List Mgmt. 2023 Trade Thread - Part III

[George]

The embedded resources below are kept up to date by the trade board mods (as much as possible – we are human after all). Enjoy!

Spoiler: 2023 Draft Order

Spoiler: 2024 Draft Order, aka Future Picks

Spoiler: Blue Tick Rumours

Courtesy of Lore

 

[sunny3193]

It's official:

The details of the deal are:


Carlton receives
Future third-round pick (tied to Essendon), future fourth-round pick (tied to Western Bulldogs), future fourth-round pick (tied to Fremantle)
Carlton gives up
Paddy Dow, future third-round pick, future fourth-round pick


Essendon receives
Pick 35, future fourth-round pick (tied to Carlton)
Essendon gives up
Pick 52, future third-round pick


St Kilda receives
Paddy Dow, Pick 40, future third-round pick (tied to Carlton)
St Kilda gives up
Nick Coffield, Pick 35, Pick 56, future fourth-round pick (tied to Fremantle)


Western Bulldogs receive
Nick Coffield, Pick 52, Pick 56
Western Bulldogs give up
Pick 40, future-fourth round pick

Former top-10 picks on the move in four-club trade

Paddy Dow and Nick Coffield have joined the Saints and Bulldogs as part of a four-club deal

www.afl.com.au

Tell you what, I’m going to ride that future third all next season.
Whoa, babe!

 

[Banger9798]

I'm rapt with Dow, I think he is well worth what we've given. It takes some players a bit longer to find their feet, but he was very good in the games I saw.
Welcome Paddy, it's OK , you're a Sainter now.

And seeya Coff....all the best and everything....when we play against you, I know we can count on you for a few short steps when the heat is on..(we always could)

 

[hangdog]

The bleating over Coffield (who wanted to leave) and some ratshit picks at the arse end of the draft is mildly ridiculous.

Pick 50-odd might be a superstar, or more likely a bloke who plays 0-40 games then gets delisted.

Coffield hasn’t played in two years.

With our midfield needs, I’d rather have Dow, frankly.

I'm still upset. We blew a chance to recruit Lewis Pierce 2.0

 

[saintmike65]

Well we offered a one year contract, think Dogs offered 3? Basically said off you go.

The guy had 3 separate injuries this year…also hasn’t played senior footy for 2 years
I wouldn’t have thought you’d offer more than 1 year if you were SOS!

 

[sammm]

Focus on what is important.

We lack mids who can actually win clearances.


Whereas we have two of the best HBFs in the AFL in Sinclair and Nas who Coffield would only be a back up to.

So we gain a first 22 player that fills a need, and lose a Sandy player who would have been depth. Plus some loss in later pick value, though with the plus of more value the likely stronger 2024 draft.

Given our strengths and weaknesses, it sounds like a win to me.

We tried Coffield as a mid and it didn't work.

 

[kernelT]

Dow trade not official until 3pm tomorrow.

What the heck is there to review it looks fairly even?

Hopefully they give Essendon the arse.

Dogs lose 40, gain Coffield
Saints lose Coffield, gain Dow
Blues lose Dow, gain 40

Why does it have to be any harder than that?

**** giving Essendon a leg-up.

 

[sunny3193]

Dow trade not official until 3pm tomorrow.

Harry Strang has been rumbled and the Stewards have called for an inquiry.

 

[Minga]

Ginnivan definitely gives me Stephenson vibes, would not be surprised to see him sink if he goes to a non-competitive club, just like Jaidyn has. People forget he was a star.

 

[PostmanBish]

I want to run him over with a Golf Kart

Can go any win tally …

 

[goodie23]

So to look at the whole board for the Saints at the moment - the ishes indicate the yoyo effect of the draft bidding system

In​	Out​
Liam Henry	Gresham
Paddy Dow	Coffield
Pick 21(ish)	Pick 35(ish)
Pick 40(ish)	Pick 56(ish)
Future 3rd (Carlton)	Future 2nd (ours)
	Future 4th (ours)

 

[kernelT]

I'm still upset. We blew a chance to recruit Lewis Pierce 2.0

He's still on the list I think.

 

[stavro#4]

Twomey on Shiel - just a watch at this point. There is a pulse for a trade in the dying hours tomorrow. It wasn’t up for grabs, it looked like it was over. But there is still a little bit of movement behind the scenes. Might be 10% might be 15% - but just keep a watch on that.

2 years left on his deal

 

[Saintos The ITK]

We still haven’t got the player we want.
We’re not accumulating picks go get some goppy in a shit draft.

 

[Remboy]

WRONG!

Our draft hand is set in stone now and I’ll tell you what, it’s very negative. Next year is already a bust and I don’t know why I bother with this mob!

That’s it, I’m barracking for the bombers! Just got my Dylan Shiel fridge magnet.

 

[BrotherofChunk]

Ross post elimination final presser:
" we need midfield support - we'll be active through the mechanisms available, draft, trade and FA"

4 weeks later:
Club brings in a genuine inside mid and an exciting wingman with pace something we lacked as whitfield and co cut us to pieces.

bigfooty users:
"but we let go a guy who hadn't played in years who when fit was behind an AA HBF and a back 6 22 under 22 member"

thats enough internet for me today.

 

[kernelT]

Twomey on Shiel - just a watch at this point. There is a pulse for a trade in the dying hours tomorrow. It wasn’t up for grabs, it looked like it was over. But there is still a little bit of movement behind the scenes. Might be 10% might be 15% - but just keep a watch on that.

2 years left on his deal

Dons can have 21 & 40
We eat their celery dump & take pick 9

 

[Remboy]

Twomey on Shiel - just a watch at this point. There is a pulse for a trade in the dying hours tomorrow. It wasn’t up for grabs, it looked like it was over. But there is still a little bit of movement behind the scenes. Might be 10% might be 15% - but just keep a watch on that.

2 years left on his deal

Not sure how that would look to Coff if we offered him one year because of injuries but give Shiel two while knowing he missed half of this year and won’t be training fully before Christmas.
But the list is a work in progress and we need mids.

 

[Saintos The ITK]

I'm rapt with Dow, I think he is well worth what we've given. It takes some players a bit longer to find their feet, but he was very good in the games I saw.
Welcome Paddy, it's OK , you're a Sainter now.

And seeya Coff....all the best and everything....when we play against you, I know we can count on you for a few short steps when the heat is on..(we always could)

Plus the old saying.
Everyone looks better in Saints colours.

 

[Mowman]

Dons can have 21 & 40
We eat their celery dump & take pick 9

How about we give them nothing and they keep Shiel

 

[Air King]

That’s it, I’m barracking for the bombers! Just got my Dylan Shiel fridge magnet.

 

[hangdog]

Assuming same finishing positions in 2024 and not accounting for 2023 picks moving around after academy/FS bids.



Basically values the trade to be

Coffield + Pick 59 = Dow

 

[PoppedCorn]

Calm down…likely wouldn’t have been used anyway

Stop assuming I need to calm down

 

[triggering bro]

Dow trade not official until 3pm tomorrow.

This has Dodoro’s dirty work written all over over it and the AFL are onto it.

 

[Coconut_twirl]

Pfft

13 21 and 40lol

Hopefully something else is happening because that's * all when you've been barking on about going to the draft for over 4 weeks

I love the trade melts. I always love the trade melts.

 

[Coconut_twirl]

So we have handed over 56 as well

Fmd

A pick that won’t get used this year. So what.