List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading Part 2

[1970crow]

Mate, seriously what have you got against Tex? It’s quite blatant and a little disturbing.

I have asked before and you never responded. Most fans see him as an all time great, leading club goal scorer, heart and soul of the club, one of the most exquisitely skilled big men in the modern era. In the conversation as a top 5 player of all time for us.

What’s your issue with him?

What happened to our club the last few years under his and Sloane's leadership. I don't think either are anywhere near the 'club first' people espoused by the media/fans. And there's the continuing support of out of form senior buddies ahead of giving in form kids a crack that sits poorly with me. I think the club will be much better off as soon as Tex, Sloane, Smith and Laird are gone from the club. I cannot fathom how supporters can look at the toxic playing culture that developed and not apply any responsibility to the very clear and obvious leaders of the day.

 

[1970crow]

Isn’t that what Greenwood did?

Exactly that, just signed a deal with Roos and that was that. No rookie draft needed.

 

[Vader]

Agreed. Burgess and Shoey are the obvious 2 (doubtful Smith with his longevity and standing with the club historically)

They did it to Mackay, so longevity & standing don't really come into it.

 

[119others]

They did it to Mackay, so longevity & standing don't really come into it.

Ok will be interesting to watch. Mackay was never in the leadership group so perhaps a little different to Smith (and Sloane previously).

It certainty wouldn’t bother me if it was Smith

 

[Dangarman]

Guy on the ABC blog just posted this:

Bolton fun fact! Shai becomes the first Docker to have a dad that also played for the Dockers. Darren played 2 games in 99. Freo's only player taken through the F/S system was Brett Peake

Brett Peake

Age

41

Ht

186cm

Wt

86kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

16.1

4star

K

9.3

4star

HB

6.8

4star

M

4.1

4star

T

2.4

4star

CL

1.3

3star

No current season stats available

D

10.6

3star

K

7.0

3star

HB

3.6

3star

M

3.0

3star

T

1.2

3star

whos dad Brian played 296 games for East Fremantle and was eligible under the concession given to the Dockers when they entered the league. Go well Shai!

Have the Crows had a player's son line up in the tri-colours yet? I know we had a Jarman Jr. on the list, but I'm pretty sure he never played an AFL game.
I guess Welsh will be the first if/when he gets an AFL call up.

 

[crow2crow]

Guy on the ABC blog just posted this:

Bolton fun fact! Shai becomes the first Docker to have a dad that also played for the Dockers. Darren played 2 games in 99. Freo's only player taken through the F/S system was Brett Peake whos dad Brian played 296 games for East Fremantle and was eligible under the concession given to the Dockers when they entered the league. Go well Shai!

Have the Crows had a player's son line up in the tri-colours yet? I know we had a Jarman Jr. on the list, but I'm pretty sure he never played an AFL game.
I guess Welsh will be the first if/when he gets an AFL call up.

welsh would be first

 

[George Kramer]

Guy on the ABC blog just posted this:

Bolton fun fact! Shai becomes the first Docker to have a dad that also played for the Dockers. Darren played 2 games in 99. Freo's only player taken through the F/S system was Brett Peake whos dad Brian played 296 games for East Fremantle and was eligible under the concession given to the Dockers when they entered the league. Go well Shai!

Have the Crows had a player's son line up in the tri-colours yet? I know we had a Jarman Jr. on the list, but I'm pretty sure he never played an AFL game.
I guess Welsh will be the first if/when he gets an AFL call up.

Jimmy Rowe!

 

[crows dude]

Guy on the ABC blog just posted this:

Bolton fun fact! Shai becomes the first Docker to have a dad that also played for the Dockers. Darren played 2 games in 99. Freo's only player taken through the F/S system was Brett Peake whos dad Brian played 296 games for East Fremantle and was eligible under the concession given to the Dockers when they entered the league. Go well Shai!

Have the Crows had a player's son line up in the tri-colours yet? I know we had a Jarman Jr. on the list, but I'm pretty sure he never played an AFL game.
I guess Welsh will be the first if/when he gets an AFL call up.

Jimmy rowe

 

[crows dude]

welsh would be first

Jimmy Rowe

 

[crow2crow]

Jimmy Rowe!

of course how did i miss that

 

[Hodgy]

What happened to our club the last few years under his and Sloane's leadership. I don't think either are anywhere near the 'club first' people espoused by the media/fans. And there's the continuing support of out of form senior buddies ahead of giving in form kids a crack that sits poorly with me. I think the club will be much better off as soon as Tex, Sloane, Smith and Laird are gone from the club. I cannot fathom how supporters can look at the toxic playing culture that developed and not apply any responsibility to the very clear and obvious leaders of the day.

Or it could just be that we’ve had a crap list because we drafted so disastrously for a decade. I can assure you that Smith and Tex at least are fantastic guys who absolutely love the club. I think you’ll find that if there where any toxic elements of the playing group, they left a few years ago.

 

[Slime Roy]

Who is Justin Reids assistant that looks like Michaelangelo Rucci's love child??

 

[crow2crow]

What happened to our club the last few years under his and Sloane's leadership. I don't think either are anywhere near the 'club first' people espoused by the media/fans. And there's the continuing support of out of form senior buddies ahead of giving in form kids a crack that sits poorly with me. I think the club will be much better off as soon as Tex, Sloane, Smith and Laird are gone from the club. I cannot fathom how supporters can look at the toxic playing culture that developed and not apply any responsibility to the very clear and obvious leaders of the day.

you are really bitter. this is way off the mark my god. you need to find a different team if this is your views...

 

[GreyCrow]

of course how did i miss that

its easy to do so

 

[1990crow]

of course how did i miss that

He wasn't technically a father son though

 

[GreyCrow]

He wasn't technically a father son though

Neither is Bolton

 

[Vader]

He wasn't technically a father son though

That wasn't the question though:

Have the Crows had a player's son line up in the tri-colours yet?

 

[Dangarman]

Jimmy Rowe!

Of course I knew that, I was just testing y'all....

 

[whattagun07]

Feel like Membrey and Jack Hayes will be a couple of good Moneyball options for another club. Seems like St K won't retain them. I can see both being handy additions to a good side or two. Collingwood could be a good option for both really, providing some support for Mihochek

 

[ABAB]

I remember last year and even this year that Welsh was rated highly. what happened? did playing him in the SANFL reserves "hide" is talent by playing him under age against men?

Clearly "celebrated" too hard after kicking 5 in the SANFL Showdown late in the season and struggle in the 2km trial.

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Feel like Membrey and Jack Hayes will be a couple of good Moneyball options for another club. Seems like St K won't retain them. I can see both being handy additions to a good side or two. Collingwood could be a good option for both really, providing some support for Mihochek

Brisbane should be all over Hayes.

 

[George Kramer]

Brisbane should be all over Hayes.

they are grabbing Day

 

[skam85]

you are really bitter. this is way off the mark my god. you need to find a different team if this is your views...

Just because someone has an opinion different to yours, it doesn't warrant the smooth brained "gO suPpORt anOTHeR TeaM" dross.

 

[skam85]

they are grabbing Day

Carpe Diem you might say

 

[GreyCrow]

Carpe Diem you might say