List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading

Should the AFC offer Taylor Walker a contract for 2025?


  • Total voters
    40
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
I had a look at mccreery's stats. surprisingly very low disposals. Not sure if its greener grass, but just feel he's a pretty effective player per touch. Kicks a few more goals, and tackles more, but gives away heaps of frees

View attachment 1979226
Surprised me last night how few goals Mcreery scores.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I had a look at mccreery's stats. surprisingly very low disposals. Not sure if its greener grass, but just feel he's a pretty effective player per touch. Kicks a few more goals, and tackles more, but gives away heaps of frees

View attachment 1979226

Haven't watched enough of him to fully judge. First impressions is that he plays a deeper forward role. Could be wrong.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Would McCreery be worth having a crack at He has Pace
During the PS ....the story was COLL was priming McCreery to play some midfield time, and use his pace to break open games

I assume, it's still an agenda item with COLL
 
After a few years of pretty poor drafting and recruiting i think our list management team have done well recently other than still not drafting a midfielder with one of our early 1st rd picks they have added some good players that should be a part of the team for the next decade. I felt like they had gained some trust back from supporters and had the list building towards a serious contender but definitely still needing to add 2 top line mids and a good young ruckman. With Welsh joining Fog and Tillthorpe next year they should be the key fwds for the next decade and Murray back soon plus Keane looking good also Curtin Worrel Michaelanny Butts defence looks pretty much sorted so surely its time to try to get a couple of gun mids and a ruckman so we can have a crack at a premiership or three! But hearing the club is talking about trading away 1st rd draft picks for players like Petty, Daniel, Perryman or any other ok players like them is a terrible plan, we already have good solid contributors on the list, what we need are match winners, stars, all Australian calibre players not more pretty good role players, they won't improve the team into a premiership contender they'll just make us a competitive 7-12 on the ladder team and no threat to top teams when it matters, that seems to be the aim for Reid and Ogilvee which is why they have to go asap
 
Not as a KPD medium to longterm ....that's like asking Rankine to play a lockdown role

Defence's win flags ....history shows that .....not sexy, but true

Keane is better suited to the Lever role .....currently Worrell struggles to position himself to leave his man and be the 3rd man up to spoil .....it's a real deficiency in our DEF ......Worrell will improve with more experience, however he's a naturally attacking player .....who could also play fwd, and do a better job than a Petty

Seriously?
 
But hearing the club is talking about trading away 1st rd draft picks for players like Petty, Daniel, Perryman or any other ok players like them is a terrible plan, we already have good solid contributors on the list, what we need are match winners, stars, all Australian calibre players not more pretty good role players, they won't improve the team into a premiership contender they'll just make us a competitive 7-12 on the ladder team and no threat to top teams when it matters, that seems to be the aim for Reid and Ogilvee which is why they have to go asap

Phew, that sentence is a fair effort.

No one has suggested that free agent Perryman will be a first round pick. Daniel will be a salary dump, if anything, so nothing like a first round pick either.

Petty? Well, that will be interesting. It seems like he really wanted to come home, but waiting to free agency probably benefits everyone.
 
Not as a KPD medium to longterm ....that's like asking Rankine to play a lockdown role

Defence's win flags ....history shows that .....not sexy, but true

Keane is better suited to the Lever role .....currently Worrell struggles to position himself to leave his man and be the 3rd man up to spoil .....it's a real deficiency in our DEF ......Worrell will improve with more experience, however he's a naturally attacking player .....who could also play fwd, and do a better job than a Petty

Keane?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top