Rumour 2024 Rumours and Speculation (Rumours total 25, last 28th August)

[Jcpdragonx]

write that in your member survey comments like I did about never wanting to see murphy play again or I expect a phone call

its going to be a laugh when murphy and anb line up together next year

 

[1990crow]

So it’s ANB for McAdam (25 is the pick we got for him).
Sounds like a win

Except McAdam wasn't valued as pick 25 at time of trade. More like 32.
At ANBs age he's worth around 35. Why do they magically just get a 10 pick upgrade because they were shit this year?

 

[George Kramer]

On gettable cal towmey said pick 25 for ANB done deal.....I'm not happy about that.

On SM-S928B using BigFooty.com mobile app

If that’s it’s because we don’t plan on using it and only bringing in pick 4 and Welsh as draftees plus experience and depth which we’ve used an excuse for our shit year and let Nicks off the hook. We are such a shit club.

 

[Draft Bored]

On gettable cal towmey said pick 25 for ANB done deal.....I'm not happy about that.

On SM-S928B using BigFooty.com mobile app

If it's 25 for ANB and 38 coming back, and then we trade Gold Coast (F2 + 38 + 42) for (Luko + 20) I will be fine with that.

4, 20, Luko, ANB with F1 intact is fine by me.

Remember GC won't be able to use 20 and 26 so they're going to have to trade them out.

 

[Barneythecrab]

Living in Portugal sucks during the off season. Hard to keep track. Are we in to Luko still or is he out? ANB I can see is a given. What about Oliver?

Where in Portugal? Working? I used to live in povoa da Santa iria

 

[Scorpus]

its going to be a laugh when murphy and anb line up together next year

Yep.

There were games this year we played five out of Rankine, Rachele, Keays, Murphy, Cook and McHenry

We will make room for Murphy and ANB to line up together

 

[Crow till I die]

If it's 25 for ANB and 38 coming back, and then we trade Gold Coast (F2 + 38 + 42) for (Luko + 20) I will be fine with that.

4, 20, Luko, ANB with F1 intact is fine by me.

Remember GC won't be able to use 20 and 26 so they're going to have to trade them out.

I think you will find that pick 20 might well go in the Rioli deal. I suspect its going to end up like your deal except we won't be getting anything back other than Luko
So it will look like

Crows in: ANB Luko + 38
Out: 25, 42 and F2

Edit. If it did end up like that, I would be fine with it as we maintain our pick 4 and F1 in that scenario and still get a second pick in this draft - maybe that ruck Mutineer was mentioning as Dodson will be long gone by then

 

[crow2crow]

its going to be a laugh when murphy and anb line up together next year

i dread you are right

 

[jackster83]

Surely a future second rounder for ANB is more around the mark?

 

[TBM]

we may still delist strachan and pay him out. he clearly cant be picked at afl level again

Yep, prime candidate who should be paid out early and draft another ruck in with an eye to the future. Very poor list management to have not done this sooner. 29, good SANFL ruck but lacks AFL attributes - doubt he'd be on any other list?

Toby Murray appears to be developing OK, but I imagine he's more of a replacement for Himmelberg than ROB.

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

Jay Clark adamant last night on MMM in Melbourne that Lukosius and Cumming to the Crows. He’s not the first journo to be confident on this either, Sam Edmund and Cal Twomey have said this for a while too. Either they’re all getting fed bad info, or these deals are already a long way down the line.

I reckon Isaac is coming but Luko isn't

 

[GROTTO]

Surely a future second rounder for ANB is more around the mark?

We really need to use this draft and not give up any picks in this draft.

Im all for using future picks in any ANB deal.

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

So it’s ANB for McAdam (25 is the pick we got for him).
Sounds like a win

not really, they're 2 separate trades.

We don't owe melbourne anything just because McAdam stunk it up for them

 

[George Kramer]

Surely a future second rounder for ANB is more around the mark?

They don’t want more young talent, they want more experience. It’s a reaction to our shit year, they want an immediate bounce to limit the noise and they have no eye on the future.

 

[Thrillthorpe7]

Is there a clip of this somewhere?

Not a clip, just his regular segment on JB and Billy towards the end, on any podcast platform

 

[Thrillthorpe7]

Surely a future second rounder for ANB is more around the mark?

Isn’t that basically the same pick anyway? This pick will blow out to 30ish too once all the FS and NGA are added in

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

If that’s it’s because we don’t plan on using it and only bringing in pick 4 and Welsh as draftees plus experience and depth which we’ve used an excuse for our shit year and let Nicks off the hook. We are such a shit club.

even if they don't want to use it at this years draft, we should hold it til draft night and then trade it for future pick.

I can see clubs paying a decent price for it

 

[Mutineer]

cumming luko ANB all make best 22

rosas doesnt

anyway i cant see how we could have the list spots even delisting strachan if bond is staying (although like borlase i believe it when the club announces it)

Wouldn't be too sure about that especially if Rankine plays more midfield, he's not a small forward in the ANB mold, he's an opportunist like Rankine, Papley types when at his best.

 

[Thrillthorpe7]

I reckon Isaac is coming but Luko isn't

The only platform with anyone thinking Luko isn’t coming here is posters on BF, all major journos have maintained it’s the Crows for a fair while now. Anyway, might get more clarity once Port are knocked out.

 

[jackster83]

Isn’t that basically the same pick anyway? This pick will blow out to 30ish too once all the FS and NGA are added in

In terms of pick numbers yes.

This year's pick is probably more valuable in terms of trade currency though. I'm hoping we use it to address the ruck situation.

 

[George Kramer]

In terms of pick numbers yes.

This year's pick is probably more valuable in terms of trade currency though. I'm hoping we use it to address the ruck situation.

It’s easy to do…..

 

[Danger in Texas]

If it's 25 for ANB and 38 coming back, and then we trade Gold Coast (F2 + 38 + 42) for (Luko + 20) I will be fine with that.

4, 20, Luko, ANB with F1 intact is fine by me.

Remember GC won't be able to use 20 and 26 so they're going to have to trade them out.

That Luko deal is highway robbery for us, to be fair

 

[crow2crow]

Isn’t that basically the same pick anyway? This pick will blow out to 30ish too once all the FS and NGA are added in

exactly they're arguing over tictacs

 

[GROTTO]

Surely a future second rounder for ANB is more around the mark?

Im getting a migraine now and the trade period hasnt even begun.

It should have always been a F2.

FFS we bend over happily and take it always.

 

[croweater 41]

Isn’t that basically the same pick anyway? This pick will blow out to 30ish too once all the FS and NGA are added in

Pending where picks matching the bids are coming from but yes likely to blow out a couple.

25 for ANB and one of their 40/50s move on shake hands and call it day.