List Mgmt. 2022 Trade Thread - Part II

[gringo2011]

We could win the flag and some people will have an issue with not winning it be enough or the trophy wasn't fuxking shiny enough.....

On SM-F711B using BigFooty.com mobile app

Good rational post. You tell the campaigners.

 

[Joffaboy]

He'd be better than most of our fringe players and come cheap. I reckon he's a bit of a Mitch Robinson, he's a team lifter. He's a GOP like DMac is.

He is shit.

 

[Diehard Saint]

I was also referring to De Goey and no just Hartigan.

Pretty sure most on here would be very happy to get De Goey.

TBH, right at the beginning when the idea was first floated, I wasn’t keen (reputation etc) but it’s amazing what two failed seasons will do to your principles

 

[Dard Ball Get]

Foofer valve you silly inbred sandgroping ne'er do well

A bit camp for mine

 

[PandaG]

He is s**t.

I disagree
Better player than Long with his hands and kicks goals. Also is tough and shows aggression. We lack that aggression all over the field.
He is also much better than Zak Jones

 

[Joffaboy]

They'll win a flag and you'll say it was all luck and their academy kids blah blah. They are the Melbourne Storm of the AFL, they get most s**t right. It's like comparing BHP Billiton to a guy who concretes backyards. You can show a few we got that look alright but they have missed finals couple of times in 20 years. We wobbled into one finals series in the last 10 years when everyone else was asleep. It's actually comical that you want to compare our "success" to theirs.

Chad Warner is 21 and looks a future superstar player. We got King in that range of young star class but we didn't get him with pick 39. King's about the only one in a long time too.

Again an answer to a post that is something completely different.

Can't argue with the points so quotes it and talks about something else.

So Warner at 39 makes them great but nothing for Battle @ 39.
Put in the academy gifts they have got and we would be in the finals as well.

Heeney and Mills for SFA. Yeah great recruiting. Pfft.

 

[jwikked]

We could win the flag and some people will have an issue with not winning it be enough or the trophy wasn't fuxking shiny enough.....

On SM-F711B using BigFooty.com mobile app

We could? Why don't we?

 

[jwikked]

Again an answer to a post that is something completely different.

Can't argue with the points so quotes it and talks about something else.

So Warner at 39 makes them great but nothing for Battle @ 39.
Put in the academy gifts they have got and we would be in the finals as well.

Heeney and Mills for SFA. Yeah great recruiting. Pfft.

You make a great point. Our recruiting is clearly as good as Sydney's is.

 

[Joffaboy]

A bit camp for mine

Right up your alley

 

[Diehard Saint]

This is dead set, the most moronic post I've seen for a while. Absolute horse s**t.

Would you say the same thing on Scott pendlebury who was the same at that age? What about Shaun Burgoyne who was never had a "chiselled" rig.....

Alot of players don't look like Jack Bytel, shredded to the ****. Alot of people bodies don't develop that way....

Actually get some knowledge about human biology before saying stupid s**t like that, absolute figgen ignorance....

On SM-F711B using BigFooty.com mobile app

Well, Muscles Curren sure looked the part….and look how many games he played…

 

[gringo2011]

Foofer valve you silly inbred sandgroping ne'er do well

You obviously haven't smelt him, I thing DBG was right.

 

[gringo2011]

He is s**t.

I reckon he's been very good in the seniors recently. He is behind others but he look okay at the Saints.

 

[Joffaboy]

You make a great point. Our recruiting is clearly as good as Sydney's is.

No it is not but we don't get the freely legups and not everything we do is as bad as the hysterics constantly whine about.

Out of any I mentioned above who was bad recruiting?

 

[Joffaboy]

I reckon he's been very good in the seniors recently. He is behind others but he look okay at the Saints.

Would be a worse trade than getting McKernan for free.

 

[gringo2011]

Again an answer to a post that is something completely different.

Can't argue with the points so quotes it and talks about something else.

So Warner at 39 makes them great but nothing for Battle @ 39.
Put in the academy gifts they have got and we would be in the finals as well.

Heeney and Mills for SFA. Yeah great recruiting. Pfft.

Battle is a good player and came on heaps but Warner looks like his ceiling is huge, like top 10 AFL mid type. At 21 he's already close. Andy Brayshaw type of gun kid.

 

[gringo2011]

Would be a worse trade than getting McKernan for free.

Okay.

 

[stavro#4]

Pretty sure most on here would be very happy to get De Goey.

TBH, right at the beginning when they idea was floated, I wasn’t keen (reputation etc) but it’s amazing what two failed seasons will do to your principles

But that’s my point.

Everyone is unhappy with one thing or another.

Unless you are gringo. He is just unhappy at everything

Let’s just let this play out. Emotionally check out of loving the individuals and see what happens.

Clark goes. Who cares.
Long heads North. Smell ya later.
Hill wants to go play under the safety of Clarko. Drive him there.

Honestly. It’s such a better feeling for your mental health this way.

 

[gubby88]

But that’s my point.

Everyone is unhappy with one thing or another.

Unless you are gringo. He is just unhappy at everything

Let’s just let this play out. Emotionally check out of loving the individuals and see what happens.

Clark goes. Who cares.
Long heads North. Smell ya later.
Hill wants to go play under the safety of Clarko. Drive him there.

Honestly. It’s such a better feeling for your mental health this way.

I'm with you on that.
I want the saints to win a flag, but pissing and moaning about absolutely EVERYTHING in the last 30 years??

Bloody hell, give it a rest....

If it's that bad, don't bloody bother...

On SM-F711B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Veer Right]

I've only been here a few weeks, but yeah, keep that one going lol

Might need to veer left there

On SM-F711B using BigFooty.com mobile app

It's good you can at least throw a lol in there. No reason to get angry at other peoples opinions on here because at the end of the day that's all they are.

I have come to the conclusion that on one side we have the rose coloured glasses crowd and club apologists and the other side, we have the keep the club accountable, over the same old, same old the club keeps dishing up.

I can see why there is angst.

 

[gringo2011]

But that’s my point.

Everyone is unhappy with one thing or another.

Unless you are gringo. He is just unhappy at everything

Let’s just let this play out. Emotionally check out of loving the individuals and see what happens.

Clark goes. Who cares.
Long heads North. Smell ya later.
Hill wants to go play under the safety of Clarko. Drive him there.

Honestly. It’s such a better feeling for your mental health this way.

We never had success to fall back on so only had the players to love. If you don't have success or the players we don't have anything. The club has a real identity crisis these days. It's like a neglected business that is running itself down.

They had better turn things around soon. Most of us are sick of waiting and there isn't much light ahead in the near future.

 

[Diehard Saint]

But that’s my point.

Everyone is unhappy with one thing or another.

Unless you are gringo. He is just unhappy at everything

Let’s just let this play out. Emotionally check out of loving the individuals and see what happens.

Clark goes. Who cares.
Long heads North. Smell ya later.
Hill wants to go play under the safety of Clarko. Drive him there.

Honestly. It’s such a better feeling for your mental health this way.

Especially considering it’s RUOK day.
I‘m a little worried for some of our posters on here the past few days.

True though, I’m not letting myself get emotionally attached to any player any more if I can help it….except maybe King.

 

[Rors]

Again an answer to a post that is something completely different.

Can't argue with the points so quotes it and talks about something else.

So Warner at 39 makes them great but nothing for Battle @ 39.
Put in the academy gifts they have got and we would be in the finals as well.

Heeney and Mills for SFA. Yeah great recruiting. Pfft.

Why stop at Heeney & Mills?

Pick 9 - Nick Blakey
Pick 5 - Brayden Campbell
Pick 32 - Errol Gulden

That’s 5 players - pretty much a quarter of their weekly 22

What shits me the most is that now no other club can achieve this level of elite-pick freebies with the new Drafting rules around Academy players

 

[JediSaint]

5 + 7 + 25 + 33

long + Clark + future 1st

Clark is worth 5 our future first will most likely be top 10 in a draft recruiters already love so 7 is like for like Plus we need some sugar for trading out of next years so 33. Long is worth 25 alone so that’s about right otherwise jog on.

There are so many possibilities how this could go. I’m hoping it’s your way.

 

[gringo2011]

Why stop at Heeney & Mills?

Pick 9 - Nick Blakey
Pick 5 - Brayden Campbell
Pick 32 - Errol Gulden

That’s 5 players - pretty much a quarter of their weekly 22

What shits me the most is that now no other club can achieve this level of elite-pick freebies with the new Drafting rules around Academy players

Bulldogs got a couple of freebies recently.

 

[BrutThough]

I’d be pushing for 25 from GC threatening them that we would be happy to lose him for nothing to north.

I reckon they would laugh at that and let North have Long.