying Rowan Marshall is a ruck, he isn't and never will be. A serviceable second ruck while playing as a KPD/KPF is what he is.

Any news ghost, are we likely to keep 7&8

 

[Yawkey way]

I keep wondering if we will make some moneyball trades but list spots are tight so who are we likely to trade out.

Is there any interest in anybody we would be willing to move.

 

[Moorabbin Ghost]

Any news ghost, are we likely to keep 7&8

No news mate. We are still trying on a couple of players and still enquiring about moving up the order.

 

[Ekomaira]

any clues on the players we're trying to get MG? I'm guessing Tomlinson is one, but the others?

 

[gringo2011]

his little mate jack sinclair is though, steele doesn't need to be.

sinc and gresh have the highest ceiling of any players on our list i think.
if those guys can become permanent mids- we've got 2 pendleburys in our midfield.
delicious

Billings not?

 

[Moral Decay]

No news mate. We are still trying on a couple of players and still enquiring about moving up the order.

any ideas on how the club feel about Darragh Joyce, will he make the grade?

 

[gringo2011]

Peoples thoughts on Rory Atkins ?

Yeah na, he's average.

 

[Diehard Saint]

Showed his cards gf day

As did most of the team, to be fair.

 

[King_Steele]

As did most of the team, to be fair.

 

[Diehard Saint]

I'd hazard a guess he's never going to live that statement down! Oops.

 

[King_Steele]

I'd hazard a guess he's never going to live that statement down! Oops.

The fool only kicks joe of the goose goals. He got found out big time.

 

[Impatient Saint]

Peoples thoughts on Rory Atkins ?

Saw he met with his manager Robbie D'Orazio in Melbourne yesterday - wheels in motion?

 

[okeydoke7]

The only reason Schache is attractive is the lack of interest. I reckon he will never be cheaper.

All logic says we should steer clear. We have that part of the list covered with Bruce and Membrey established, McCartin up and coming and Battle/Marshall as young prospects.

Schache would be overkill and we probably can't allow that many list spots to be taken by potential forwards.

However, for some club, it could make a great investment. A young forward, a pick 2, a bit of development and 30-40 games in him. He hasn't done much at all yet. He wants to go home and there's not much interest. You'll get him for a reasonable pick. You'd back yourselves to get more from him. Natural development, more experience, more development within the club, more strength. Moreover, the improvement from a sound mind. Back home. Not worrying about contracts and his future. He would improve, in sure of that.

A shrewd investment, in my opinion, but not one that we are in a position to make in all likelihood.

 

[Longmembrey]

The only reason Schache is attractive is the lack of interest. I reckon he will never be cheaper.

All logic says we should steer clear. We have that part of the list covered with Bruce and Membrey established, McCartin up and coming and Battle/Marshall as young prospects.

Schache would be overkill and we probably can't allow that many list spots to be taken by potential forwards.

However, for some club, it could make a great investment. A young forward, a pick 2, a bit of development and 30-40 games in him. He hasn't done much at all yet. He wants to go home and there's not much interest. You'll get him for a reasonable pick. You'd back yourselves to get more from him. Natural development, more experience, more development within the club, more strength. Moreover, the improvement from a sound mind. Back home. Not worrying about contracts and his future. He would improve, in sure of that.

A shrewd investment, in my opinion, but not one that we are in a position to make in all likelihood.

Will probably go cheap to Hawthorn. Brisbane owe them a favour for Hawks 'trading' Hodge to enable them to keep their Rockliff FA compensation

 

[bennymc7]

When talking about our rucks please stop saying Rowan Marshall is a ruck, he isn't and never will be. A serviceable second ruck while playing as a KPD/KPF is what he is.

Haven't seen enough of him myself but could he play FB??

 

[King_Steele]

Haven't seen enough of him myself but could he play FB??

Was played in defence a little bit for Sandy iirc

 

[bennymc7]

Billings not?

Of our younger players Billings is clearly no.1 at this stage imo..

Gresh, Sinclair, Steele a rung below but both have shown plenty to be excited about.

FWIW i reckon Dunstan will do a 2016 Ross next year and stamp himself as a real gun, future skipper

 

[coachnoodles]

The only reason Schache is attractive is the lack of interest. I reckon he will never be cheaper.

All logic says we should steer clear. We have that part of the list covered with Bruce and Membrey established, McCartin up and coming and Battle/Marshall as young prospects.

Schache would be overkill and we probably can't allow that many list spots to be taken by potential forwards.

However, for some club, it could make a great investment. A young forward, a pick 2, a bit of development and 30-40 games in him. He hasn't done much at all yet. He wants to go home and there's not much interest. You'll get him for a reasonable pick. You'd back yourselves to get more from him. Natural development, more experience, more development within the club, more strength. Moreover, the improvement from a sound mind. Back home. Not worrying about contracts and his future. He would improve, in sure of that.

A shrewd investment, in my opinion, but not one that we are in a position to make in all likelihood.

We should offer up Battle as a straight swap

 

[Jade Buddha]

We should offer up Battle as a straight swap

No Battle will be much IMO

 

[bennymc7]

Was played in defence a little bit for Sandy iirc

Yeh i remember that as well, though i see him more of the carlisle intercept mould?