List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading Part 2

[crow2crow]

Smith yes because we could've kept him below his trigger
Burgess has always had a contract for next year. Could pay him out but not sure that's the best signal to send to potential recruits

pay him out hes not AFL
they are keeping him to prop up the sanfl team

 

[Vader]

Current list maths by my calculations means we must delist at least two further senior listed players and move them to the rookie list to make the mandatory three draft picks.

I would guess that we might delist two players, then use our third mandatory draft selection to promote Keane from the rookie list to the senior list. That way we also free up the two rookie list spots needed to re-draft the delisted senior players.

Senior List

OUT:
Sloane (retired)
McHenry (delisted)
Gollant (delisted)
Himmelberg (free agent)
????
????

IN:
Neal-Bullen
Cumming
Peatling
Pick 4
Second draft pick (Welsh F/S?)
Third mandatory draft pick

Rookie List

OUT:
Parnell (delisted)
Hamill (delisted)

IN:
T. Murray
FREE LIST SPOT

If we're not delisting anybody else (i.e. Burgess), then we're down to 1 list management option - move 2 players from the senior list to the rookie list (i.e. delist & re-draft in the RD), and upgrade 1 player from the rookie list (most likely Keane).

There are no other options available to us, unless an unexpected trade pops up in the next week, removing a contracted player from our list.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Can we "Hugh Greenwood" someone?

Delist them with the goal of definitely, totally re-rookieing them when they might have a small amount of interest elsewhere then bank the free draft pick slot when someone else takes them?

I nominate Murphy.

 

[Danger in Texas]

Makes no sense because now there will be so many main list delistings next year

smith
c burgess
schoenberg
strachan
(and probably bond)
gallagher from cat B

Walker, too. I doubt Bond goes at this stage

Someone like Milera could also look for more opportunity

 

[dogs105]

Makes no sense because now there will be so many main list delistings next year

smith
c burgess
schoenberg
strachan
(and probably bond)
gallagher from cat B

Walker going around again?

 

[Scorpus]

I nominate Murphy.

Wouldn't work. No one would take him

 

[rocket18]

I think Laird will be top 5 at the B&F. Maybe even top 3.

The same morons that select our team are the same morons that award BnF votes.

Our head moron thinks Smith is a big part of our future.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Wouldn't work. No one would take him

Can only live in hope...

Port are chasing another small forward.

 

[Crow_68]

Walker, too. I doubt Bond goes at this stage

Someone like Milera could also look for more opportunity

ROB, Milera and Crouch all UFAs, no guarantee we keep any of them.

 

[MrBarry]

We gave Ned a block of games early in the season, I suspect we basically said to him “show us what you’ve got or you’re gone”.

Yeah but I could have told you that years ago, why do we feel need to flog a clearly spent horse to death.

 

[Danger in Texas]

ROB, Milera and Crouch all UFAs, no guarantee we keep any of them.

Yeah I’d hope we push Crouch to look for another club, our 2026 mid rotation should look like Dawson/Rankine/Peatling/Soligo/pick 4

God knows what happens with our ruck situation

 

[MrBarry]

Yeah I’d hope we push Crouch to look for another club, our 2026 mid rotation should look like Dawson/Rankine/Peatling/Soligo/pick 4

God knows what happens with our ruck situation

You'd hope Curtin is in that rotation by then as well.

 

[PeterSalt]

Ouch

 

[Danger in Texas]

You'd hope Curtin is in that rotation by then as well.

Maybe Dawson gradually spends more time on the wing/flanks as Curtin spends more time in the middle

With a full handover by 2028 or so

 

[crow2crow]

Walker, too. I doubt Bond goes at this stage

Someone like Milera could also look for more opportunity

sorry missed walker but yes.
milera hopefully sorts out his body

 

[Danger in Texas]

Ouch

To be fair, Cumming wasn’t available to us

Still makes for unfortunate reading

 

[Danger in Texas]

sorry missed walker but yes.
milera hopefully sorts out his body

I think with Cumming coming in and Ryan on the rise, Milera’s gonna be regulated to just about permanent depth

He’s probably better than that if he gets back to full fitness, so I can see an interstate team or two calling him

 

[Vader]

Yeah but I could have told you that years ago, why do we feel need to flog a clearly spent horse to death.

Congratulations. Would you like a medal, or a chest to pin it on?

 

[1970crow]

We will almost certainly need to dip into our future picks, given that both Peatling & ANB are apparently valued as 2nd round picks.

It's quite conceivable that we could trade our F1 for Peatling + a 2024 1st (or some similar variation), using the 2024 1st on Dodson.

Losing the bulk of 25 for ANB would be criminally poor list management.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Losing the bulk of 25 for ANB would be criminally poor list management.

Think something like #27 & #44 for ANB, #39 & #47.

Should give us enough picks for Welsh.

 

[1970crow]

they realised pretty quickly they had a lemon

didnt get a game when a second ruck was badly needed and preferred EH so i would be suprised if they dont delist him still

I presume he’s been announced among the delistees then?

 

[1970crow]

Nicks

Not Nix particularly, AFC. It’s in our DNA.

 

[1970crow]

We say that every year with Nicks.

Happened under Pyke too.

 

[1970crow]

That doesn't change the fact that he's an ineffectual stat padder.

Surely no one thinks that he would leave a gaping hole in our list if we traded him.

Smallest of holes.

 

[1970crow]

kelly just said no more delistings

like WTF

Ha ha, your campaign against Burgess falls flat. Alll those ha ha’s coming back to bite the egg on your face. I don’t rate him either, but it’s not hard to see that with Berg going and T Murray on 0 preseasons, Burgess was a fair chance to be retained as forward/pinch hit ruck depth.