List Mgmt. 2020 Trade Thread - Part III

StCicatriz · Nov 12, 2020

bird_man said:
From memory Gags did at the time was suggest we need a replacement for Robbo who went down.

Toce was the SA talent manager at the time and he and Libba were both in contact with Wilkie.

Gallagher was a few weeks into his role fresh out of a banking job in Melbourne so I'm not sure he can claim that one?

Anyway, we can't expect to continually bring in quality recruits and also keep everyone we've drafted in the 50's and 60's.

When you start to build a strong list and is going to push a few out.

Liberatore seems to have done well with what he's had. He apparently unofficially took the reigns in the 2017 draft when he was the Vic manager. He aced that draft and has managed to bring in some pretty good talent since despite having a weak draft hand.

Thats a very fair comment

bird_man · Nov 12, 2020

I hope Lonie doesn't do a Newnes and find a home after trade period and asked to be delisted.

LiterallyNobody · Nov 12, 2020

StCicatriz said:
Hope i don't come off too negative. I think its been another excellent trade period. Probably a good thing we get a bit more stability with less players coming in. Also good to get some draft action again.

Much rather get the big trades right like crouch than the minor stuff like hind

I dont think you have at all. Not everyone will be happy with everything the club does all the time. That’s life.
I think that what we haven’t done this trade period is almost as important as what we did do. Our future picks for next year all intact (apart from round two but big deal) and we have a good chance to aim for a big catch next season.

Armoooo · Nov 12, 2020

A little bit of an idea of our depth chart. Looking decent.

FB:	Paton	Howard	Wilkie
	Geary	Frawley	Webster
HB:	Clark	Carlisle	Coffield
	Savage	Clavarino	Roberton
C:	Hill	Ross	Jones
	Philips	Byrnes	Sinclair
HF:	Billings	Marshall	Gresham
	Kent	McKernan
FF:	Membrey	King	Butler
	Marsh		Lonie
R:	Ryder	Steele	Crouch
	Alabakis	Dunstan	Bytel
I/C (From):	Battle	Long	Hannebery	Higgins
	Joyce		Connolly

Mstr Strokesman · Nov 12, 2020

2ballz said:
Should get into Darcy Moore

30

Darcy Moore

Age
28

Ht

203cm

Wt
100kg

Pos.
Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D
11.1

3

K
7.0

3

HB
4.1

3

M
4.8

5

T
1.6

4

MG
169.1

3

D
13.9

3

K
7.3

3

HB
6.6

4

M
4.9

5

T
0.7

1

MG
182.0

3

D
6.8

2

K
4.2

2

HB
2.6

3

M
2.6

3

T
1.8

4

MG
87.4

2

's ear about coming across next year if he wants to jump off the burning ship at Collingwood

Probably on 1.2 million, maybe they can pay some of his wage too

Ads734 said:
We should be eyeing of some fringe doggie players they are going to stacked this year.
could pry one out next year

Ed Richards anyone ?

Magnifisaints · Nov 12, 2020

XhazzafootyX · Nov 12, 2020

Will Savage get a contract extension?

Ricochet · Nov 12, 2020

Who are the player that went in them picks

scotteydog · Nov 12, 2020

When you look at the year 2020. You see list improvement's from Battle, Butler, Clark, Coffield, Howard, King, Long, Marshall again, Paton, Ryder, Steele. If we can get hopeful improvements out of Billings doesn't fade out, Brynes, Bytel, Clavarino, Connolly, Hannebery stays on the park, Hill, Jones. Add Crouch, Gresham, Higgins & Webster, Geez, top 4 must be a possibility, yeah. And yes, I still believe Webster could be in our best 22.

Armoooo · Nov 12, 2020

jwikked said:
The afl are a joke of an organization. Well done to Gil for organizing a competition this year, but he is running a circus in all other aspects.

If there were to be another trade period I think Collingwood would be within their rights for major compensation. Dishing out a fire sale before they had the info needed to make informed decisions.

Ricochet · Nov 12, 2020

XhazzafootyX said:
Will Savage get a contract extension?

I think we have moved passed him so I hope not

OxSaint · Nov 12, 2020

Jay Beast said:
Love Nick Cox. Absolutely want!

He looks pretty special in his highlight reel. Bit of Harris Andrew’s about him

Dard Ball Get · Nov 12, 2020

The girlfriend is fine with me playing the Ned Guy interview during bedroom time, what a day

The_Steadier · Nov 12, 2020

I wouldn't be too disappointed on missing Treloar.

Sounds like the dogs are paying him 800k+ x 5.

"Collingwood will pay a small amount of Treloar's salary. The Dogs had asked for $1.5 million to be paid over the next five years of the life of his $900,000 a year contract. While the Magpies will pay a something of his contract it is not in that range."

Magpies fire sale sends Treloar to the Dogs

Collingwood delivered one of the biggest fire sales in AFL history, jettisoning three players and more than $2 million in their salary cap next year as they secured last-minute deals that saw star players move clubs.

www.theage.com.au

We could be confident of landing a much better fit (and less injury concerned player) than Treloar like dunkley, kelly or merrett with 800k x 5 next year.

ihaveacrushonratts · Nov 12, 2020

sammm said:
where is the article that says Carlisle for 1 year with a trigger of a 2nd?

Not official but Lethers said he has signed with trigger for 2nd

FootyMaster11 · Nov 12, 2020

Is anyone able to post the summary of what we got compared to what we gave up in this trade period, I have spent time trying to find it but I couldn’t and would like to reference it to my mates

Armoooo · Nov 12, 2020

Ricochet said:
Who are the player that went in them picks

Jacob Hopper, Griffen Logue, Ely Smith and Mitch Georgiades.

Honestly, the years of service they got from Treloar alone looks enough to make this whole exchange look ok.

They also got Side, a couple of picks in the 40s and the picks they got tonight.

If you look at the best players they COULD have taken with those picks it gets a lot uglier. But pick for pick, they haven't missed much.

Armoooo · Nov 12, 2020

FootyMaster11 said:
Is anyone able to post the summary of what we got compared to what we gave up in this trade period, I have spent time trying to find it but I couldn’t and would like to reference it to my mates

Signed Crouch and McKernan as Free Agents

Traded Pick 17 and a 2021 2nd for Higgins and a 2021 4th

Hind and Pick 77 for Pick 67 and Pick 74

In:
Crouch
Higgins
McKernan
Pick 21
Pick 67
Pick 74
2021 4th (Rich)

Out:
Hind
Pick 17
Pick 77
2021 2nd

Solid B+ effort IMO.

Snag a big fish next season and I would retrospectively upgrade the rating as one of the intangibles we achieved is flexibility going into next season's transfer markets.

Jezzarayman · Nov 12, 2020

FootyMaster11 said:
Is anyone able to post the summary of what we got compared to what we gave up in this trade period, I have spent time trying to find it but I couldn’t and would like to reference it to my mates

hrs

Who left: Nick Hind

Who arrived: Brad Crouch, Shaun McKernan, Jack Higgins

2020 NAB AFL Draft picks: 21, 64, 67, 74, 93

Future picks: St Kilda gave its future second-round selection to Richmond as part of a deal that saw it secure Higgins, but also received a future fourth-round pick in return.

We say: St Kilda is again one of the big winners from the Trade Period. It bolstered its midfield by luring Crouch as a free agent, secured key position depth by signing McKernan, and added a key part of its future through a trade for Higgins. Although the Saints were forced to slide down the draft order to pick No.21 to secure Higgins, they kept their first-round draft choice – something the club had previously described as a "non-negotiable" during the Trade Period. Look out for the Saints in 2021. - Riley Beveridge

Grade: 9/10 (ranked 2nd)

Mstr Strokesman · Nov 12, 2020

Armoooo said:
A little bit of an idea of our depth chart. Looking decent.

FB: Paton Howard Wilkie
Geary Frawley Webster
HB: Clark Carlisle Coffield
Savage Clavarino Roberton
C: Hill Ross Jones
Philips Byrnes Sinclair
HF: Billings Marshall Gresham
Kent McKernan
FF: Membrey King Butler
Marsh Lonie
R: Ryder Steele Crouch
Alabakis Dunstan Bytel
I/C (From): Battle Long Hannebery Higgins
Joyce Connolly

McKenzie ?

scotteydog · Nov 12, 2020

Jezzarayman said:
hrs

Who left: Nick Hind

19

Nick Hind

Age
30

Ht

180cm

Wt
78kg

Pos.
D/F

Career

Season

Last 5

D
10.7

3

K
7.2

3

HB
3.5

3

M
2.0

2

T
1.9

4

MG
117.0

2

D
9.5

2

K
4.0

1

HB
5.5

3

M
2.0

2

T
2.0

3

MG
117.0

2

D
10.2

3

K
7.2

3

HB
3.0

3

M
2.0

3

T
2.2

4

Who arrived: Brad Crouch

5

Brad Crouch

Age
30

Ht

186cm

Wt
86kg

Pos.
Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D
26.1

5

K
12.1

4

HB
14.0

5

M
2.7

3

T
5.5

5

CL
5.0

5

D
20.3

5

K
11.1

4

HB
9.1

5

M
1.5

2

T
3.9

5

CL
4.6

5

D
21.6

5

K
10.0

4

HB
11.6

5

M
3.4

4

T
4.2

5

CL
2.6

5

, Shaun McKernan

27

Shaun Mckernan

Age
34

Ht

196cm

Wt
100kg

Pos.
F/R

Career

Season

Last 5

D
13.0

3

K
8.3

3

HB
4.7

3

M
4.5

4

T
1.8

4

G
1.0

4

D
8.4

2

K
5.6

2

HB
2.8

2

M
3.6

4

T
1.6

3

G
1.0

4

D
17.0

5

K
8.2

4

HB
8.8

5

M
3.6

4

T
1.2

3

G
0.2

3

, Jack Higgins

2020 NAB AFL Draft picks: 21, 64, 67, 74, 93

Future picks: St Kilda gave its future second-round selection to Richmond as part of a deal that saw it secure Higgins, but also received a future fourth-round pick in return.

We say: St Kilda is again one of the big winners from the Trade Period. It bolstered its midfield by luring Crouch as a free agent, secured key position depth by signing McKernan, and added a key part of its future through a trade for Higgins. Although the Saints were forced to slide down the draft order to pick No.21 to secure Higgins, they kept their first-round draft choice – something the club had previously described as a "non-negotiable" during the Trade Period. Look out for the Saints in 2021. - Riley Beveridge

Grade: 9/10 (ranked 2nd)

Who we didn't get: Caldwell & Treloar, oh well.

Mindtraveller · Nov 12, 2020

I hope we oppose the extra trade period. Can't support incompetence

AFLOnline · Nov 12, 2020

We traded hind for that little? i mean, he was never a superstar... but watch him shine off a back flank for the bombers now...

StCicatriz · Nov 12, 2020

Dard Ball Get said:
The girlfriend is fine with me playing the Ned Guy interview during bedroom time, what a day

Got a link? Might have to watch this infamous interview

StCicatriz · Nov 12, 2020

scotteydog said:
Who we didn't get: Caldwell & Treloar, oh well.

If I go over the best 22 its hard to fit Caldwell in now even if we did get him

List Mgmt. 2020 Trade Thread - Part III

Brownlow Medallist

Hall of Famer

Cancelled due to poster being a Campaigner

Club Legend

Club Legend

Debutant

Norm Smith Medallist

Team Captain

Cancelled

Club Legend

Team Captain

Club Legend

Premium Platinum

Brownlow Medallist

Rookie

Senior List

Club Legend

Club Legend

All Australian

Club Legend

Cancelled

Premium Gold

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Similar threads

Log In or Create New Account