List Mgmt. 2020 Trade Thread - Part I

[NeXus Nick]

Hanners is not finished. Get him right for the finals. I don’t understand this post Joffaboy.

CaptainRisky I see you LOL'd and Disliked my post. Could you give your reasons why?

 

[CaptainRisky]

CaptainRisky I see you LOL'd and Disliked my post. Could you give your reasons why?

I just dont see that a bloke with his history is gong to get back this year , if it was another player without history id say maybe a chance but not hanners , poor old Hanners gets a tweek walking to the loo , He is going to struggle even when he comes back next year i think , Like some have said he maybe cooked

 

[NeXus Nick]

I just dont see that a bloke with his history is gong to get back this year , if it was another player without history id say maybe a chance but not hanners , poor old Hanners gets a tweek walking to the loo , He is going to struggle even when he comes back next year i think , Like some have said he maybe cooked

Let him Rehab for 5 weeks and when he is right give him another 2 weeks before he comes back.

 

[CaptainRisky]

Let him Rehab for 5 weeks and when he is right give him another 2 weeks before he comes back.

ok , Snap

 

[NeXus Nick]

ok , Snap

What I am trying to say is don't rush him back. The sole focus should be just to get him ready for finals.

 

[CaptainRisky]

What I am trying to say is don't rush him back. The sole focus should be just to get him ready for finals.

Hamstring tendon surgery has typically resulted in an 8-12 week stint on the sidelines.

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

This is Hanners we are talking about , no chance in hell he will play again this season which is a shame but lets try and get him right for next year

Yeah my post was before surgery was confirmed.

Look forward to seeing him in Round 1 2021 when he hasn't broken his foot after getting p1ssed and falling down some stairs

 

[Joffaboy]

Yeah my post was before surgery was confirmed.

Look forward to seeing him in Round 1 2021 when he hasn't broken his foot after getting p1ssed and falling down some stairs

Can't wait to see see Hanners and Paddy tearing it up again in 2021

 

[Munga]

Hamstring tendon surgery has typically resulted in an 8-12 week stint on the sidelines.

Yeah Rooey missed 12 weeks with it back in 2010. One would think that Hanners would be ever longer.

 

[Murraj1966]

So do we have any confirmed targets yet ala Hill last year?

 

[gringo2011]

Yeah Rooey missed 12 weeks with it back in 2010. One would think that Hanners would be ever longer.

And you are coming off no training so likely to pop another one if not careful.

 

[NeXus Nick]

Hamstring tendon surgery has typically resulted in an 8-12 week stint on the sidelines.

If he is having surgery then I agree, he is cooked for this year.

 

[CarnTheSAINTERS]

id definitely pick up constable for the price. 31 disposals and a goal in your second game with Dangerfield, Selwood, Duncan ect to take disposals off you is pretty good. Was racking up 40+ in the vfl. Dunstan got 25+ once in his first year. Constable got 27 a few times as well. The real question is why isn’t he being picked at Geelong?

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

id definitely pick up constable for the price. 31 disposals and a goal in your second game with Dangerfield, Selwood, Duncan ect to take disposals off you is pretty good. Was racking up 40+ in the vfl. Dunstan got 25+ once in his first year. Constable got 27 a few times as well. The real question is why isn’t he being picked at Geelong?

Constable is playing tonight isn’t he?

Reckon he might be that player that we talk about all year then we target someone out of the blue & Constable returns to the VFL Cats.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[SaintsSeptember]

id definitely pick up constable for the price. 31 disposals and a goal in your second game with Dangerfield, Selwood, Duncan ect to take disposals off you is pretty good. Was racking up 40+ in the vfl. Dunstan got 25+ once in his first year. Constable got 27 a few times as well. The real question is why isn’t he being picked at Geelong?

Slow and poor disposal?

 

[Mstr Strokesman]

What I am trying to say is don't rush him back. The sole focus should be just to get him ready for finals.

Big ask to be 5 weeks out and then first game back have an influence in a final
Dont think we can afford the risk

 

[Sab22]

More likely to see Dunstan play before Hanners

 

[Olliver]

Yeah Rooey missed 12 weeks with it back in 2010. One would think that Hanners would be ever longer.

The rehab processes have come a long way since then. Back then it was still novel. These days it’s a 8-10 week process give or take. Having said that they may decide to be conservative and put a line through him.

And you are coming off no training so likely to pop another one if not careful.

As a reference point, Freezer was in full training at 7 weeks and returned at 9 in 2018.

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

The only knock on Caldwell, is that he can sortve just bomb the ball rather than lower the eyes. Has cost them a few goals the past few weeks. Trying to do too much with it

sounds like a contradiction in terms. Doing too much would be trying to pin point passes in traffic and turning it over. This can be trained out though and if it wasn't an issue in his draft year then he's probably still just getting used to the pace of the game

 

[Joffaboy]

More likely to see Dunstan play before Hanners

More likely to see Brad Crouch play for us before Hanners

 

[Xxxx66]

Slow and poor disposal?

First afl game I have seen of Charlie's. Good size Looked slowish with average disposal.
Then again, not a great night for footy

 

[NeXus Nick]

More likely to see Brad Crouch play for us before Hanners

If we get Brad Crouch as a FA then that is a big win for us.

 

[austinnn]

What's our plan to replace Carlisle who will be 29 next season?

What about someone like Elliott Himmelberg from Adelaide?

Has played mostly forward and not getting a huge go at the Crows but is only 22yo and is 198cm tall, big body, pretty agile, can take a mark and could be worth a try down back and played there in his junior career

Contract finishes at the end of the year and would not cost much

Thoughts?

Oscar Clavarino is the key!

 

[jwikked]

Let him Rehab for 5 weeks and when he is right give him another 2 weeks before he comes back.

How many times did we try that in 2019 only for him to keep doing his hammies? He was never rushed back, ever. With plenty of precautions on his return.
It’s not the injury management, it’s the player.
It’s unfortunate, but his hamstrings just can’t handle AFL footy anymore.

 

[jwikked]

id definitely pick up constable for the price. 31 disposals and a goal in your second game with Dangerfield, Selwood, Duncan ect to take disposals off you is pretty good. Was racking up 40+ in the vfl. Dunstan got 25+ once in his first year. Constable got 27 a few times as well. The real question is why isn’t he being picked at Geelong?

I’d pass on Constable. He wasn’t interested in a trade involving Jack Steven last year but now he still can’t break into the team he wants a lifeline? Yeah, I don’t think so.