![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/port_adelaide.png)
Walsh is the absolute perfect guy to have as your 3rd or 4th banana in the midfield. If that's where you are at you are in a very strong position. If he's your 1 or 2 you probably have a very low ceiling
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Semi Finals
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
And yet Walsh stood up as his teams best midfielder through the finals series while Rozee shrank like a Richard in a cold poolWalsh is the absolute perfect guy to have as your 3rd or 4th banana in the midfield. If that's where you are at you are in a very a strong position. If he's your 1 or 2 you probably have a very low ceiling
I know you eagles fans haven't seen a defensive effort for 3-4 years but I wouldnt have thought you'd have forgotten what a tackle is.Weak as piss, and one of the worst kicks in the league.
On top of that he doesn't have a defensive bone in his body.
Massive drop off from last year, and he has been figured out by other clubs.
Will be a vanilla midfielder like Laird and Parish for the rest of his uninspiring career.
Reckon if that draft was done now...He ain't no Rankine,Butters,Daicos,Rozee or Gulden though, i would say walsh now and the other players in 2018 draft (specifically rankine and rozee) have had better careers and are higher rated players in the comp
The day Bobby Hill is rated in the top 5 of his draft is the day the world implodes. Even Owies has kicked more snags than that spud.Reckon if that draft was done now...
1. Butters
2. Rankine
3. B King
4. M King
5. Bobby Hill
6. Rozee
7. Blakey
8. Jordan Clark
9. Briggs
10. Bailey Smith
No Walsh![]()
Bobby Hill gives away more goals than Owies kicks.The day Bobby Hill is rated in the top 5 of his draft is the day the world implodes. Even Owies has kicked more snags than that spud.
Bobby will be satisfied for now having won 100% of the total N Smith medals from that draft yearThe day Bobby Hill is rated in the top 5 of his draft is the day the world implodes. Even Owies has kicked more snags than that spud.
Bobby Hill gives away more goals than Owies kicks.
Oh, and he has a Norm Smith Medal to his name. Not sure Owies has that in him...
The fact Owies is leading him in any important metric is an indictment on Hill.Bobby will be satisfied for now having won 100% of the total N Smith medals from that draft year
Maybe 5 is too low
An accurate reflection of the delusion levels of each supporter base. Pies think a squib is a the GOAT, Blues fans think Walsh is the best player in his draft.It is quite an interesting case study though.
In the Daicos GOAT thread, the conversation leads to discussing players of the ilk of Matthews, Coleman, Bunton, Ablett Snr and Ablett Jnr.
In the Walsh GOAT thread, the conversation leads to discussing Bobby Hill and Matt Owies.
I find Walsh really hard to watch, lurching around out there, running very straight lines, flexing and kicking potatoesIt is quite an interesting case study though.
In the Daicos GOAT thread, the conversation leads to discussing players of the ilk of Matthews, Coleman, Bunton, Ablett Snr and Ablett Jnr.
In the Walsh GOAT thread, the conversation leads to discussing Bobby Hill and Matt Owies.
It hasn't been the Pies fans bringing up Matthews, Coleman, Bunton, etc. in the Daicos GOAT thread.An accurate reflection of the delusion levels of each supporter base. Pies think a squib is a the GOAT, Blues fans think Walsh is the best player in his draft.
Aka, Pies fans are living in fantasy land while Blues fans live in the land of reality.
As I said... Fantasy landIt hasn't been the Pies fans bringing up Matthews, Coleman, Bunton, etc. in the Daicos GOAT thread.
Success breeds success.
I know you are trolling but that list is awfulReckon if that draft was done now...
1. Butters
2. Rankine
3. B King
4. M King
5. Bobby Hill
6. Rozee
7. Blakey
8. Jordan Clark
9. Briggs
10. Bailey Smith
No Walsh![]()
Walsh is the absolute perfect guy to have as your 3rd or 4th banana in the midfield. If that's where you are at you are in a very strong position. If he's your 1 or 2 you probably have a very low ceiling
What a weird conclusion you came to.Walsh isn't good enough to play VFL for Geelong or Collingwood- just ask Mr Meow and the Fudgelator.
Also - only donkeys vote for goats.
Yep. He has no hurt factor. He's a stat plodder and turnover merchant and poor defensively.Weak as piss, and one of the worst kicks in the league.
On top of that he doesn't have a defensive bone in his body.
Massive drop off from last year, and he has been figured out by other clubs.
Will be a vanilla midfielder like Laird and Parish for the rest of his uninspiring career.
Un-intentionallyA lot of his kicks are like bananas...![]()
A bit like with the embarrassment the OP of the Nicky thread should be feeling, something in me just doesnt think either trolls will give a damnThis is funny, as he isn’t in the top three players currently playing at his club.
Nor would he be in the top 20 players in the league.
Yet some pelican thinks he may be the best to play the game ever.
Horrible, horrible call and the OP should be embarrassed.
Except....A bit like with the embarrassment the OP of the Nicky thread should be feeling, something in me just doesnt think either trolls will give a damn
The OP of the Daicos thread is surrounded by equally as blind Nicky sycophants who preach the same drivel as he does.Except....
The OP of the Daicos thread isn't alone when suggesting he's already in the mix as the best current player in the game, less than three years into his career, and tracking to be one of the all time great players.
So no, it's nothing like it.